The difference between bv and kv^2 drag

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hannibal123
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Difference Drag
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the differences between linear drag (F = b*v) and quadratic drag (F = k*v^2) for objects moving through air. Quadratic drag is relevant for high-speed objects, while linear drag applies to lighter objects at low speeds. The drag coefficient in linear drag is inversely proportional to velocity and related to the Reynolds number, which factors in fluid density, viscosity, and object size. An experiment measuring wind force on a water rocket confirmed that the drag experienced was quadratic, leading to the conclusion that the k value derived from this experiment cannot be applied to linear drag scenarios. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for accurately modeling drag forces in various contexts.
Hannibal123
Messages
20
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



What is the difference between the two proportionality constants for liner drag
F=b*v
and quadratic drag
F=k*v^2
considering a general object moving trough air? i know that k is given by
1/2*ρ*C_w*A
where C_w is the drag coefficient
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Quadratic drag is typically applicable to objects moving through a medium at relatively high speeds , like heavy falling objects, whereas linear drag is typically applicable to light objects or particles moving through a medium (like a viscous thick fluid) at relatively low speeds. For objects moving through air, generally the quadratic drag equation applies. Similarly, wind forces on structures are proportional to the square of the wind speed...if you double the wind speed, the force or pressure is quadrupled.
 
Thank you. But can the constant in linear drag be descirbed by som factors similar to the constant in qudratic drag? except for sferes moving in fluids...
 
Hannibal123 said:
Thank you. But can the constant in linear drag be descirbed by som factors similar to the constant in qudratic drag? except for sferes moving in fluids...
Oh, i see what you are driving at...see here for the difference betweeen k and b


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics )
 
Last edited by a moderator:
In the region where the linear drag equation applies, the drag coefficient Cw is inversely proportional to the velocity. More, precisely, the drag coefficient is inversely proportional to the (dimensionless) Reynolds Number (Re), which is equal to ρvL/η, where ρ is the fluid density, η is the fluid viscosity, and L is a characteristic length for the object, such as the diameter of a sphere.
 
Ok thanks. I have made an experiment where i have measured the wind force on an object (a water rocket) at different wind speeds. Plotted into a graph it gives me these values:
http://imgur.com/He0Qd
Which must be quadratic drag
Or the same values but the with the velocity squared on the horisontal axis
http://imgur.com/0xfMX
Thus obtaining the k value K=0,0032 kg/m
Now based on what you said, it wouldn't make any sense to try and apply this k value to a linear drag right?
 
Right.
 
Back
Top