Using a Spreadsheet to determine the Fourier Series

AI Thread Summary
Using a spreadsheet to determine the Fourier Series involves entering data correctly into Excel and utilizing the Fourier Analysis tool found under Data Analysis. A user encountered discrepancies in their results, which were traced back to incorrectly referencing the data range, as the input data was in column B instead of column A. The importance of following the problem statement precisely was highlighted, as even minor errors can lead to incorrect outputs. The discussion emphasizes the need for careful attention to detail when inputting data ranges in Excel. This serves as a reminder that understanding the original problem is crucial for accurate results.
Gremlin
Messages
91
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Use a spreadsheet to determine the F.S. of the data given in Fig 6

See attached for Fig 6

Homework Equations



N/A - Use the Fourier Series tool of MS Excel. Tools > Data Analysis > Fourier Series. If you don't have the Data Analysis tool loaded you can load it by going Tools > Add-ins > Analysis Tool Pack.

The Attempt at a Solution


My attempt at the solution is attached, but my results don't match the results in my course notes. I was wondering if someone could see where I am going wrong.

I open a new excel spreadsheet, enter the data of fig 6 in exactly the same cells.

Then I run the Fourier Analysis tool, my data range is cells A2-A9 and the output range is cell D2.
 

Attachments

  • Fig 6 PDF.pdf
    Fig 6 PDF.pdf
    63.2 KB · Views: 272
  • My Attempt.jpg
    My Attempt.jpg
    49.2 KB · Views: 476
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Perhaps it has something to do with the format of your range specifications? Did you enter the ranges manually, or did you use the mouse to select them so they'd be automatically constructed?
 
I selected them using the mouse, highlighting A2 and dragging down to A9, so that in the 'Input Range' cell on the Fourier analysis tool it reads: $A$2:$A$9
 
Your data points are in column B, not column A. Fix your input data range.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
You're correct.

In my defence I followed the example to the letter of the law, and that says "Next we enter the input data range (A2-A9)..."

Thanks.
 
Gremlin said:
You're correct.

In my defence I followed the example to the letter of the law, and that says "Next we enter the input data range (A2-A9)..."

Thanks.
Ha! Glad it worked out.

This is a great example of why it's always a good idea to relate the original problem statement word-for-word. Sometimes the problem is the problem!
 
Back
Top