Why Does a Block Lose Contact with a Frictionless Sphere?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MathematicalPhysicist
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Confused
AI Thread Summary
A small block sliding from rest on a frictionless sphere loses contact at a specific displacement below the top, denoted as x. The calculations involve using energy conservation to find the block's velocity and relating it to the angle of contact with the sphere. The normal force becomes zero when the block loses contact, leading to the equation cos(a) = v^2/(Rg). The correct relationship for cos(a) is derived from the geometry of the situation, giving cos(a) = (R-x)/R. The final answer for x, where the block loses contact, is R/3, indicating a discrepancy in the initial calculations presented.
MathematicalPhysicist
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
4,662
Reaction score
372
a small block slides from rest from the top of a frictionless sphere of radius R, how far below the top x does it lose contact with the sphere? the sphere doesn't move.
the question is from kleppner's in troduction to mechanics page 196 problem 4.6. (my scanner doesn't work so i can't scan the picture).

anyway, x is the displacement from when the block was on top the shpere up until where it loses contact with the sphere.

what i got so far is:
i calculated the tan of the angle of velocity, i got that tan(a)=sqrt(2Rx-x^2)/x and i got by energies that v^2=2xg and i know that v_y/v_x=tg(a) and v^2=v_y^2+v_x^2
and that v_y^2=xg, but after all that i didnt get the answer in the book, which is R/3.
can someone help me here?
thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Loss of contact implies that the normal force N equals 0. Since N = mgcosA - mv^2/R, we have cosA = v^2/(Rg). Since you already found the velocity v for a displacement x, your problem is solved.
 
im having a problem here:
iv'e done the calclulation for v, v^2=2xg
and cos(a)=x/sqrt(2xR)
but then:
x/sqrt(2xR)=v^2/Rg=2xg/Rg=2x/R
x/2R=4x^2/R^2
Rx=8x^2
x=R/8
and according to my book the answer is R/3, where did i go wrong here?
 
someone can help me here?
any help is appreciated.
 
Find cos(a) in terms of x and R from what you've already found out[cos(a) = v^2/Rg] and then find what cos(a) is from the diagram (right triangle).Equate the two.
 
a is the angle of the velocity of the block, i found that:
cos(a)=x/sqrt(2xR)
bus as i said i don't get in the end the right answer, which is R/3.
 
angle of the velocity?

Take a look at radou's post. A is the angle bet. the vertical and the position at which the block falls off.
 
so how should i calculate the angle, i thought that my calclualtion was correct i.e cos(a)=x/sqrt(2xR)
how should i calculate the angle?
 
what did i do wrong here?
 
  • #10
\cos{a} = \frac{v^2}{Rg}

v^2 = 2gx - conservation of energy

Also, \cos{a} = \frac{R-x}{R} (from the right triangle)

Angle a is measured clockwise from the vertical two the point where the block loses contact.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top