Why is the maximum y value different from the centroid?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the maximum axial stress in a beam subjected to axial force and moments. The user successfully applied Navier's formula to derive the maximum stress but is confused about the values of y(max) and z(max). The correct value for y(max) is identified as 124, not 151, prompting a deeper examination of what these variables represent in the context of stress distribution. Understanding the stress distribution diagrams is crucial for clarifying these values. The conversation emphasizes the importance of accurately interpreting geometric parameters in structural analysis.
kasse
Messages
383
Reaction score
1
I've got a sectional area of a beam that is subjected to an axial force N = -100 and momenst M(y) = -50 kNm and M(z)= - 120 kNm. I've found the centroid and the second moment of area around both axes.

How can I compute the maximum axial stress?

Here's the section: http://www.badongo.com/pic/624173


Edit:
I got the correct answer after trying Naviers formula several times:

Max stress = N/A + (M(z)*y(max))/I(z) + (M(y)*z(maks))/I(z)

What I don't understand is: Why is y(maks)=124 and not 151??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Well, if you got the correct answer, you should ask yourself what ymax and zmax represent in your formula and compare them with your results.
 
Look at the stress distributions diagrams.
 
Back
Top