Chemistry Ideal gas law problem with two cylinders

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around solving an ideal gas law problem involving two cylinders containing hydrogen and helium. The initial calculations suggest that the pressure in cylinder A (hydrogen) is four times that in cylinder B (helium), leading to the conclusion that P1 = 4P2. However, confusion arises from the notation used, particularly with terms like "He mol," which could mislead readers regarding the number of moles versus mass. Clarifications are made regarding the correct molecular weights and the need for clearer variable definitions, such as using "x" for mass. Overall, while the calculations are correct, the notation needs improvement for better understanding.
DottZakapa
Messages
239
Reaction score
17
Homework Statement
There are two cylinders A and B with the same capacity and at the same temperature. If the mass of hydrogen contained in cylinder A is double the mass of helium contained in cylinder B. How does the pressure vary? (Consider the ideal gases)
Relevant Equations
ideal gas law
my answer will be ##P_1=2 P_2## but I have some doubts, if that is correct or not
 
Physics news on Phys.org
That would be correct if both cylinders were filled with the same gas.
 
ok so the reasoning will be:
Concerning H, in the first container, the moles will be given by ## \frac {2 *He (g)} {\text{molar mass of} H_2 \text{(because comes as diatomic molecule} } ##
that is :

## \frac {2*He (g)}{2\frac {g} {mol} } = He\text{ mol } \rightarrow P_1=\frac {He \text{ mol} * R*T}{V} ##

Concerning the second, which contains He :

## \frac {He (g)}{4\frac {g} {mol} } = \frac {He}{4} mol \rightarrow P_2=\frac {He \text{ mol} * R*T}{4V} \rightarrow 4P_2=\frac {He \text{ mol} * R*T}{V}##

concluding, merging everything :

## P_1=4*P_2##

is it how it should be managed ?
 
The answer is correct, but your working is a bit confusing. Is He a variable equal to the number of grams of helium in cylinder 2? Then it is correct that there are He moles of hydrogen in cylinder 1; but the notation is confusing. "He mol" could easily be understood as "the number of moles of He" rather than, as I think is meant, " a number of moles equal to the number of grams of He". Then the pressures would be out by a factor of 4, but the ratio would still be correct. It would be better to use e.g. mHe for the mass of helium - or a variable like x; mass of helium = x g. Then P1 = xRT/V and P2 = xRT/4V.
 
mjc123 said:
The answer is correct, but your working is a bit confusing. Is He a variable equal to the number of grams of helium in cylinder 2? Then it is correct that there are He moles of hydrogen in cylinder 1; but the notation is confusing. "He mol" could easily be understood as "the number of moles of He" rather than, as I think is meant, " a number of moles equal to the number of grams of He". Then the pressures would be out by a factor of 4, but the ratio would still be correct. It would be better to use e.g. mHe for the mass of helium - or a variable like x; mass of helium = x g. Then P1 = xRT/V and P2 = xRT/4V.
The problem says:
"the mass of hydrogen contained in cylinder A is double the mass of helium contained in cylinder B"
so, if :
PV=nRT
where n are the moles of gas.
If n is equal to the mass of the gas divided by the Molecular Mass of the gas, then, knowing that in cylinder A the mass of Hydrogen is twice the mass of Helium, in the above mentioned mass of the gas I should write twice the mass of Helium (g)divided by the Molecular mass of Hydrogen (## \frac g {mol}##).
that is :
##n_a= \frac {H (g)}{H \frac g {mol}}= \frac {2He (g)}{H\frac {g} {mol} } = \frac {2He(g)}{2 \frac g {mol}} ##
This is for cylinder A.
For cylinder B always mass of gas (Helium) divided by molecular mass of Helium.
##n_b= \frac {He (g)}{He \frac g {mol}}= \frac {He (g)}{4\frac {g} {mol} } = \frac {He(g)}{4\frac g {mol}} ##
correct?
 
Your method is correct. It is your notation that I'm concerned about. I don't like "He (g)" for "the mass of helium in grams", because it's potentially confusing, especially when you go on to write "He mol", not meaning "the number of moles of helium". Further confusion is caused by writing H when you should write H2. The molar mass of H is 1 g/mol, not 2. But you don't have H, you have H2. So your calculation is right, but the way you write it is confusing.
 
mjc123 said:
Your method is correct. It is your notation that I'm concerned about. I don't like "He (g)" for "the mass of helium in grams", because it's potentially confusing, especially when you go on to write "He mol", not meaning "the number of moles of helium". Further confusion is caused by writing H when you should write H2. The molar mass of H is 1 g/mol, not 2. But you don't have H, you have H2. So your calculation is right, but the way you write it is confusing.
it was an MCQ, but, just in case I will have it in a written test, would you Kindly explain how should I write? Yes in H it was a typo.
 
Let mass of helium be x g; MW of He = 4. No. of moles helium = x/4. PB = nBRT/V = xRT/4V.
Mass of hydrogen is twice mass of helium = 2x g. MW of H2 = 2. No. of moles hydrogen = 2x/2 =x.
PA = nART/V = xRT/V = 4PB.
 
  • Like
Likes DottZakapa
mjc123 said:
Let mass of helium be x g; MW of He = 4. No. of moles helium = x/4. PB = nBRT/V = xRT/4V.
Mass of hydrogen is twice mass of helium = 2x g. MW of H2 = 2. No. of moles hydrogen = 2x/2 =x.
PA = nART/V = xRT/V = 4PB.
thank you :)
 
Back
Top