What are the correct labels for frequency and displacement in a wave graph?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the correct interpretation of wave graphs, particularly concerning frequency and displacement labels. A participant initially calculated wave speed incorrectly, leading to confusion about the correct values. The importance of using proper units and labels on graphs is emphasized, as mislabeling can lead to misunderstandings in calculations. There is a suggestion that clearer labels, such as "Displacement in cm" and "Time in ms," might reduce confusion. Overall, the conversation highlights the significance of accurate labeling in educational contexts to aid comprehension.
desmond iking
Messages
284
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement



my working is as in the photo which is v=f X wavelength = 0.4 X 0.04= 0.16 ... but the ans given is 0.10m/s

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution

 

Attachments

  • IMG_20140629_075737[1].jpg
    IMG_20140629_075737[1].jpg
    32.6 KB · Views: 460
  • IMG_20140629_075825[1].jpg
    IMG_20140629_075825[1].jpg
    38.7 KB · Views: 479
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Ever look at the dimension of speed and compared to the dimension of your answer ?

Oh, and use the template, please. If you'd done so you would have discovered where you went off the rails. (And never have posted in the first place, thus robbing me of a chance to promote the use of the template. All bad things have a bright side :smile:).

If you have time left, read the guidelines too...
 
The value you got for the frequency f is not correct.

Also 0.4 * 0.04 = 0.16 isn't a correct equation.
 
sorry... my working should be ( (40X10^-3 )X (4X10^-3) )/100= 0.016 m/s .. which part is wrong?
 
Your second diagram is not clear. Distance in what?
 
Ignore the question. Found my mistake.
 
adjacent said:
Your second diagram is not clear. Distance in what?
How about betting on mm ?

But poor Des is still looking at the wrong frequency. He may be confused by the label on the x-axis of graph a.

Des: you see there one full period ends at the number 40. that is the period divided by ms.

Meaning: ##{period \over ms} = 40\, ## so that period = ??
What is the dimension of frequency ?
- - - -

Graph b x-axis label is distance / mm but there he has no problem extracting ##\lambda## = 4 mm.

Des: Now, do you see where you ended up upside down ?

- - - -

Personally I think the labels are quite correct, but in my own work I use labels like "Displacement in cm" and "Time in ms" that (I hope) are less confusing than the correct labels.

(But then, I am not a teacher / pedagogics expert. Any opinions/experience from the field?)

[edit] woke up after some soccer. Des is happy. My opinions question stands.
 
Back
Top