What is the liquid used to break stone slabs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter venkat badugu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Break Liquid
AI Thread Summary
A discussion revolves around a method observed in a village where an individual heats a stone slab with a gas flame and then pours a mysterious liquid onto it, causing the stone to break into smaller pieces. The liquid, which resembles water but is not, raises curiosity among participants, particularly from a chemistry perspective. The consensus suggests that the liquid likely cools the heated stone, creating stress due to temperature differences that lead to fracturing. While some participants speculate about the possibility of it being a chemical solution, the prevailing opinion is that it is probably water, as it is the most accessible and effective option for inducing such fractures without producing dangerous vapors. The discussion highlights the physical processes at play, emphasizing the role of thermal stress in breaking the stone.
venkat badugu
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi guys,

I have seen in my village that there is one guy who is heating up the stone slab for few mins with gas cylinder fire and after few mins. he pouring some liquid on that heated part. Immediately that part becomes break small pieces. He removes them and again heating up and pouring that liquid. Like this, he total breaks that stone slap and makes big hole. As a chemist student, i wanted to know what is that liquid. when i asked him, he simply smiles and not revealing me. I felt very bad that though i studied person, i could n't find out the liquid name as that person know. I think its available every where. i thought that its spirit, but its not when i checked its smell. he carrying in plastic bottle and it looks like water. but its not water.

so what could be the liquid. any guesses here guys. Just out of interest, i am posting it here. Thanks to all.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
How do you know it is not just water?
 
  • Like
Likes HAYAO and russ_watters
Borek said:
How do you know it is not just water?

I have checked. I don't think stone slab split into pieces if we pour water into it. water reduces heat, where as here liquid giving more heat to stone.
 
 
  • Like
Likes HAYAO and Asymptotic
From your description this has to be a physical process. The breaks are inside the material, but the liquid touches only the surface.
Since the flame is heating the material, it seems reasonable to think the liquid does the opposite and cools it. Water would seem a good candidate.

The mechanism would be stress caused by parts of the stone being at different temperatures and different strain. Heating with the torch may be relatively slow, so that the temperature gradient is not great enough. Sudden cooling could increase the strain gradient.

Heating alone is enogh to fracture some stone.
 
Borek said:

I know that glass will break with water when its in high temperature. How about for raw stones and stone slabs. will it be happens the same.
 
venkat badugu said:
How about for raw stones and stone slabs. will it be happens the same.

See what Merlin wrote above, same mechanism at work.
 
I doubt that it is any chemical solution because that would make a dangerous amount of vapor. Although there probably is certain chemicals that might work for something like that, what he is using is most likely water
 
Jake Osborne said:
I doubt that it is any chemical solution because that would make a dangerous amount of vapor. Although there probably is certain chemicals that might work for something like that, what he is using is most likely water
what he said (very small).jpg
 

Attachments

  • what he said (very small).jpg
    what he said (very small).jpg
    3.2 KB · Views: 715
Back
Top