What will be the order of increasing radius?

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
prakhargupta3301
Messages
58
Reaction score
1
Thread moved from the technical forums, so no Homework Template is shown
Multiple-choice question: The species Ar, K- and Ca2+ contain the same number of electrons. In which order do their radii increase? Options (A) Ar < K+ < Ca2+, (B) Ca2+ < Ar < K+, (C) Ca2+ < K+ < Ar, (D) K+ < Ar < Ca2+.

My answer is A.
Because effective nuclear charge would increase in order Ar<K+<Ca2+ and radius would be inverse of that.
However, the answer isn't that. Can you just point me?
Also, can you tell me in this question, do we think of the noble gas and the Ca and K ions as single atomic species or diatomic? Because Ar doesn't exist in single form right? So will be compare metallic radius(for metal ions) and Vander Waal's radius(for noble gas) or ionic radius for all three?
 
Attachments
  • Multiple-choice question: The species Ar, K- and Ca2+ contain the same number of electrons. In which order do their radii increase? Options (A) Ar < K+ < Ca2+, (B) Ca2+ < Ar < K+, (C) Ca2+ < K+ < Ar, (D) K+ < Ar < Ca2+.
    upload_2018-7-11_22-42-9.png
    27.2 KB · Views: 847
You don't need any concept of effective nuclear charge here. Just use the actual nuclear charge (the atomic number). The higher the nuclear charge, the more tightly it will bind to electrons.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: prakhargupta3301
Khashishi said:
You don't need any concept of effective nuclear charge here. Just use the actual nuclear charge (the atomic number). The higher the nuclear charge, the more tightly it will bind to electrons.
So I think C?
Am I correct please tell me.