RLC Circuit qualitative explanation some1 ?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the qualitative aspects of RLC circuits, focusing on the physical meanings behind the behavior of inductors, capacitors, and resistors in AC circuits, including concepts like resonance and the Q factor. Participants seek to understand energy transfer, voltage drops, and the oscillatory nature of these components without relying on vector diagrams.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a desire for a qualitative explanation of RLC circuits, specifically how energy is transferred and voltage drops occur across inductors, capacitors, and resistors.
  • Another participant describes the oscillation of energy between the inductor and capacitor in an RLC circuit, likening it to a pendulum and noting that energy loss occurs in the resistor.
  • Some participants discuss the relationship between voltage and current in inductors and capacitors, emphasizing the phase differences and energy storage mechanisms.
  • A participant questions whether there is both gain and loss of voltage as energy flows between the capacitor and inductor, seeking a deeper theoretical explanation.
  • One participant explains that the energy stored in the capacitor and inductor oscillates, with the resistor acting as a damping element in the system.
  • Another participant suggests that at resonance, the actions of the inductor and capacitor cancel each other out, leading to minimal power consumption, and questions the necessity of using both components instead of just a resistor.
  • Responses clarify that resistors do not store energy but dissipate it, prompting further inquiry into the purpose of energy storage in inductors and capacitors.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally express varying degrees of understanding and interpretation of the RLC circuit behavior, with some agreeing on the oscillatory nature of energy transfer while others contest the necessity of both inductors and capacitors in achieving resonance. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the implications of resonance and the roles of each component.

Contextual Notes

Some participants reference specific relationships between voltage, current, and energy storage without fully resolving the underlying assumptions or mathematical details. The discussion reflects a mix of conceptual understanding and uncertainty about the physical mechanisms at play.

sudar_dhoni
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
can some one explain me the qualitative aspects of RLC circuit
i am satisfied with the vector diagrams i want the physical meaning behind
say for instance in ac with inductor when current varies induced electric field is set up which opposes the current so there is a voltage drop
similarly in capacitor it stores charges and they repel the incoming current and also for resistor
like this i want a physical explanation of RLC series circuit what happens there and also about resonance and q factor because i study with proper reasoning
so PLZ PLZ PLZ any 1 to help me
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In an RLC circuits, the voltage across the inductor is given by V = L dI/dt, and the current in the capacitor is given by I = C dV/dt. In an LRC circuit flows back and forth between the inductor and capacitor without loss, like the pendulum in classical mechanics. Energy loss in the resistor is like damping in the pendulum. the resonant frequency is given by 1/sqrt(LC) in radians per second.

Bob S
 
Bob S said:
In an RLC circuits, the voltage across the inductor is given by V = L dI/dt, and the current in the capacitor is given by I = C dV/dt. In an LRC circuit flows back and forth between the inductor and capacitor without loss, like the pendulum in classical mechanics. Energy loss in the resistor is like damping in the pendulum. the resonant frequency is given by 1/sqrt(LC) in radians per second.

Bob S

can u explain in terms of voltage drops in inductor capacitor and resistor
see the source supplies energy to current or charges,these charges then somehow or the other they have to return to lower energy state so they drop their energy (energy is same as voltage -enegy possesed by unit charge) so they drop their voltage.All i have said till now is in
http://www.physicsclassroom.com/Class/circuits/u9l1b.cfm
my doubt is that how does this happen in RLC circuit
please don't explain in terms of vector diagrams as it is not convincing
i want the physical meaning behind
 
sudar_dhoni said:
can u explain in terms of voltage drops in inductor capacitor and resistor
see the source supplies energy to current or charges,these charges then somehow or the other they have to return to lower energy state so they drop their energy (energy is same as voltage -enegy possesed by unit charge) so they drop their voltage.
The energy stored in the capacitor is proportional to the square of the voltage, the energy stored in the inductor is proportional to the square of the current, the power dissipated by the resistor is proportional to both the voltage and the current. Energy oscillates between the capacitor and inductor and is damped by the resistor.
 
