Does Entropy Change Consider Irreversibility in Solids and Liquids?

AI Thread Summary
Entropy changes in solids and liquids are typically calculated using the equations Cp(or Cv)ln(T2/T1) or Q/T + Sgen, which accounts for irreversibility. For a reservoir with no change in temperature and volume, its entropy change is theoretically zero; however, when it exchanges heat, the entropy change is expressed as Q/T due to its infinite heat capacity. The formula for entropy change applies differently for reservoirs, as they can be treated with a very large heat capacity, leading to minimal temperature change. This allows the entropy change to be approximated as ΔS = Q/T when considering heat exchange. Thus, while the reservoir's entropy change is zero in isolation, it becomes non-zero when interacting with other systems.
son hong chang
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
usually, entropy change in solid and liquid is formulated as Cp(or Cv)ln(T2/T1) or Q/T(integral)+ Sgen.
so, considering the former and the latter equations, Do their entropy changes include irreversibility due to Sgen?

And next question,
reservoir has no change in temperature and volume. therefore, its'entropy change is zero.
(According to this formula: dS=Cvln(T2/T1)+Rln(V2/V1) )
but when we solve many matters in thermodynamics especially in entropy part, we think that the reservoir exchanging the heat with another part has the entropy change expressed as Q/T not zero.
why is that?
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
Because the reservoir has infinite heat capacity?
(Just my guess that this confused you.)
 
son hong chang said:
usually, entropy change in solid and liquid is formulated as Cp(or Cv)ln(T2/T1) or Q/T(integral)+ Sgen.
so, considering the former and the latter equations, Do their entropy changes include irreversibility due to Sgen?
The first equation is correct. I'm not sure about the second equation, unless T represents the temperature at the boundary with the surroundings and the integration is over time. The change in entropy from and initial thermodynamic equilibrium state to a final thermodynamic equilibrium state of a system depends only on the initial and final states, and not on the path between the two states.
And next question,
reservoir has no change in temperature and volume. therefore, its'entropy change is zero.
(According to this formula: dS=Cvln(T2/T1)+Rln(V2/V1) )
but when we solve many matters in thermodynamics especially in entropy part, we think that the reservoir exchanging the heat with another part has the entropy change expressed as Q/T not zero.
why is that?
The formula you wrote is for an ideal gas, which would not normally be used as a reservoir. But if you apply ##ΔS=mC_v\ln{(T_2/T_1)}## to a reservoir that has a very high value of ##mC_v##, you find that it reduces to Q/T. Here's how:

$$ΔS=mC_v\ln{(T_2/T_1)}=mC_v\ln{\left(1+\frac{(T_2-T_1)}{T_1}\right)}$$
If ##mC_v## is very large (as is the case of a reservoir, where it is infinite), the temperature change is very small. So we can expand the natural log term in a Taylor series and retain only the first term in the expansion. We thereby obtain:
$$ΔS\rightarrow mC_v\frac{(T_2-T_1)}{T_1}$$
But, $$mC_v(T_2-T_1)=Q$$Therefore,
$$ΔS\rightarrow \frac{Q}{T_1}$$
 
  • Like
Likes PietKuip
Thread 'Thermo Hydrodynamic Effect'
Vídeo: The footage was filmed in real time. The rotor takes advantage of the thermal agitation of the water. The agitation is uniform, so the resultant is zero. When the aluminum cylinders containing frozen water are immersed in the water, about 30% of their surface is in contact with the water, and the rest is thermally insulated by styrofoam. This creates an imbalance in the agitation: the cold side of the water "shrinks," so that the hot side pushes the cylinders toward the cold...
Back
Top