What is best software used to design electronic circuits?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the search for reliable software for electronic circuit design and simulation. Participants are exploring options for both design and analysis tools, with a focus on ensuring circuits function correctly before manufacturing.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant requests recommendations for software that can design and analyze circuits to avoid manufacturing errors.
  • Another participant mentions several simulation programs, including Multisim, and emphasizes the importance of prototyping as a final test beyond simulation.
  • A participant shares their experience using OrCAD CIS for schematics and MicroCAP for SPICE simulations, noting its integration with PSPICE for mixed-signal simulations.
  • Another user expresses a preference for Altium, highlighting its features for schematic capture, simulation, and 3D modeling, while criticizing Zuken Cadstar as inferior.
  • LTSpice is recommended by a participant for simulation, particularly for music electronics, citing its effectiveness and free availability.
  • A detailed description of OrCAD's capabilities is provided, including its accuracy and limitations regarding SPICE models for certain devices.
  • A participant mentions their past experience with Microsim PSpice, noting the limitations of the free student version compared to LTSpice, which they find less user-friendly.
  • Another recommendation is made for Cadsoft's software, described as the best for circuit board design, including various editing features.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a variety of opinions on different software options, with no consensus on a single best choice. Some prefer LTSpice for its free access and component limits, while others favor OrCAD or Altium for their features. Disagreements exist regarding usability and effectiveness of the mentioned software.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note limitations in the free versions of software, such as component restrictions in PSpice and potential convergence issues in LTSpice. There are also mentions of the need for users to create their own SPICE models for certain devices in OrCAD.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for electronics engineers, students in electrical engineering, hobbyists in circuit design, and anyone interested in software tools for electronic circuit design and simulation.

New_Gaber
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hello everybody,

Please i need a reliable software to use in electronic circuit design, and to check the circuit to be working before manufacturing,i mean not to make it, and then find that it doesn't work, so software to design and another to do analysis of the circuit, or one software do both, anyone can help me with that?.

Thanks in advance.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
there's a number of simulation programs out there ... eg multisim

do some google searching on simulation packages.
whatever you end up using... actual prototyping will be the final test as you will find that sim software doesn't take into account the way things work in the real world

Dave
 
New_Gaber said:
Hello everybody,

Please i need a reliable software to use in electronic circuit design, and to check the circuit to be working before manufacturing,i mean not to make it, and then find that it doesn't work, so software to design and another to do analysis of the circuit, or one software do both, anyone can help me with that?.

Thanks in advance.

Here at work, we use OrCAD CIS to do the schematics, and we use MicroCAP to do the SPICE simulations of the analog circuitry. We use Xilinx tools for our digital work for the most part. I believe that OrCAD also can link up with PSPICE, if you want a more automatic way to do your mixed-signal simulations.

http://www.cadence.com/products/orcad/pages/default.aspx

.
 
I really liked Altium for schematic capture, spice simulation, and board layout. It also has good parts/documentation management features and let's you model your board+components in 3D to visually check for interferences.

The last software I had to use was Zuken Cadstar, and I really hated it in every category compared to Altium. It is clumsy, buggy, ugly, confusing, awkward, and takes a while to get work done.
 
I use LTSpice for simulation. I have been using it quite a bit lately for designing music electronics, so far so good. In fact, I design on LTSpice before I even breadboard the circuit because I design the waveform and it works.

http://www.linear.com/designtools/software/

It's free!
 
berkeman said:
Here at work, we use OrCAD CIS to do the schematics, and we use MicroCAP to do the SPICE simulations of the analog circuitry. We use Xilinx tools for our digital work for the most part. I believe that OrCAD also can link up with PSPICE, if you want a more automatic way to do your mixed-signal simulations.

http://www.cadence.com/products/orcad/pages/default.aspx

.

OrCAD is a circuit design suite which has Capture/Capture CIS as schematic editor, Layout as PCB Layout and PSpice/PSpice A/D as SPICE simulator. The newest version includes many more in the package. The advantage of using OrCAD is its accuracy and convergence. They have improvised the simulation algorithm a lot for that. It also supports various device and macromodel and supports upto BSIMv3.1 (for those unaware it is MOSFET model by Berkeley). It also comes as free demo/ Lite / student edition where simulation capability is limited to 10 transistor. The disadvantage of using OrCAD is you won't find SPICE model for all devices in the package. You have to download datasheet and make your own model.

I don't know about other simulator, but I do know about some down point about LTspice. I once ran a simulation which had convergence problems and all other spice simulator gave me errors about time step. LTspice did not stop and warn me and just gave me erroneous result.
 
i would recommend http://www.cadsoftusa.com/.
It is the best software for circuit board design i think.
It includes a schematic editor, autorouter and a layout editor.
For more info just check the homepage.
greetings
 
About 15 years ago I used the full Microsim PSpice package and liked it very much. At the time I believe it cost about $5000. Now I use the free student version but it is severely limited in the number of components that can be used. When I have a small circuit I often use PSpice but if the circuit is larger than what the free PSpice can handle, I use LTSpice. LTSpice is not limited in the number of components and is also free, but for me, it's not as easy to use as PSpice.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K