Do you understand how a capacitor and an inductor work? Bob S' explanation is pretty much complete, he already related the relationships between voltage and current for an ideal inductor and capacitor. Inductors and capacitors store energy. The energy is exchanged between the capacitor and inductor when they are in an isolated series circuit, in effect, they become a harmonic oscillator. The introduction of a resistor provides a means of dissipating the energy in the circuit, effectively damping the oscillator system.
 
Born2bwire said:
Do you understand how a capacitor and an inductor work? Bob S' explanation is pretty much complete, he already related the relationships between voltage and current for an ideal inductor and capacitor. Inductors and capacitors store energy. The energy is exchanged between the capacitor and inductor when they are in an isolated series circuit, in effect, they become a harmonic oscillator. The introduction of a resistor provides a means of dissipating the energy in the circuit, effectively damping the oscillator system.

do u mean that there is both gain as well as loss of voltage when it flows between capacitor and inductor?
could u explain much more deeper as i am not aware of oscillator
i think what u mean is that in one cycle capacitor may drop voltage and inductor might supply energy by means of induced electric field acting in same direction of current i.e while passing through capacitor it flows from higher potential to lower potential so it has to do work and voltage is dropped while in inductor it accelerates and supplies energy so that gain=loss and the only loss is in resistor. is this what happening ?
if not can u explain theoritically not mathematically
 
A capacitor works by storing charges on opposite plates when a voltage is applied across the plates. These charges build up an opposing voltage to the applied voltage and as more charges build up, eventually the built up voltage cancels out the applied voltage. If we were to remove the capacitor from this charging circuit, it can now act as a low-energy source. Equivalently, the energy is stored in the electric field that is built up by the charges. An inductor can be thought of as a coil of wire, like a solenoid. When current passes through the coils, it induces a magnetic field through the coils. Energy is stored in the magntic field as well.

In a time-varying circuit, the changing current in the inductor will cause a changing magnetic field in the coils over time. But, from Lenz's law we know that the changing magnetic field will impose an electromotive force that seeks to "oppose" the change in its field. This causes a voltage to be induced. In a sinusoidally applied signal, this causes the voltage and current to be 90 degrees out of phase with the current lagging the voltage.

Likewise, in a capacitor, a time-varying current will cause a time-varying voltage across the capacitor as the charges between the plates are constantly shifted. In a sinusoidal signal, the current leads the voltage by 90 degrees.

Thus, in a LC circuit, the phase of the energy in an inductor is 180 degrees out of phase with the capacitor. When one is fully energized, the other is fully dissipated of energy. This is what allows the energy to oscillate back and forth between the two elements at a specific resonant frequency. It is the same behavior as a harmonic oscillator, which is how an idealized pendulum behaves for small displacements. But an ideal capacitor and inductor do not dissipate energy, so the introduction of a resistor to make an RLC circuit causes power dissipation. However, since the phases of the current and voltages are not the same, the power dissipated is less than the power that is stored up in a capacitor or inductor over the same cycle. Only a part of the power (called reactive power) that is going back and forth between the inductor and capacitor is dissipated by the resistor over a cycle. So the resistor behaves as a dampener in our harmonic oscillator.
 
When one is fully energized, the other is fully dissipated of energy. This is what allows the energy to oscillate back and forth between the two elements at a specific resonant frequency

this means that energy of current is drained at one site and energy is gained at the other site such that at resonance both loss and gain are equal such that the energy of current is drained only by resistor.
if it is so what at happens at resonace is that inductor and capacitor actions are equal and opposite and they cancel off ,this is what resonace as power consumed is less.
my suggestion is that in order to achieve this state
no need to use inductor and capacitor.Use only resistor which is same as cancelling impedances of inductor and capacitor at resonace.Instead of struggling like this in order to achieve resonace don't use inductor and capacitor and use only resistor ?
 
