How to Calculate Sag in Terms of Weight, Pulleys, and Distance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter leonkhasi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Pulleys
AI Thread Summary
To calculate the sag (d) in a pulley system with weights w1 and w, the equilibrium of forces must be analyzed, particularly the tension in the wire. The relationship between the weights and the horizontal distance (L) is crucial, leading to the equation d = 1/2L/√((2w/w1)^2 - 1). It is emphasized that both weights are not equal, and the tension in the wire must be consistent throughout the system. Understanding the angles involved and drawing force vectors are essential steps in deriving the correct sag equation. The discussion highlights the importance of equilibrium in solving for sag in pulley systems.
leonkhasi
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Snapshot.jpg

Homework Statement


A pulley to which is attached w1 rides on a wire that is attached to a support at the left and that passes over a pulley on the right to weight w.the horizontal distance between the left support and the pulley is L.Express the sag d at the center in terms of w,w1 and L.
The answer is d = 1/2L/√(2w/w1)^2-1.Please help. how do you arrive at the equation for the sag d. sag is the sink or downward bulge.
-

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello Leon, :welcome:

The answer to your question is: make a drawing and identify all the forces that play a role. Then proceed with working out the free body diagrams of the relevant parts -- that are in a steady state, so they must be in equilibrium. In yout list of relevant equations :rolleyes: you should have relationships that you can apply to that equilibrium state. Post an attempt at solution, even if you get stuck (it is one of the conditions to get help in PF, see the guidelines)
 
  • Like
Likes leonkhasi
i understand that w=1/2w1 is it not?
 
No they are not necessarily the same, that's why the two weights are differentiated in the answer. BvU is requesting you to upload your attempt at solving the question, please do that so that we may help you :approve:
 
  • Like
Likes leonkhasi
ouch I'm stuck.:frown:
 
leonkhasi said:
i understand that w=1/2w1 is it not?
You can check for yourself by considering the limit case: For d >> L it's somewhat true, but the smaller d is, the less it's true: Why should it be true for d ##\rightarrow## 0 ?
 
Good picture. What forces work on W1 ? What forces work on W ? what force is in common ?
 
[for d →0 i must say w is maximum.or i must say w1 is zero.
 
Snapshot1.jpg
I'm just guessing how to arrive at the solution but i think its nowhere at all close to the solution :wideeyed:
 
  • #10
How about draw some forces? In particular, tension will be useful here.
 
  • #11
leonkhasi said:
i understand that w=1/2w1 is it not?
No, but the moving pulley might be at the middle.
 
  • #12
is d=tanθ⋅L/2? how do i determine how θ changes when i do not know basedwhich of the weights are heavier?
 
  • #13
You are asked to say something about d at equilibrium.
W is heavier than W1
##1\over 2##W is not right for the tension in the wire.
 
  • Like
Likes leonkhasi
  • #14
leonkhasi said:
is d=tanθ⋅L/2?
Yes,

Both weights are in equilibrium. The forces the string exerts on them is the tension in the string. Draw the force vectors both at w and w1. They need to add up to zero.
 
  • Like
Likes leonkhasi
  • #15
do we have to show the equilibrium of the forces at the point at the center ?
 
  • #16
Hello there
is w1.g=2t1cosθ? and wat about should t2=w=t1? where t1 and t2 are tensions and should t1=t2 for tension tobe same in the system since force is transmitted on the same rope.
 
Last edited:
  • #17
leonkhasi said:
Hello there
is w1.g=2t1cosθ? and wat about should t2=w=t1? where t1 and t2 are tensions and should t1=t2 for tension tobe same in the system since force is transmitted on the same rope.
Yes, t1=t2=w. If theta is the angle the string makes with the horizontal then w1.g=2t1cosθ is not true.
 
  • #18
i assume θ is the angle between the sag d and the hypotenuse..
 
  • #19
leonkhasi said:
i assume θ is the angle between the sag d and the hypotenuse..
Then your equation d=tanθ⋅L/2 is not true . (Post #12)
 
  • Like
Likes leonkhasi
  • #20
if i assume the angle θ like i mention then d=L/2/tan θ yes..but i guess i won't arrive at the solution so i must take θ as angle between hypotenuse and horizontal and d=tanθ.L/2. am i right?
 
  • #21
leonkhasi said:
if i assume the angle θ like i mention then d=L/2/tan θ yes..but i guess i won't arrive at the solution so i must take θ as angle between hypotenuse and horizontal and d=tanθ.L/2. am i right?
You can use any angle, but do it consequently.
 
Back
Top