In a cylinder, why do we use just the ground area to get p?

AI Thread Summary
In hydraulic cylinders, the force exerted by the compressed fluid is calculated using the formula F = p * A, where A is the area of the piston. The pressure acts uniformly across all surfaces within the cylinder, but only the piston area contributes to the work done, as it is the surface that displaces against the force. While pressure is present on all surfaces, the relevant area for calculating work is the piston surface because it is directly involved in the movement. As the piston ascends, the pressure decreases due to the increasing volume of the cylinder. Understanding that pressure affects all surfaces but only the piston area does work clarifies the confusion regarding force distribution.
MicroCosmos
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Hi,

given an Hydraulic Cylinder with the Formula:
F=p*A

Why do we use APiston to calculate the Force in Work-Direction? Doesnt it suppose the "Potential Energy" of the compressed air just presses in that Area?

Im pretty confused, sorry about the unconcrete question.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The potential energy of the compressed air is what causes the p in your equation. Can you re-state your question? I am not sure what you are asking.
 
The fact is that a Zylinder is built with 2 circles and 1 rectangle. But when i look for the formula that calculates the Force applied to one of the circles (Like Piston with compressed fluid work) depending on the Pressure, i find everywhere: F=p*ACircle, where A is the Area of that circle. My question is: isn't it wrong? because the pressure schould cause Force in all surfaces, it should distribute among all of them, causing an smaller Force than F=p*ACircle tells me.
 
There is a force pushing against the piston surface that is p(area of the piston surface).

There is a force pushing against the wall of the cylinder that is p(area of the cylinder wall).

It is not an either / or, the pressure presents a force against all surfaces of the interior of the cylinder, and the force against any part of that interior surface is the pressure times the area of interest.

Work is force * displacement, so when calculating work, the relevant area to use is the piston surface, because that is the surface that is involved in doing work, because it is displacing against a force.

As the piston moves up, the p decreases, of course, since the volume of the interior of the cylinder is increasing. This is where you are getting your spring analogy from, I think.
 
  • Like
Likes MicroCosmos
I understand what you mean, i was confused, thanks a lot. I thought the fact that a Force acts in a surface means there is less pressure for the others to hold. That is of course not true.
 
I have Mass A being pulled vertically. I have Mass B on an incline that is pulling Mass A. There is a 2:1 pulley between them. The math I'm using is: FA = MA / 2 = ? t-force MB * SIN(of the incline degree) = ? If MB is greater then FA, it pulls FA up as MB moves down the incline. BUT... If I reverse the 2:1 pulley. Then the math changes to... FA = MA * 2 = ? t-force MB * SIN(of the incline degree) = ? If FA is greater then MB, it pulls MB up the incline as FA moves down. It's confusing...
Back
Top