Electric field at a point affected by two charges

10 replies · 7K views · last reply
pbj_sweg
Messages
12
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


(a) What is the strength of the electric field at the position indicated by the dot?
(b) What is the direction of the electric field at the position indicated by the dot? Specify direction as an angle measured ccw from the positive x-axis.

Diagram of two positive point charges, Q1 at top left and Q2 at bottom left, 10 cm apart vertically, with a dot 5.0 cm to the right of Q1, and x and y axes at lower right.


##Q_{1} = 4.0 C##
##Q_{2} = 9.0 C##

Homework Equations


$$\vec{E} = \frac{Kq}{r^2}$$
$$\text{Pythagorean's Theorem:}~a^2+b^2=c^2$$
$$K = 9\times10^{-9}$$

The Attempt at a Solution


(a) ##\vec{E_{1}}## = effect of ##Q_{1}## on point
##\vec{E_{2}}## = effect of ##Q_{2}## on point

##\vec{E_{1}} = \frac{KQ_{1}}{r^2} = \frac{K(4~C)}{r^2} = \frac{K(4~C)}{0.05^2} = 1.44\times10^{13} \frac{N}{C}##
##E_{1}\hat{i} = 1.44\times10^{13} \frac{N}{C}##
##E_{1}\hat{j} = 0 ~ \frac{N}{C}##

distance between ##Q_{2}~## and the point was found with Pythagorean's Theorem to be ~0.118 m.
##\vec{E_{2}} = \frac{KQ_{2}}{r^2} = \frac{K(9~C)}{r^2} = \frac{K(9~C)}{0.118^2} = 5.8\times10^{12} \frac{N}{C}##

Breaking ##\vec{E_{2}}## into it's components:
##E_{2}\hat{i} = E_{2}(\sin(\theta)) = 2.596\times10^{12} \frac{N}{C}##
The angle is between the long leg of the triangle and the hypotenuse and was found using tan(0.05/0.1) to get 26.57°.

##E_{2}\hat{j} = E_{2}(\cos(\theta)) = 5.192\times10^{12} \frac{N}{C}##

##E\hat{i} = E_{1}\hat{i} + E_{2}\hat{i} = 1.44\times10^{13} + 2.596\times10^{12} = 1.696\times10^{13}##
##E\hat{j} = E_{1}\hat{j} + E_{2}\hat{j} = 0 + 5.192\times10^{12} = 5.192\times10^{12}##

##| \vec E | = \sqrt{(1.696\times10^{13})^{2}+(5.192\times10^{13})^{2}} = 1.77\times10^{13}##

(b) direction of electric field is ##\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{5.192\times10^{12}}{1.696\times10^{13}}\right)## = 17.01°.

Both parts of the question are incorrect, and I'm 99% sure the second part is incorrect because the components of the electric field on the point are incorrect. Could someone please point out what I've done wrong? Thank you!
 
pbj_sweg said:
$$K = 9\times10^{-9}$$

Is this a typo? Or did you use this value?
 
Recalculate your distance value for Q2. You should keep a few extra decimal places in intermediate values such as this distance. This is to prevent rounding/truncation errors from creeping into your significant figures. Only round at the end for your final results.
 
Student100 said:
Is this a typo? Or did you use this value?
Sorry, that's a typo. It's to the 9th power. I used the correct value.
 
Last edited:
gneill said:
Recalculate your distance value for Q2. You should keep a few extra decimal places in intermediate values such as this distance. This is to prevent rounding/truncation errors from creeping into your significant figures. Only round at the end for your final results.
Correct distance should be 0.1118 meters instead. I got my final answer to be ##1.82\times10^{13}## which is still wrong. I also didn't round until my final answer. Is there something wrong with my method instead?
 
pbj_sweg said:
Correct distance should be 0.1118 meters instead. I got my final answer to be ##1.82\times10^{13}## which is still wrong. I also didn't round until my final answer. Is there something wrong with my method instead?
Your result looks good. They may be quibbling about the significant figures though.

Also, what was your angle for the field direction?

Diagram of two positive point charges, Q1 = 4.0 C at upper left and Q2 = 9.0 C at lower left, 10 cm apart vertically, with a field point to the right. Dashed lines show 5.0 cm horizontal separation; vectors E1, E2 and resultant E are drawn, with angles theta and phi marked and alpha between E and E1.
 
Last edited:
gneill said:
Your result looks good. They may be quibbling about the significant figures though.

Also, what was your angle for the field direction?
I initially got an angle of 17.01° but after recalculating, using the picture you provided, I got 63.25°. Both are wrong :frown:. The program usually gives some kind of notification if the issue is with sig figs. Frankly, I think my technique is correct, so maybe MasteringPhysics just has the incorrect answer?
 
Your method for calculating the angle was okay. My figure shows the original field contributions by Q1 and Q2, not the net field. I probably should have added that (let me go back and change the figure). The angle should be a bit larger than 17°, but nowhere close to 63°.
 
gneill said:
Your method for calculating the angle was okay. My figure shows the original field contributions by Q1 and Q2, not the net field. I probably should have added that (let me go back and change the figure). The angle should be a bit larger than 17°, but nowhere close to 63°.
I see. Is there anything else wrong with my calculations? Thank you so much for your help!
 
gneill said:
I don't see any other problems.
Thank you, seems like the problem is just incorrect.