Lorentz Transformations vs Galilean Transformation

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Kudox117
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Typed translated problem text about two projectiles moving left at the same speed, one reversing at 0.60c, with separation velocity 0.945c, asking for the speed of the leftward projectile relative to the person; handwritten note below reads Solution according to the book: 0.796c.


2. The attempt at a solution
Handwritten diagram of two observers: S2 moves at -0.6c and an event E is shown with velocity V2 = 0.945c. Labels S1 non-moving observer, S2 moving observer, and V1 = ? from the stick-figure observer. Below, the relativistic velocity addition formula V1 = (V2 + V)/(1 + V2V/c^2) = (0.945c - 0.6c)/(1 + (0.945)(-0.6c)/c^2), giving V1 = 0.7967c.


3. Relevant equations

In the first problems of that book i was using the Galilean transformations where

V1 = V2 + V

But if i use that then
V1 = 0.945 - 0.6
V1 = 0.345

Is not the same result, so I am confused.
In this new problems we are using Lorentz transformations.
When i should use Galilean transformations and when to use Lorentz transformations?
 
Lorentz transformations should always yield you the correct answer, but Galilean transformations are typically accurate for speeds much less than the speed of light. One way to think of it is that anytime you are using units in terms of c, you should be working in terms of Lorentz transformations. I'm not aware of an actual official cutoff point, but any typical speeds you're going to find here on Earth you can use Newtonian physics, with the exception of perhaps objects in orbit such as our GPS satellites.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Kudox117
TJGilb said:
...any typical speeds you're going to find here on Earth you can use Newtonian physics,
It depends on how sensitive the phenomenom under investigation is to relativistic effects. For example, even though electrons (usually) move slowly through a current carrying wire, a small amount of length contraction causes significant magnetic field to arise.