Resistors do not store energy, they only dissipate energy (convert it from electrical energy to thermal energy).
 
  • #10
DaleSpam said:
Resistors do not store energy, they only dissipate energy (convert it from electrical energy to thermal energy).

what is the use of storing that energy by inductor and capacitor
 
  • #11
Are you asking for practical energy-storage applications of capacitors and inductors or are you asking about something wrt the use of capacitors and inductors in RLC circuits. If the latter then I do not understand precisely what you are asking.
 
  • #12
are you asking about something wrt the use of capacitors and inductors in RLC circuits. If the latter then I do not understand precisely what you are asking.[/QUOTE]

see
at resonance the impedance offered by capacitor and inductor are equal so the net effect on the voltage drop is cancelled. the voltage is only dropped by the resistor.which means only resistor is doing the dropping of voltage.
THEN why need to use capacitor and inductor which don't drop any voltage instead u use ony resistor
 
  • #13
Usually because you want to suppress other frequencies as well as pass your resonant frequency. A resistor alone will not do that.
 
  • #14
DaleSpam said:
Usually because you want to suppress other frequencies as well as pass your resonant frequency. A resistor alone will not do that.

i can't understand what u mean could u please explain elaborately
also in one cycle how much time the current changes its direction once or twice
i am clear about frequency of AC
PLZ DaleSpam i know u r a genius could u please explain the whole of RLC elaborately
also i have many doubts in electrical engineering could u please shower upon me some of ur intellect by teaching me and answering my doubts
 
  • #15
You are asking way too much. I cannot explain everything about a RLC circuit in a single post, there are literally whole textbooks on the subject.

However, it seems that your primary question is about impedance and since you mentioned some specifics I will assume that you understand impedance. Recall that the impedance of a capacitor is 1/(jwC) where j is the imaginary number, w is the frequency, and C is the capicatance. Similarly the impedance of an inductor is jwL where L is the inductance, and the impedance of a resistor is R where R is the resistance. If these are placed in series then the series impedance of the RLC circuit is jwL + 1/(jwC) + R = R + j(CLw²-1)/Cw which as you have mentioned is equal to R for the resonant frequency of w = sqrt(1/LC). However, consider other frequencies such as w = 0, in that case the impedance of the RLC circuit is infinite. So although the RLC circuit behaves just like the R by itself at the resonant frequency, the behavior of the RLC circuit at other frequencies is different. This can be used to create a "band pass filter", which will allow frequencies near the resonant frequency through, but suppress higher or lower frequencies.
 
  • #16
DaleSpam said:
You are asking way too much. I cannot explain everything about a RLC circuit in a single post, there are literally whole textbooks on the subject.

However, it seems that your primary question is about impedance and since you mentioned some specifics I will assume that you understand impedance. Recall that the impedance of a capacitor is 1/(jwC) where j is the imaginary number, w is the frequency, and C is the capicatance. Similarly the impedance of an inductor is jwL where L is the inductance, and the impedance of a resistor is R where R is the resistance. If these are placed in series then the series impedance of the RLC circuit is jwL + 1/(jwC) + R = R + j(CLw²-1)/Cw which as you have mentioned is equal to R for the resonant frequency of w = sqrt(1/LC). However, consider other frequencies such as w = 0, in that case the impedance of the RLC circuit is infinite. So although the RLC circuit behaves just like the R by itself at the resonant frequency, the behavior of the RLC circuit at other frequencies is different. This can be used to create a "band pass filter", which will allow frequencies near the resonant frequency through, but suppress higher or lower frequencies.

thats what i asked
i asked at resonance the RLC circuit behaves just like the R by itself so at resonance without inductor and capacitor also is same is with both them connected

could u please explain my doubt mentioned here no1 is responding to it
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=352683
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
44
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K