Engineering Solve a Circuit Problem: Node-Voltage Method

  • Thread starter Thread starter Novean
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circuit Method
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a circuit problem using the node-voltage method, with specific attention to the role of a 150 Volt source that seems to be omitted in the solution provided by the textbook. The user has attempted to ground certain nodes and create node-voltage equations but is confused by the textbook's answer, which states the power absorbed is 23.68 W. There is a debate about whether the 150 Volt source should be included in the calculations, as it appears to affect the current through the bottom resistor. The conversation also touches on the interaction between voltage and current sources in the circuit, emphasizing the need for clarity in representing these elements in node-voltage equations. Overall, the thread seeks assistance in understanding the correct approach to the problem and the implications of the omitted voltage source.
Novean
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Here's a link to a picture of the problem:
http://i.imgur.com/zMAiR.png

V(delta) is above the 7 Ohm resistor, and V(x) is described by the positive Node between the 7 Ohm resistor and the 5 Amp Source, and the negative Node between the 9 ohm resistor and 150 Volt Source.

i(omega) runs down the 4 Ohm source on the left.

The top dependent voltage source is 3*V(x)
The left dependent voltage source is 5*i(omega)
The right dependent voltage source is 13*v(delta)

Homework Equations



I advise to use the node-voltage method to solve this. Plus, it will help me understand it since that and the Current-mesh are the tools our professor expects us to know for the coming exam.

The Attempt at a Solution



I have spent far too many hours and countless papers and methods trying to solve this problem in a way that gave me the answer that the book has. I've begun to think that the book may be wrong in regards to their answer?

Anyway, I'll detail my usual procedure:

Using the node-voltage method:

I chose to ground the node in the top between the 1 Ohm and 2 Ohm resistors. Since a wire connect that node to the one under it, I concluded that both of those nodes are grounded. I pretty much erased that wire and connected both nodes into one.

I then created node-voltage equations, and use a program called MATLAB to solve matrices that I created out of the linear equations (As my professor has told us to do for every problem).

The answer in the answer manual says that the Power absorbed is 23.68 W.
They show a procedure to doing it, but they always skip the 150 Volt source in their equations. It's as if it doesn't exist. Why is this?

If someone could either do it and get the right answer, or tell me why they chose to omit the 150 Voltage source in their calculations, that'd help me greatly. Also, you could just tell me a different method to doing the problem and I'll give it a go.

What really has me confused is the usage of the Voltage and Current source on the bottom wire. I don't know how to represent those in a node-voltage equation correctly.

Thank you if you can help me in anyway.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
We have voltage source and current source in series. This configuration gives constant current at any voltage so it is actually current source.
 
szynkasz said:
We have voltage source and current source in series. This configuration gives constant current at any voltage so it is actually current source.

So what you're saying is that they are right in that they ignore the 150 Voltage source?
Cause the way I'm thinking is that the voltage source would also create a current through the bottom resistor, such that the current in the bottom can be represented as a sum of the Current source and Voltage source through the resistor.
 
The current source produces 100 mA current regardless of what is connected to it.
 

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
5K
Back
Top