Is the coil the only viable shape for an electric engine ?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the use of coils in electric engines, particularly in low voltage and low current applications. It questions whether coils are the only effective shape for inducing current in DC and AC motors, considering alternatives like rings or cylinders. The efficiency of coils is attributed to their ability to increase magnetic flux with the square of the number of turns, allowing for significant flux with minimal current. Various motor designs, including linear and disk motors, demonstrate that different geometries can be effective, as seen in historical examples like the Faraday Disk. Ultimately, while coils are common, other shapes and configurations can also serve as viable options in electric motor design.
zunf
Messages
8
Reaction score
2
Hi, I'm an hobbyist
right now I'm into electric engines, simple engines for low voltage and low current applications; I have noticed that there are many variations about how and what an electric engine can do even considering only DC motors, but basically all the engines that I have examined up until now have something in common, and that is the presence of a coil, a copper coil, used as a conductor in the internals of the engine itself .

I wonder if such twisted copper cables are the only way to induce current in a DC / AC engine, for example can you replace a coil with a ring of copper ? A cylinder ?

What is the physical explanation that motivates the use of a coil and what makes it efficient compared to other shapes / solutions ?

After all the pulse of current is given by the change in the magnetic flux, which basically refers to the rotating parts of your engine, up until now I haven't found any explanation as to why it's an optimal thing to use a coil rather than a cylinder, or a sphere, or any other piece of geometry in metal form .
There are formulas that dictate the ins and outs of an optimal coil given the specs of an electrical engine ?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
There are lots of motor topologies. There are disk motors, linear motors, solid plate motors, etc.

The usual reason coils are used is that the flux increases with the square of the number of turns. This gives lots of flux for little current.

Linear motors are used in rail guns. Disk type motors are lightweight and cheap using traces on PCB boards as their conductors. The Faraday Disk was the first electric generator and used a solid plate.

A Van de Graaff generator doesn't even use metal in its moving parts. It relies on the electric field rather than the magnetic field.
 
  • Like
Likes OCR
Thread 'Weird near-field phenomenon I get in my EM simulation'
I recently made a basic simulation of wire antennas and I am not sure if the near field in my simulation is modeled correctly. One of the things that worry me is the fact that sometimes I see in my simulation "movements" in the near field that seems to be faster than the speed of wave propagation I defined (the speed of light in the simulation). Specifically I see "nodes" of low amplitude in the E field that are quickly "emitted" from the antenna and then slow down as they approach the far...
Hello dear reader, a brief introduction: Some 4 years ago someone started developing health related issues, apparently due to exposure to RF & ELF related frequencies and/or fields (Magnetic). This is currently becoming known as EHS. (Electromagnetic hypersensitivity is a claimed sensitivity to electromagnetic fields, to which adverse symptoms are attributed.) She experiences a deep burning sensation throughout her entire body, leaving her in pain and exhausted after a pulse has occurred...
Back
Top