Operations across an inequality

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the validity of operations involving inequalities, specifically when comparing powers and roots of numbers. It highlights that while a<b implies a^2<b^2 and a^3<b^3 for positive a and b, this does not hold for negative values, as shown with specific examples. The conversation also addresses proving the inequality u_n<2 using mathematical induction, emphasizing the importance of initial conditions and the behavior of the sequence defined by u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}. Participants clarify that taking the square root is valid under certain conditions, particularly when the sequence is increasing and bounded. The conclusion reinforces the necessity of understanding the properties of the sequence to manipulate inequalities correctly.
rock.freak667
Homework Helper
Messages
6,221
Reaction score
31

Homework Statement



If a<b...can I then say that a^2&lt;b^2 or a^3&lt;b^3 or even \sqrt{a}&lt;\sqrt{b}?Why I ask is that usually in some of the induction questions I do with inequalities, they give an expression like x_{n+1}=x_n^2 -7 or something like that.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Consider cases where a, b are positive or negative.
 
also, another key thing to consider is greater than or less than 1.
 
mutton said:
Consider cases where a, b are positive or negative.

Choose a=-1 and b=2, -1<2 true

(-1)^2=1, (2)^2=4...1&lt;4 true.

a=2,b=3; 2<3 true

(2)^2=4,(3)^2=9...4&lt;9 true

So I can do it across the inequality?
 
but say: -3<2 however (-3)^2=9 is not smaller than 2^2=4.
 
sutupidmath said:
but say: -3<2 however (-3)^2=9 is not smaller than 2^2=4.

ah right...sooo...then if am given something like

u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}[/itex]<br /> <br /> and to prove u_n&amp;lt;2<br /> <br /> I can&#039;t add 7 to both sides and then take the square root as my inequality might not be the same after taking the square root? If so...then how would I manipulate the u_n to get u_{n+1}
 
Can you post the original problem, because i don't think i am getting what you are saying?

Are you asked to prove that u_n<2, or you are provided with this fact? Because if the former is the case then you cannot start from this, since you are actually asked to prove this. IN other words, what is the problem asking you to do?
 
sutupidmath said:
Can you post the original problem, because i don't think i am getting what you are saying?

Are you asked to prove that u_n<2, or you are provided with this fact? Because if the former is the case then you cannot start from this, since you are actually asked to prove this. IN other words, what is the problem asking you to do?

Prove by mathematical induction that u_n&lt;2 given that u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}
 
rock.freak667 said:
Prove by mathematical induction that u_n&lt;2 given that u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}

And you have no prior information about u_1,... or ... u_0...?? It looks kind of hard, without having at leas some other information about this sequence besides that recurrence relation.
 
  • #10
Sorry...u_1 =1
 
  • #11
Ok then,

u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}


let n=1, so

u_{2}=-1+\sqrt{u_1 +7}=-1+\sqrt{8}=-1+2\sqrt{2}&lt;2

So for n=1, the inequality is valid.

Now let's suppose that the inequality is valid for n-1, that is

u_{n-1}&lt;2--------(IH) we need to show now that it is also true of n. That is we need to show that

u_n&lt;2...?

u_n=-1+\sqrt{u_{n-1}+7}

now from IH we have u_{n-1}+7&lt;2+7=9=&gt;\sqrt{u_{n-1}+7}&lt;\sqrt{9}=3----------(*****) so


u_n=-1+\sqrt{u_{n-1}+7}&lt;-1+\sqrt{9}=-1+3=2

What we actually wanted to prove.!

P.S. Step (*****) is valid, because the sequence is increasing, so since u1=1, it means that u_n&gt;0,\forall n
 
Last edited:
  • #12
So since u_n is a monotonic increasing sequence and bounded, its limit exists, so it also is a convergent sequence. If you are interested in finding the limit, it is very straightforward, just let:

\lim_{n\to\infty}u_n=L=\lim_{n\to\infty}u_{n+1} and use the reccurrence relation, you will end up with two solutions, and you'll know which one to choose when you get there.

I hope i was of any help!
 
  • #13
sutupidmath said:
now from IH we have u_{n-1}+7&lt;2+7=9=&gt;\sqrt{u_{n-1}+7}&lt;\sqrt{9}=3----------(*****)

P.S. Step (*****) is valid, because the sequence is increasing, so since u1=1, it means that u_n&gt;0,\forall n

ahh..thanks...that is what I wanted to know. If and why it was valid to take the square root on both sides.
 
  • #14
rock.freak667 said:
ahh..thanks...that is what I wanted to know. If and why it was valid to take the square root on both sides.

Just to be more precise, it should have read here:

u_n\geq 1,\forall n
 
  • #15
rock.freak667 said:
If a<b...can I then say that a^2&lt;b^2 or a^3&lt;b^3 or even \sqrt{a}&lt;\sqrt{b}?

Hi rock.freak667! :smile:

Rewrite a^2&lt;b^2 as a^2\,-\,b^2\,&lt;\,0\,.

Then (a - b)(a + b) < 0, so either a < b and a + b > 0, or a > b and a + b < 0.
rock.freak667 said:
Prove by mathematical induction that u_n&lt;2 given that u_{n+1}=-1+\sqrt{u_n +7}

"Prove by induction" means that you can assume that un < 2.

You'd better also assume that un > -1.

And √ in this case means the positive root.

Then √(un + 7) is between √6 and √9, so … ? :smile:
 
  • #16
tiny-tim said:
You'd better also assume that un > -1.




Well he need not assume this at all, since u_1=1 and u_n is an increasing sequence, it means like i said in one of my other posts, that

u_n\geq 1,\forall n \in N

So all other opertations follow because of this.!
 
Back
Top