Hi All;(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

I was trying to understand Lorentz Transformation equation and special theory of relativity, but as I compared the derivation with a thought experiment which I imagined I found the whole Lorentz Transformation Equation fails. The details of the problem is given below. I know I m wrong but I wish you help me to find where I went wrong.

Thought Experiment Details

PLEASE SEE THE FIGURE ATTACHED

Let us consider a spacecraft moving with a velocity v m/s, two observers are there, one inside the spacecraft (observer-1) and other watching spacecraft from earth (observer-2). Two light sources (L1, L2) are emitted inside the spacecraft from point ‘P’ and point ‘A’ simultaneously as shown in figure. After one second (time with respect to observer-2) the spacecraft moves ‘x’ m. Observer-1 measures light source L1 moved a distance ‘a’ and light source L2 a distance ‘b’, but observer-2 measures L1 moved a distance ‘a1’ and L2 a distance ‘b1’.

From ΔABC Lorentz Transformation Equation can be derived;

Ø x = v*t1....................................................................................(1)

Ø a = c*t.......................................................................................(2)

Ø a1 = c*t1...................................................................................(3)

where;

x is the distance travelled by spacecraft in time t1 (t1 is taken as 1 sec for simplicity)

t1 is time w.r.t observer-2

v is velocity of spacecraft

a is distance travelled by L1 in time t as per observer-1

c is speed of light

a1 is the distance travelled by L1 in time t1 as per observer-2

Applying Pythagoras Theorem to ΔABC;

a1^{2}= a^{2}+ x^{2}

(v*t1)^{2}= (c*t)^{2}+ (c*t1)^{2}

─► (c*t)^{2}= (c*t1)^{2}- (v*t1)^{2}

─►t^{2}= t1^{2}(1- v^{2}/c^{2})

t = t1√(1- v^{2}/c^{2})....................................Lorentz Transformation Equation

ConsiderΔPQR;

Since L1 and L2 are emitted at same time the distance travelled by both light will be same after a time interval ‘t’ as measured by observer-1, hence;

a = b

From figure the sides PR = AC

Hence from theΔABC & ΔPQRit is clear that the distance travelled by L1 & L2 measured by observer-2 in time t1 is not equal.

But the distance travelled by L1 & L2 at time ‘t1’ from observer-2 should be equal since speed of light is constant from any frame of reference;

ie;

a1 = c*t1

b1 = c*t1

Since a1≠b1, the only thing which should vary is the speed of light measured from observer-2’s frame of reference.

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Dismiss Notice

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Lorentz Transformation Equation Paradox

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**