Temperature of ideal gas in a cylinder

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the behavior of an ideal gas in a cylinder during piston movement. When the piston is suddenly moved inwards, the gas molecules increase in speed, leading to a rise in temperature due to the lack of heat exchange, as indicated by the First Law of Thermodynamics. If the piston is moved slowly, there is enough time for heat transfer, resulting in no change in temperature. After a sudden compression, the system will eventually reach thermal equilibrium with its surroundings, which may not return to the original room temperature. Understanding these principles clarifies the effects of compression on gas temperature and the dynamics of heat transfer.
Boomzxc
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
Qn : https://www.dropbox.com/s/dpcws9q4bjpzvtp/20151123_112037.jpg?dl=0

Why is option A and C wrong or correct?

My attempted answer :
A :A is plausible as if the piston is suddenly moved inwards, the gas molecules bounce off the piston at higher speeds
Since Temp proportional to rms speed, temp increases
Or
based on 1st law of thermodynamics
The piston suddenly moved in... So means Q=0 cos no time for heat transfer.
Since compression, W is +ve so U is +ve. That implies T increases.

C : as P increases, V decreases

Please help to correct my understanding! !
Thanks a million! !
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
"Suddenly moves inwards" in the question implies that there was little or no heat exchange during this compression process. With this information, apply the First Law and try and deduce for yourself whether A or C is the correct answer.
 
  • Like
Likes Boomzxc
What if the piston is slowly moved inwards? How will the answer change?
 
Boomzxc said:
What if the piston is slowly moved inwards? How will the answer change?

If the piston is moved slowly enough, the temperature will not change. Can you rationalize why?
 
  • Like
Likes Boomzxc
JeremyG said:
If the piston is moved slowly enough, the temperature will not change. Can you rationalize why?
Is it because there's time for heat distribution throughout the gas??
 
Boomzxc said:
Is it because there's time for heat distribution throughout the gas??

There's sufficient time during the process for heat to enter or leave the system.
 
  • Like
Likes Boomzxc
JeremyG said:
There's sufficient time during the process for heat to enter or leave the system.
If the piston is suddenly moved inwards and the temp increased, and i leave the system there for some time, will the system return to it's prior temperature (room temp) assuming this is carried out at room temp?
 
Boomzxc said:
If the piston is suddenly moved inwards and the temp increased, and i leave the system there for some time, will the system return to it's prior temperature (room temp) assuming this is carried out at room temp?

Yes, heat will flow from higher temperature region to lower temperature region. It would be more precise to say that the system and its surroundings reach an equilibrium temperature, which may or may not be the original room temperature. (before the compression)
 
  • Like
Likes Boomzxc
Back
Top