Nodal Analysis: Understanding Method & Solving for Unknown Voltage

AI Thread Summary
Nodal analysis requires careful consideration of each node, particularly when calculating unknown voltages. The initial equation presented did not account for the current through the 75 V voltage source, which is crucial for accurate results. The correct approach involves applying Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) only at nodes with unknown voltages, while known voltages, like the 75 V node, should be treated as fixed. The discussion emphasizes the importance of including all relevant currents in the equations to avoid discrepancies in voltage calculations. Understanding these principles is essential for effective nodal analysis.
influx
Messages
162
Reaction score
1
ssvjv.png


I understand their method. However, if you use the node to the left of the 2 ohm resistor (the node where the voltage = 75 V) then you get:

(75-Vx)/2 -10 = 0

so 75-Vx = 20
so Vx - 75 = -20
Vx = 55 V

But this is not 25 V as it should be?

When doing nodal analysis, do you have to consider each node?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You did not include the current through the 75 v voltage source. your first equation should have been
(75-Vx)/2 -10 -(i3+0.4*Vx)= 0

that being said when you do nodal analysis you should only do kcl's at nodes with unknown voltages. you know that the 75v node is 75 v above ground. So try a KCL at nodes Vx and V1

does that make sense?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
donpacino said:
You did not include the current through the 75 v voltage source. your first equation should have been
(75-Vx)/2 -10 -(i3+0.4*Vx)= 0

that being said when you do nodal analysis you should only do kcl's at nodes with unknown voltages. you know that the 75v node is 75 v above ground. So try a KCL at nodes Vx and V1

does that make sense?

Ah yes! Thanks a lot mate.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top