# The binding energy per nucleon of tritium

• Redwaves
In summary: No, you still have it backwards!The binding energy is energy released as a result of the nucleons binding to form the atom. That is why the atom has less mass than the sum of the nucleons that went into making it. To break the atom up again you have to add back the binding energy.
Redwaves
Homework Statement
The binding energy per nucleon of the ##^3 He## nucleus is 2.6 MeV. Deduce the binding energy per nucleon of tritium from the following information: (1) The mass energies of isolated protons, neutrons and electrons are 938.3 MeV, 939,6 MeV and 0.5 MeV. (2) Tritium decays by the reaction ##^3 H ---> ^3 He + e + v##, where kinetic energy of the final particles is 0.0186 MeV. (3) the mass energy of the antineutrino v is negligible on the MeV scale.
Relevant Equations
##E_i = E_f##
##E^2 = \vec{P}^2 c^2 + m^2 c^4##
##E = \gamma mc^2##
Hi,
I know from conservation of energy that ##E_i = E_f##
Thus, ## M_h c^2 + binding energy = M_{he}c^2+ M_e c^2 + K = M_{he}c^2 + 0.5 MeV + 0.0186 MeV##
If I'm right I have to find ##M_{he}c^2##, but something is missing in my understanding, since I don't see how to find that mass energy ##M_{he}c^2##.

Is the binding energy the difference between initial energy and final energy?
Is the mass energy of an atom the sum of all the neutrons, proton and electrons and the binding energy?

Redwaves said:
Is the mass energy of an atom the sum of all the neutrons, proton and electrons and the binding energy?
It relates to all those, but not quite in that way.
Can you define the binding energy?
Hint: it would be better termed the unbinding energy.

haruspex said:
It relates to all those, but not quite in that way.
Can you define the binding energy?
Hint: it would be better termed the unbinding energy.
You are right, but it uses binding in the book.
the unbinding energy is the amount of energy needed to "break" the tritium into the new particles.

Redwaves said:
You are right, but it uses binding in the book.
the unbinding energy is the amount of energy needed to "break" the tritium into the new particles.
Yes, but that also applies to the helium, right?
So what is the answer to your question that I quoted in post 2?

Yes, but I don't know the way they are related.
Maybe I wasn't clear, but this is the essence of my question.
I though the mass energy was the sum of all the nucleons, electrons and the binding energy of all nucleons and electrons as well.
I know from the statement that the binding energy for the nucleons of helium is ##2.6 \cdot 3##

Is ##E_{he} = M_{he}c^2 + (2.6 \cdot 3) + K## ?

Last edited:
Redwaves said:
I though the mass energy was the sum of all the nucleons, electrons and the binding energy of all nucleons and electrons as well.
No, you are still getting it backwards.
If the mass energy of an atom is ##E_m## and its binding energy is ##E_b## then you have to add energy ##E_b## to disassemble it into separate nucleons. So if the energy of that collection of nucleons is ##E_n##, what equation relates those three energies?
Apply that to both the ##^3H## and the ##^3He##.

What's the difference between ##E_m## and ##E_n##. The mass energy is not the energy of all the nucleons ?

##M_{he}c^2 = 2P + 1N - (2.6 \cdot 3) = 2808.4 MeV##
##E_0 = 2808.4 + K + 0.5 + k = 2808.94##
##E_0 = M_H c^2 = 2N + 1P - E_b = 2808.94##
##E_B = 8.56##
##8.56 / 3 = 2.85 MeV##

It sound really good, but I'm not sure to understand why the mass energy is the sum of all nucleons - binding energy.

Last edited:
Redwaves said:
What's the difference between ##E_m## and ##E_n##. The mass energy is not the energy of all the nucleons ?

##M_{he}c^2 = 2P + 1N - (2.6 \cdot 3) = 2808.4 MeV##
##E_0 = 2808.4 + K + 0.5 + k = 2808.94##
##E_0 = M_H c^2 = 2N + 1P - E_b = 2808.94##
##E_B = 8.56##
##8.56 / 3 = 2.85 MeV##

It sound really good, but I'm not sure to understand why the mass energy is the sum of all nucleons - binding energy.
Maybe I am using the terminology incorrectly. By mass energy of an atom or nucleon of mass m I mean ##mc^2##.
The mass of an atom is less than the sum of the masses of its nucleons. So its mass energy is less than the sum of the mass energies of its nucleons. The difference is the binding energy.

The difference is the binding energy.
Is this because it takes that energy to bind the nucleons together. Does it makes sense?

Redwaves said:
Is this because it takes that energy to bind the nucleons together. Does it makes sense?
No, you still have it backwards!
The binding energy is energy released as a result of the nucleons binding to form the atom. That is why the atom has less mass than the sum of the nucleons that went into making it. To break the atom up again you have to add back the binding energy.

Tom.G and Redwaves
Ah ! I see. Thanks a lot for your help.

## What is the binding energy per nucleon of tritium?

The binding energy per nucleon of tritium is the amount of energy required to break apart the nucleus of a tritium atom into its individual nucleons (protons and neutrons). It is a measure of the stability of the tritium nucleus.

## How is the binding energy per nucleon of tritium calculated?

The binding energy per nucleon of tritium is calculated by taking the total binding energy of the tritium nucleus and dividing it by the number of nucleons in the nucleus. The binding energy is determined by the difference between the mass of the tritium nucleus and the combined mass of its individual nucleons.

## What is the significance of the binding energy per nucleon of tritium?

The binding energy per nucleon of tritium is significant because it provides insight into the stability and strength of the tritium nucleus. A higher binding energy per nucleon indicates a more stable nucleus, while a lower binding energy per nucleon suggests a less stable nucleus.

## How does the binding energy per nucleon of tritium compare to other elements?

The binding energy per nucleon of tritium is relatively low compared to other elements. This is because tritium has a relatively small number of nucleons (3) in its nucleus, making it less stable compared to larger elements with more nucleons.

## What factors can affect the binding energy per nucleon of tritium?

The binding energy per nucleon of tritium can be affected by changes in the number of nucleons in the nucleus, as well as changes in the nuclear force that holds the nucleons together. External factors such as temperature and pressure can also impact the binding energy per nucleon of tritium.

• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
428
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
1K
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
13
Views
309
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
1K
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
782
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
2
Views
670
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
14
Views
979
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K