"Temperature feel" and evaporation

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ronny33344
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Evaporation
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the possibility of calculating a "temperature feel" index using data from an evaporation pan, including average, minimum, and maximum temperatures, as well as evaporation rates. While traditional indices like the heat index and wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT) require relative humidity, which is not directly available from the provided data, it is suggested that relative humidity could be estimated from the temperature data. The conversation emphasizes that "temperature feel" relates more to heat transfer rather than just temperature readings. It is noted that factors like wind and sun exposure significantly influence perceived temperature, and using the minimum or maximum temperature from the evaporation pan could serve as a proxy for wet bulb temperature in calculating relative humidity. The discussion also raises questions about the source of the minimum temperature data, indicating the need for clarity on whether it reflects daily minimums or readings from different locations within the pan.
Ronny33344
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Is there a formula relating "temperature feel" to measured temperature and evaporation of water in an evaporation pan (in mm)?
I have data on:
*average temperature
*evaporation of water in an evaporation pan
*minimum temperature of water in an evaporation pan
*maximum temperature of water in an evaporation pan

I want to somehow calculate or approximate "temperature feel" for hot days, something like the temperature-humidity index. Is that possible from this data?

I'm a social scientist and I know absolutely nothing about this stuff, so please excuse me if this question is ridiculous.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
Also, why is my text so big compared to everyone else's?
 
Ronny33344 said:
Also, why is my text so big compared to everyone else's?
Your copy/pasted text included BBcode formatting tags. I've removed them for you :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes Ronny33344
The question is not ridiculous, but it is not straightforward either. First you would need to define what "temperature feel" means because I've never heard of it before. There are, however, measures that attempt to reconcile weather conditions against what you feel, such as heat index and wbgt. You should probably google and read up on them and see if they meet your needs.
 
  • Like
Likes Ronny33344
Heat index and wbgt require relative humidity as an input. I don't have relative humidity in my data. :(
 
gneill said:
Your copy/pasted text included BBcode formatting tags. I've removed them for you :smile:
Thanks.
 
Sorry, missed the response...
Ronny33344 said:
Heat index and wbgt require relative humidity as an input. I don't have relative humidity in my data. :(
You should be able to calculate RH from your data for the heat index, but wbgt does not require RH -- you should be able to use your data directly.
 
  • Like
Likes Elliot Svensson
If you think of yourself as an instrument for measuring things, then what is "I feel cold" or "I feel hot" measuring? As an engineer, it seems to me that a person doesn't measure temperature but heat transfer, i.e. the passage of thermal energy from your skin and hair to the environment or vice versa.

To me this is confirmed by the experiment with the three cups of water, one cold, one hot, and one lukewarm... when you set your hands in the cold and hot cups for a while, and simultaneously put them both in the lukewarm cup, it seems that the lukewarm cup is either quite hot or quite cold--- but not lukewarm.

I think that this thought I have is also confirmed by how well the measurement of wind chill factor predicts the need for a coat, and that folks are advised to get out of the sun to relieve heatstroke. Both wind and sun don't change the air temperature immediately, but they do change a person's heat transfer.
 
  • #10
For relative humidity I would choose either your minimum or maximum temperature in the evaporating pan as equivalent to "wet bulb temperature". Having re-named your data this way, the equation for relative humidity is super-common, being a well-used calculation by weather people. You will also need barometric pressure, but you may find that assuming constant pressure doesn't really change your analysis.

Is the minimum a daily minimum or a measurement from a different sensor, i.e. perhaps at the bottom instead of the top of the pan?
 
Back
Top