Covariant Definition and 345 Threads

So given this identity: [V,W] = \nablaVW-\nablaWV ^^I got the above identity from O'Neil 5.1 #9. From this I'm not sure how to make the jump with vector functions, or if it is even possible to apply that definition to a vector function [xu,xv].

Hi everyone, have a question about covariant, coordinate independent quantities in GR. Reading Kolb and Turner's book The Early Universe one can find the Boltzmann equation in a GR setting. Now, one of the terms in that equation is - \Gamma_{\alpha \beta}^\gamma p^\alpha p^\beta...

I'm trying to teach myself GR from Wald's General Relativity, and it's very tough going. I do have basic knowledge of differential geometry, but I think my geometric intuition is next to nonexistent. I'd very much appreciate some help in understanding several basic questions, or pointers to...

hey, I'm getting really confused with something. If i have the covariant derivative of say, constant * exp(2f), is this equivalent to 2*constant*exp(2f) * cov.deriv. of f ?

hello! just a quick question, does the covariant derivative of the metric give zero even when the indices(one of the indices) of the metric are(is) raised? also another question not entirely related, does the covariant deriv. of exp(2 phi) where phi is the field, also give zero or not...

I get in essence what the covariant derivative is, and what it does, but I am having trouble with the definition, of all things.\nabla_{\alpha}T^{\beta\gamma}=\frac{\partial{T^{\beta\gamma}}}{\partial{x^{\alpha}}}+\Gamma^{\beta}_{d\alpha}T^{d\gamma}+\Gamma^{\gamma}_{d\alpha}T^{\beta d} Im good...

Homework Statement I know this is an easy question, I just can't seem to grasp what I am actually doing: Let M be a manifold. Let Va be contravariant, and Wa be covariant. Show that \mu=VaWa Homework Equations (couldn't get Latex to work consistently, sorry) (1) V 'a = (dx 'a /...

For starters, there is the covariant vector (E/c, p). Dividing by the scalar invariant, h_bar/2∏, where k is the propagation vector, there is (ω/c, k). There must be a significant number of covariant objects in electromagnetism...

The title says it all, basically I'm trying to figure out what the difference is between the two tensors (levi-civita) that are 3rd rank. Do they expand out in matrix form differently?

Hey there, For quite some time I've been wondering now whether there's a well-understandable difference between the Lie and the covariant derivative. Although they're defined in fundamentally different ways, they're both (in a special case, at least) standing for the directional derivative of...

Hi, How can we represent covariant and contravariant vectors on curved spacetime diagrams? How can we draw these vectors on a spacetime diagram? Contravariant vectors are really vectors, therefore we can represent them on the diagram with directed line elements. Covariant vectors are...

Reading Roger Penrose's The Road to Reality, I wondered what is the relationship/difference between these? Can one be expressed simply in terms of the other? The exterior derivative seems to be only defined for form fields. He says the covariant derivative of a scalar field (0-form field) is the...

we have studied in Tensor's analysis that there are two kinds of tensors that usually used in transformation. one is Contravariant & covariant. what is the difference between them and and why they are same for Rectangular coordinates?

Homework Statement This two-part problem is from O'Neill's Elementary Differential Geometry, section 2.5. Let W be a vector field defined on a region containing a regular curve a(t). Then W(a(t)) is a vector field on a(t) called the restriction of W to a(t). 1. Prove that Cov W w.r.t...

Homework Statement I have a few introductory problems dealing with proofs of tensor properties, and one about a transformation from rectangular to spherical coordinates. If someone has the time and inclination to help out this week, I can email you the specific problem set. (I'd prefer not...

Homework Statement Is the covariant derivative of a Christoffel symbol equal to zero? It seems like it would be since it is composed of nothing but metrics, and the covariant derivative of any metric is zero, right?

I often meet the question whether the (physical) space is 'covariant' or 'contravariant'. I once replied to that question with: Space is space. The COMPONENTS of a tensor are covariant/contravariant if the basis is CHOSEN TO BE contravariant/covariant. As far as I know tensors the...

