Weight causing a wheel to rotate

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the relationship between tension, weight, and angular acceleration in a system involving a wheel and a hanging mass. It clarifies that the tension in the string is not equal to the weight of the hanging mass when the mass is accelerating downwards. The participants derive equations linking linear and angular acceleration, emphasizing the need to eliminate tension to solve for angular acceleration. The correct approach involves using torque and force equations to relate the system's dynamics. Ultimately, the discussion concludes with a successful resolution of the problem, highlighting the collaborative nature of problem-solving in physics.
JamesGold
Messages
39
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



ZbboC.png


Homework Equations



I_solidcylinder = .5mr^2
I_thinring = mr^2
torque = I*Ω (where Ω = angular acceleration)
change in theta = .5(Ω)(time^2)

The Attempt at a Solution



Attempted to solve for angular acceleration:

(2.5)(9.8)(0.1) = (3*0.25^2 + 0.5*4*0.1^2)Ω

Ω = 11.8 rad/s/s

which I then plugged into the rotational kinematics formula:

Δ∅ = 0.5*11.8*0.5^2

which gave me a wrong answer. Where'd I go wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The torque causing angular acceleration is provided by the tension in the string.
But is this tension equal to the weight of the hanging mass?
Note that the hanging mass is accelerating downwards.
 
grzz said:
But is this tension equal to the weight of the hanging mass?

I don't see why it wouldn't be. Can you explain why it isn't?
 
What if you had two blocks connected by a string and dropped them over a balcony, would the string have a tension equal to the weight of the lower block?
 
Is the hanging mass accelerating downwards?
 
JHamm said:
What if you had two blocks connected by a string and dropped them over a balcony, would the string have a tension equal to the weight of the lower block?

I'm not sure. Wouldn't it depend on the relative weights of the two blocks?

grzz said:
Is the hanging mass accelerating downwards?

Yes.
 
So if the hanging mass is accelerating which is the greater force, the tension upwards or the weight of the mass downwards?
 
The weight of the mass downwards.
 
Correct.
 
  • #10
So mg - T = ma?
 
  • #11
Hence the tension is not equal to the weight.

The torque is provided by the tension and this tension is still unknown.

But one can obtain another equation so that one can find the tension.
 
  • #12
JamesGold said:
So mg - T = ma?
exactly.
 
  • #13
Then how do you find the acceleration of the block?
 
  • #14
The linear acceleration is related to the angular acceleration.

Note that

for distance there is, x = rθ
hence for velocity there is, v = rω
and for acceleration there is, a = rα
 
  • #15
I used α instead of Ω for angular acc
 
  • #16
Right... but without knowing the tension of the string, I don't see how we can calculate the angular acceleration of the wheel or the acceleration of the block.
 
  • #17
We have two equations:

1...torque eqn for rotational acc

2...f = ma for linear acc

get linear acc 'a' in terms of the ang acc

and then eliminate tension from these two equations.
 
  • #18
Okay, so I have now:

String tension * moment arm = I of system * ang acc

[ (2.50)(9.80) - (2.50)(0.1)α ] * 0.1 = (0.02 + 0.1875) * α

Is this correct?
 
  • #19
Yes.
 
  • #20
Got the right answer. I can't thank you enough, selfless sir.
 
  • #21
Welcome to Physics Forums, the site which helps those who help themselves.
 
Back
Top