Will water flow ever stop if we increase resistance?

In summary, the conversation discusses the flow of water in a scenario with two communicating vessels, where water is constantly being added to the higher vessel and excess water is collected by a water collector. The main element of interest is the pipe distance d, which can be considered as the main resistance to the flow. Increasing this resistance by decreasing the pipe diameter reduces the flow rate, and an infinite resistance would result in a complete stop of flow. The conversation also mentions a real-life example where water flowed downhill through a long pipe despite attempts to control the flow with valves. The math for this situation is shown in a Moody chart, and the Reynolds number decreases with smaller pipe diameter and lower pressure differences. The conversation also questions the statement that the pressure at point
  • #1
Complete question:
Will flow ever reverse or stop if we increase resistance in this pipe scenario?

wI3VI.png
There are 2 comunicating vessels. The highest vessel is coninuosly alimented with new water. Water in excess flows down on the sides.
Water will try to reach the same height in both vessels, so some water will pour out of the shortest one and will be collected by the water collector.
The pipe distance d and the point A are our elements of interest.
The pipe distance d can be considered our main resistance to the flow, and it increases as the pipe become of a smaller diameter ( R1, R2, R3, R4 ).
In the first scenario, the pipe distance d doesn't get restricted so the pressure at point A should be the pressure exerted by the left vessel's water column minus the pressure exerted by the right vessel's water column.
Flow should be from left to right since the right vessel is higher, shouldn't?
What does it happen if we restrict the pipe distance d, given that some water is always able to flow through it ( Resistance it's not infinity )?
If we restrict the pipe distance d shouldn't pressure exerted by the water coming from the restricetd pipe too weak respect at point A to overcome the presssure exerted by the right vessel's water column?
If this is correct, shouldn't flow stop,or reverse and then stop?
 

Attachments

  • wI3VI.png
    wI3VI.png
    6.5 KB · Views: 1,511
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Gabriele99 said:
If we restrict the pipe distance d shouldn't pressure exerted by the water coming from the restricetd pipe too weak respect at point A to overcome the presssure exerted by the right vessel's water column?
What is important is the difference in pressure form the left and the right.
 
  • #3
Increasing resistance reduces the flow rate at a given pressure differential. In order to reduce the flow rate to zero you would need an infinite resistance.
 
  • Like
Likes Lord Jestocost
  • #4
A friend learned the hard way that water flows downhill regardless of the length of the pipe. It was a setup similar to your sketch. The pipe was 4800 feet of 2 inch PVC, and the elevation difference 10 feet. The liquid was chlorine dioxide in water solution. There was a pump on the supply tank, and several flow control valves on the discharge end. After the first startup test, he shut the pump off, and left. The flow control valves, in a different building, went full open. Part of the paper mill had to be evacuated until a valve was closed and the vapors cleared out. But he learned that water flows downhill, even through long pipes.

The math for this situation is shown in a Moody chart. The math still works for long, small diameter pipes with low pressure differences. The Reynolds number just gets smaller. A very large pipe would be analyzed using the Bernoulli equation.
 
  • #5
Gabriele99 said:
In the first scenario, the pipe distance d doesn't get restricted so the pressure at point A should be the pressure exerted by the left vessel's water column minus the pressure exerted by the right vessel's water column.

On what basis have you made this statement. It makes no sense to me.
 

1. Will increasing resistance cause water to stop flowing completely?

No, increasing resistance will not cause water to stop flowing completely. Resistance only slows down the flow of water, but it will not stop it completely. The water will continue to flow, but at a slower rate.

2. What factors affect the resistance of water flow?

The resistance of water flow is affected by several factors, including the diameter of the pipe, the length of the pipe, the viscosity of the water, and the temperature of the water. These factors can all impact the resistance and flow rate of water.

3. How does resistance impact the pressure of water flow?

Resistance and pressure are directly related. As resistance increases, the pressure of water flow decreases. This is because the water has to work harder to overcome the resistance, resulting in a decrease in pressure.

4. Can we control the resistance of water flow?

Yes, we can control the resistance of water flow by changing the factors that affect it. For example, we can change the diameter of the pipe or the temperature of the water to adjust the resistance and flow rate.

5. Is there a maximum resistance that water can overcome?

Yes, there is a maximum resistance that water can overcome. This is determined by the strength of the pump or other mechanism that is pushing the water through the system. If the resistance is too high, the pump may not be able to overcome it and the water flow will decrease or stop completely.

Suggested for: Will water flow ever stop if we increase resistance?

Replies
2
Views
637
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
408
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
763
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
576
Replies
5
Views
824
Back
Top