Torque on a current-carrying loop

gnome

When a current carrying loop is placed in a uniform magnetic field and the normal to the plane of the loop is &perp; to the direction of the field (iow the plane of the loop is parallel to the direction of the field), at that moment the torque (about any axis) exerted on the loop is supposed to be
T = IAB
where I is the current, A is the area of the loop, and B is the field.

So, I want to try this out on an equilateral triangular loop with base = 2x, height = x&radic;3, and hypotenuse = 2x.
I'll put my axis of rotation along a vertical line from the apex to the center of the base. This way, the torque on half of the base is clockwise & on the other half counterclockwise, so the base can be ignored in the calculations. By symmetry, the torque contributions of the other two legs are equal, so we can just calculate one of them & then double it. So, now I'm looking at half of the original equilateral triangle: a 30-60-90 triangle, with the axis of rotation along the vertical (long) leg. The measurement along this axis is h = x&radic;3. The measurement along the base is just x.

The magnetic force is exerted along the hypotenuse, L = 2x.
The force exerted on each little piece dL is:
F = BIdL
but
L = (2/&radic;3)h; therefore
dL = (2/&radic;3)dh; so
The distance from each dL to the axis:
Therefore the torque contribution from each dL should be
dT = Fd
dT = (2/3)BIhdh
So the total torque on this half of the triangle is
T = (2/3)BI&int;0x&radic;3 hdh
T = (2/3)BI*(3x2/2)
T = BIx2

The torque on the entire equilateral triangle should be double this, or
T = 2BIx2

But this is wrong. The formula says that the torque should be
T = IAB
For an equilateral triangle with side = 2x, A = x2&radic;3

Where did I go wrong?

Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org

Doc Al

Mentor
Originally posted by gnome
The force exerted on each little piece dL is:
F = BIdL
The force is given by F = Idl X B, where "dl X B" is the cross product of the vectors dl and B. Since they are not perpendicular, you must include a factor of sin 60. Include that missing factor and your answer is perfect.

gnome

Thanks, Doc. I forgot that now I'm dealing with the L vector instead of just the orthogonal to the plane of the loop.

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving