Nodal Analysis and Power Balance in AC Circuits

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on using nodal analysis in AC circuits to establish power balance between sources and resistors, as well as reactive power balance with inductors and capacitors. The user encounters discrepancies in power calculations, noting that some power values are negative, leading to a total power supplied of 205W, while the power dissipated in resistors sums to 284W. They question whether to take absolute values of the powers and share their node equations and calculations for voltage and current. A suggestion is made that the second term in the first node equation may need to be adjusted to include an imaginary component. The user seeks assistance in identifying the source of the imbalance in their calculations.
sandy.bridge
Messages
797
Reaction score
1
I'm working on an ac circuit, and we were told to use nodal analysis. Furthermore, we are asked to show a power balance between the sources and the power dissipated in the resistors, along with a reactive power balance between the sources and the inductors and capacitors.

I have this formula for the sources:
P=I_{rms}V_{rms}cos(\theta{_v}-\theta{_i})

However, when I am using this forumla, some of power in regards to the sources is negative, and some is positive. Therefore, upon summing together each of their contributions, the power is really low in comparison to the power dissipated in the resistors. Am I supposed to be taking the absolute value of these powers or what?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I decided to post an example:
Untitled-11.jpg

At nodes 1, 2 and 3 respectively I have
(0.6-j0.2)V_1+0.2V_2-0.1V_3=0, 0.2V_1+(0.2+j0.05)V_2-0.2V_3=8.75+j2.1651, -0.1V_1-0.2V_2+(0.3+j0.25)V_3=-12.5
Upon solving the system of equations, I find that
(V_1, V_2, V_3)=(-18.2797-9.09145j, 61.7064+8.49923j, -2.44807+5.00906j)=(20e^{-j156}, 62.3e^{j7.84}, 5.575e^{j116})
The current through the j10V source is
(V_3-j10)/(-j4)=1.38975e^{-j26.1}
and the power generated by this source is
P=(1.38976)(10)cos(90-(-26.1))=-6.1W
Current through the 50V source is
(V_3+50-V_2)/5=2.916e^{-j166}
and the power is
P=(2.916)(50)cos(0-(-166))=-141.5
The current in the final voltage source is
(V_2-10cos(30)-j10sin(30))/(-j4)=13.29e^{j94}
and the power is
P=(13.29)(10)cos(30-94)=58
Total power supplied is 205W.
The power dissipated in the 10-ohm resistor is
|V_3-V_1|^2/10=42W
In the 5-ohm resistor,
|V_3+50-V_2|^2/5=42W
and in the 2-ohm we have
|V_1|^2/2=200W
Combined we have total power dissipated as 284W.
Can anyone see where I have gone wrong here? Obviously this is not adding up, but I've been staring at this problem for a very long time and cannot seem to pin point it.
 
Last edited:
I believe that the second term of your first node equation (for node 1) should be imaginary.
That is, j0.2V2.
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top