Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

All number of bosons in case of Bose condensation

  1. Oct 9, 2009 #1
    All number of bosons in case of Bose condensation is

    [tex]N=N_0+\sum_{\vec{p}\neq 0}N_{\vec{p}}[/tex]

    I found in one book that [tex]N_0=\hat{b}^+_0\hat{b}_0[/tex]

    In that book author say that [tex]\hat{b}^+_0\hat{b}_0=N_0[/tex] and [tex]\hat{b}_0\hat{b}^+_0=N_0+1\approx N_0[/tex]

    so

    [tex][\hat{b}_0,\hat{b}^+_0]\approx 0[/tex]

    and from there

    [tex]\hat{b}_0=\hat{b}^+_0=\sqrt{N_0}[/tex]

    Is this true? Little seems ridiculous to me because I do not know how he could get

    [tex]\hat{b}_0\hat{b}^+_0=N_0+1\approx N_0[/tex]


    without using

    [tex][\hat{b}_0,\hat{b}^+_0]=1[/tex]

    So

    [tex]1\approx 0[/tex]

    :)

    Am I
    right?

    I have problem also with calling for example [tex]N_{\vec{p}}=\hat{b}^+_{\vec{p}}\hat{b}_{\vec{p}}[/tex] because [tex]N_{\vec{p}}[/tex] is eigen -value of this operator!
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Oct 9, 2009 #2
    Re: Superfluidity

    By
    [tex]
    \hat{b}_0\hat{b}^+_0=N_0+1\approx N_0
    [/tex]
    it is implicitly ment that the approximation holds when you act on the wavefunction. So if [tex]|\Psi\rangle[/tex] represents the wavefunction, you normally have:


    [tex] \hat{b}^+_0\hat{b}_0|\Psi\rangle = N_0|\Psi\rangle[/tex]
    and using the commutation relation for the bosonic operators:
    [tex] \hat{b}_0\hat{b}^+_0|\Psi\rangle = (N_0+1)|\Psi\rangle[/tex]

    but because [tex]N_0[/tex] is so big we can approximate these as equal.

    So the authors are indeed sloppy, and strictly speaking you're right by saying that you should distinguish between operators and numbers. But in this case the eigenvalue is so big, we are allowed to replace the number operator by [tex]N_0[/tex]. And for good reason, because it simplifies a lot!
     
  4. Oct 9, 2009 #3
    Re: Superfluidity

    (continuing xepma) Put in other words, when two operators are approximately exchangible, they reduce to conventional numbers !
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook




Similar Discussions: All number of bosons in case of Bose condensation
Loading...