Pulleys - Relationship between mass and aceleration

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the relationship between mass and acceleration in a pulley system, specifically how to derive the equation ax=2ay. The original poster attempts to solve the problem using linear equations but struggles with the correct application of the "conserving string" principle, which dictates that the length of the string remains constant. They initially arrive at an incorrect conclusion regarding the accelerations of the two masses. Participants clarify that understanding the movement of one mass directly affects the other, leading to the correct ratio of accelerations. The conversation emphasizes the importance of the string conservation law in solving such dynamics problems.
AlonsoDeMaria
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
1. Homework Statement
upload_2015-9-22_9-44-48.png

upload_2015-9-22_10-3-21.png
upload_2015-9-22_10-7-6.png


2. Homework Equations
How to get ax=2ay?

3. The Attempt at a Solution
a=10m/s2

And the solution I found was a=2m/s2

I found this at : http://www.physicstutorials.org/home/exams/dynamics-exams/142-dynamics-exam1
 

Attachments

  • upload_2015-9-22_10-2-56.png
    upload_2015-9-22_10-2-56.png
    5 KB · Views: 446
  • upload_2015-9-22_10-7-10.png
    upload_2015-9-22_10-7-10.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 431
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
So, I see you pointing at an exam solution. I don't see your attempt.

The solution you pointed at has a typo. And the explanation for it is wonky. You get the ratio of acceleration of the two masses by conserving string. That is, the string does not change length.
 
Oh, I am sorry. I didn't want to write all my attempt.

This was my full attempt
I used linear equations to solve this part:
Following the exam solution:
2T-10m=m*ax
T-10m=m*ay (I multiplied this by 2) and got 2T-20m=2m*ay

Then I tried to make a comparison between the accelerations, so I deleted "T" subtracting the first and second equations:
2T-10m - (2T-20m)=m*ax-2m*ay
10m=m(ax-2ay)

Then 10=(ax-2ay). Then, ay=(10-ax)/2
I replaced ay on the second equation:
T-10m=m*(10-ax)/2
Then, 2T-20m=10m - m*ax
2T-30m= - m*ax
-2T+30m= m*ax
Then I took the first equation and replaced m*a
2T-10m = -2T + 30m
4t=40m , T=10m

And then
20m-10m=m*ax, 10m=m*ax, ax=10m/s2

I need to how to get that ax=2ay
And if my answer was correct.
 
Did you read to the bottom of my post? You get the ratio of accelerations by noting that the length of string does not change. Suppose that the mass X moves up by 1 unit. How far down will Y move?
 
2 units.

I am checking all again.
 
So I was reading that ay= - 2 ax.
And the answer is 2m/s2

What did I do wrong on my process?
 
AlonsoDeMaria said:
10m=m(ax-2ay)

Then 10=(ax-2ay). Then, ay=(10-ax)/2

So the correct was to write: ay=(ax-10)/2
Even so, using that leads to nowhere.

So the only possibility to solve that was just knowing "conserving string" law.

Is there any other way to solve that without that law?
(Or better for me to create another thread?)

Thank you very much for your help.
 
Back
Top