Hi, everyone I was playing with the coordinate transformations and metric tensors to get a feeling of how it all behaves, and got stuck with some basic problem I am hoping you can help me with. So, I have defined a coordinate system (s,t), with the s axis going along the x-axis in the...

Hi Now I'm studying Electromagnetic we started to study the EM with the Covariant method (contravariant method too) we use cgs units almost of time so I ask if someone can give a hand to with recomendation to where study the notation and the mathematical approach of EM by covariant method (EM...

I was noodling about with 4-vectors and Maxwell's Equations when I took it upon myself to figure out how to write the field of a point charge in terms of 4-vectors, since I'd never seen it before (if anyone knows a book that has this I'd be happy to see it). It's actually relatively simple...

Hi everybody, I have this simple question. ¿Where can I find the covariant maxwell equations in materials?. I've already one and proved they correctly represent the non-homogene maxwell equations, is this one \partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu}+\Pi^{\mu\nu}A_{\nu}=J^{\mu}_{libre} with the tensor...

Homework Statement I've been reading a textbook on tensor analysis for a while. The book uses the conclusion of "covariant differentiation commutes with contraction" directly and I searched around and found most people just use the conclusion without proof.Homework Equations For example...

Are potentials appearing in the Maxwell equations the components of a contravariant vector or a covariant vector? Let us be specific. metric is (+,-,-,-) . Let us write the potentials which appear in the Maxwell equations as \Phi and \vec{A}=(A_x,A_y,A_z) Is it then the case that...

When calculating the derivative of a vector field X at a point p of a smooth manifold M, one uses the Lie derivative, which gives the derivative of X in the direction of another vector field Y at the same point p of the manifold. If the manifold is a Riemannian manifold (that is, equipped...

A random question - Does the Riemman tensor and the covariant derivate commute? a yes/no answer would suffice, but any explanation would be welcome:) From the equations, it looks as though they do for flat metrics - but if we have other manifolds, it seems to me that the Christoffel...

Is this the right way to think about the covariant derivative, and if not, what improvements would you suggest to visualize the meaning of the covariant derivative? (1)\mbox{ }\vec{e}_i(x')=\vec{e}_i(x)+\frac{\partial \vec{e}_i(x)}{\partial x^j}dx^j...

Heisenberg's uncertainty relations are not covariant under Lorentz transformation. That means they don't have the same form in any inertial frame. So, how to modify these relations to leave them invariant in form under a Lorentz transformation ?

Hello everyone, While studying properties of Riemann and tensor and Killing vectors, I found this notation/concept that I'm not sure of it's meaning. What does it mean to have a covariant derivative, using semi-colon notation, showing in upper index position. Is it just a matter of raising...

Hello! I registered here today because I'm quite curious about the covariant derivative, and although I've consulted several texts on the subject (and wikipedia, and other locations), I've found it somewhat difficult to piece together a visual understanding of the covariant derivative. The...

In the Wolfram Mathworld section on spherical coordinates there's given a list of nine covariant derivatives. The derivatives are given with respect to radius, azmuth, and zenith using the usual symbols r, theta and phi. The question is: what would be examples of the vectors whose derivatives...

How do I show that a Vector field X on \Re^{3} is tangent to a Cylinder in \Re^{3}?

Hi everyone, I'm trying to work through section 86 of Landau and Lifgarbagez volume 2 (The Classical Theory of Fields). Basically, I am unable to get equation (86.6) from equations (86.4) and (86.5). I've detailed my working/question in the attached jpg file. I would appreciate any inputs...

I've seen read a lot of books where they use different sign conventions for the metric and the covariant derivative. I'd like to ask the physics community the following questions: I've seen both, the (+, -, -, -) and (-, +, +, +), conventions used for the metric, and I've also seen both...

I'm having some trouble breaking into tensors. What is specifically bewildering me is contravariant vs. covariant indices. Could someone please explain this to me (or link me)? I barely understand what each one means in its own right, let alone the differences between the two.

This comes from Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics 3rd edition, page 613. He finds the Green's function for the covariant form of the wave equation as: D(z) = -1/(2\pi)^{4}\int d^{4}k\: \frac{e^{-ik\cdot z}}{k\cdot k} Where z = x - x' the 4 vector difference, k\cdot z = k_0z_0 -...

