Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the feasibility of determining the power consumption of a standing fan using an ohm meter in the context of an AC power supply. Participants explore the relationship between resistance, voltage, current, and power in AC circuits, particularly focusing on the limitations of using an ohm meter for this purpose.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that power can be calculated using the formula P = Voltage x Current, but express uncertainty about its application in AC circuits.
- Others argue that simply multiplying voltage by current does not yield accurate power measurements in AC due to phase differences between voltage and current waveforms.
- One participant explains that the power can be calculated using P = V·I·cos(θ), where θ is the phase difference, and emphasizes the importance of measuring RMS values.
- Another participant asserts that an ohm meter cannot determine the power of the fan, as it only measures resistance and does not account for factors like motor speed and load.
- It is noted that the resistance measured by the ohm meter does not correlate with the power consumed by the motor under normal operating conditions, as it only reflects the resistance when the motor is blocked.
- Some participants highlight that the current drawn by the fan is influenced by the motor's inductance, which complicates the relationship between resistance and power measurement.
- A later reply clarifies that an ohm meter operates in DC, which further limits its usefulness in measuring AC power consumption.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally disagree on the effectiveness of using an ohm meter to measure power in an AC circuit. Multiple competing views remain regarding the relationship between resistance, current, and power in this context.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include the dependence on the motor's rotational speed and load, which are not accounted for in resistance measurements. The discussion also highlights the distinction between DC and AC measurements, which affects the applicability of the ohm meter.