Adiabatic, Ideal gas, changing heat capacity, work calculation

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the adiabatic expansion of propane vapor, specifically calculating work (W), change in entropy (Delta S), and the differences between reversible and irreversible processes. Participants express confusion about calculating work in irreversible processes, questioning whether it is zero and how it relates to changes in kinetic energy and internal energy. They discuss the application of the Ideal Gas Law and the implications of varying heat capacities during adiabatic expansion. The conversation emphasizes the need to understand the relationship between internal energy and work in both reversible and irreversible scenarios, particularly when heat capacity is not constant. Overall, the complexities of thermodynamic calculations in adiabatic processes are highlighted.
dhoyda
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
1. Propane vapour (1kmol) at a pressure of 40 bar and 230 C expands adiabatically to 0.25 bar and 95 C. Determine a)W, b)Delta S, c)The amount of work obtained if the expansion were done reversibly from the same initial conditions to the final pressure of 0.25bar



2. I am not sure how to calculate work for a irreversible process. Is it zero, a gas that expands adiabatically in an irreversible process loses no kinetic energy right? so then work has to be zero cause heat is zero as well right? I am not sure about delta S either, I think in reversible delta S is zero but in irreversible its always increasing? I think there's is a formula for delta S for ideal This stuff can get confusing, can anyone help me?



The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
dhoyda said:
1. Propane vapour (1kmol) at a pressure of 40 bar and 230 C expands adiabatically to 0.25 bar and 95 C. Determine a)W, b)Delta S, c)The amount of work obtained if the expansion were done reversibly from the same initial conditions to the final pressure of 0.25bar
2. I am not sure how to calculate work for a irreversible process. Is it zero, a gas that expands adiabatically in an irreversible process loses no kinetic energy right? so then work has to be zero cause heat is zero as well right? I am not sure about delta S either, I think in reversible delta S is zero but in irreversible its always increasing? I think there's is a formula for delta S for ideal This stuff can get confusing, can anyone help me?
W = \int PdV

What is the change in volume? How would you determine that? What is the relationship between P V and T?

AM
 
Change in volume would be determined by the Ideal Gas law. Would you replace P with nRT/V? In this case what is constant because the gas is going to new temperature and volume. Is Temp constant when you replace P?
 
If you replace the P from the integration formula a few posts earlier with (nRT/V) and integrate the formula, you will get W=nRT*ln[V(init)/v(fin)]
 
the temperature is changing. I don't see how you can do that. I think I figured it out. From the first law. dU = dQ + dW. If its adiabatic the dQ = 0 and dU = dW.

We can say dU = C*dT for an ideal gas.
 
matthew1991 said:
If you replace the P from the integration formula a few posts earlier with (nRT/V) and integrate the formula, you will get W=nRT*ln[V(init)/v(fin)]
That is only the case if T remains constant. But since work is being done and there is no heat flow, internal energy and therefore T must decrease.

AM
 
sorry, that was isothermal. adiabatic expansion work can be found by W = (3/2)nR(deltaT)
 
did I figure it out Andrew that internal energy is equal to work and we can say dU = C*dT for Ideal gas.
 
dhoyda said:
Change in volume would be determined by the Ideal Gas law.
In looking at this again, you can only determine the work from the change in volume if this is a reversible process. You have to first determine the change in internal energy. What is the relationship between change in internal energy and work in an adiabatic process?

AM
 
  • #10
dhoyda said:
did I figure it out Andrew that internal energy is equal to work and we can say dU = C*dT for Ideal gas.
Yes. Change in internal energy = - Work done by gas. dU = nC_vdT

AM
 
  • #11
this is confusing. It is an irreversible process. I do not have a constant heat capacity. We defined in class a reversible work formula for adiabatic conditions with a constant heat capacity. How do I use that if my heat capacity is not constant.
 
  • #12
so basically the work from a reversible adiabatic process in an ideal gas with a non constant heat capacity is the same as the work in an irreversible process in an ideal gas with a non constant heat capacity
 
  • #13
but I thought that if a process is reversible. no work is done because it goes back to its original state. but then i remember that free expansion of gas is an irreversible process so the process can't be reversible. I feel like I am going in circles.
 
  • #14
dhoyda said:
this is confusing. It is an irreversible process. I do not have a constant heat capacity. We defined in class a reversible work formula for adiabatic conditions with a constant heat capacity. How do I use that if my heat capacity is not constant.
How does the heat capacity vary with temperature? Plug that into:

\Delta U = \int nC_vdTAM
 
  • #15
the heat capacity is a function of temperature. Pretty easy integration. its like. Cp/R = A + BT + CT^2. Where A, B, C are constants.
 
  • #16
dhoyda said:
the heat capacity is a function of temperature. Pretty easy integration. its like. Cp/R = A + BT + CT^2. Where A, B, C are constants.
You are determining internal energy: you must use Cv not Cp. Cv = Cp-R

AM
 
Back
Top