I calculated the christoffel symbols and know that I have them right. I want to take the covariant derivative of the basis vector field e_{r} on the curve s(t) = (a, t/a). I differentiate it and get s' = (0, 1/a) and according to the metric, this is a unit vector because a will always be equal...

Homework Statement The problem concerns how to transform a covariant differentiation. Using this formula for covariant differentiation and demanding that it is a (1,1) tensor: \nabla_cX^a=\partial_cX^a+\Gamma^a_{bc}X^b it should be proven that \Gamma'^a_{bc}=...

A little stuck while working through a derivation. Hope someone can help. Homework Statement Starting from -\xi^c(\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{db}+\Gamma^d_{cb}g_{ad})+\partial_b\xi^dg_{ad}+\partial_a\xi^cg_{cb}=0 I need to obtain the Killing equations, i.e...

I'm teaching myself about connections and came across something I am not completely sure about. The text I am using defines a connection as taking in two vector fields and outputting a vector field. However, later when discussing covariant derivatives along a curve I see this equation...

Hi, I'm having problems following a derivation for the covariant derivative. I've shown the line where I'm having trouble: http://img15.imageshack.us/img15/49/covariantderivative.jpg The general argument being used is that if the covariant derivative must follow the product rule it can...

Rovelli has given his team and himself just seven months to advance LQG to a new stage. Why do I call this "throwing the eagle"? Because a Roman general would on occasion hurl his legion's eagle standard into the opposing army's midst, confident his side could rout their foes the recover it...

Homework Statement For a perfect fluid verify that the spatial components of T^{\mu \nu};_{\nu} = 0 in the Newtonian limit reduce to (\rho v^{i}),_{t} + (\rho v^{i} v^{j}),_{j} + P,_{i} + \rho \phi ,_{i} Homework Equations Metric ds^{2} = -(1+2 \phi )dt^{2} + (1-2 \phi) (dx^{2} +...

Hello once again. I'm trying to understand the relation between the superspace representation of the SUSY generators Q_\alpha,\overline Q_{\dot\beta} and the covariant derivatives on superspaces D_\alpha, \overline D_{\dot\beta}: Q_\alpha = \frac{\partial}{\partial\theta^\alpha} -...

Could anyone tell me about the covariant derivative with respect to the connection?

Is this correct? \nabla _{\vec{p}} \vec{p} = (\nabla_a \vec{p} ) p^a =< (\nabla_a p^0 ) p^a, (\nabla_a p^1 ) p^a , (\nabla_a p^2 ) p^a, (\nabla_a p^3 ) p^a > (where the a's are summed from 0 to 3)

in my GR book, it claims that integral of a covariant divergence reduces to a surface term. I'm not sure if I see this... So, is it true that: \int_{\Sigma}\sqrt{-g}\nabla_{\mu} V^{\mu} d^nx= \int_{\partial\Sigma}\sqrt{-g} V^{\mu} d^{n-1}x if so, how do I make sense of the d^{n-1}x term? would...

...of the four-momentum vector. Why is the energy of a particle identified with p0 instead of p0? Is there a theoretical basis for this, or was it simply observed that p0 is conserved in a larger set of circumstances?

In developing the Yang-Mills Lagrangian, Wikipedia defines the covariant derivative as \ D_ \mu = \partial _\mu + A _\mu (x) . Is A_mu to be taken as a 1-form, so that \ D _\mu \Phi = \partial _\mu \Phi + A _\mu (x) or an operator on \Phi, such that \ D _\mu \Phi = \partial...

Homework Statement Let e_{i} with i=1,2 be an orthonormal basis in two-dimensional Euclidean space ie. the metric is g_{ij} = \delta _{ij}. In the this basis the vector v has contravariant components v^{i} = (1,2). Consider the new basis e_{1}^{'} = 5e_{1} - 2e_{2} e_{2}^{'} = 3e_{1} - e_{2}...

If there is a contravariant vector v=aa+bb+cc with a reciprocal vector system where [abc]v=xb×c+ya×c+za×b would the vector expressed in the reciprocal vector system be a covariant vector? Is there any connection between the reciprocal vector system of a covariant vector and a...