What is the range of response time when communicating with a friend from Mars?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the response time for communication between Earth and Mars. Participants clarify the distances involved, noting that the minimum distance is 228 million km and the maximum can be up to 378 million km depending on their positions in orbit. The formula T=D/V is confirmed as the correct approach for determining time, with the speed of light used as the velocity. After calculations, the minimum response time is determined to be 260 seconds and the maximum 1260 seconds. The importance of accounting for the round trip of the signal is emphasized, ensuring accurate understanding of communication delays.
louie3006
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
Q#1 : Mars and Earth orbit the sun at radii of 228 million km and 150 million Km , respectively. when, in the future, your friend from Mars calls you on the phone and you answer "Hello" what are the minimum and maximum times you will have to wait for your friend to reply ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
So what have you done so far? There's a template for a reason.
 
What the maximum and minimum distances from Mars to Earth. T=D/V. Please at least try?
 
i did try:
2500x 10 ^9 /3x10^8(m/s) am i doing it the right way ?
 
2500x10^9 what? Meters, km? Put units on your distance. And how did you get 2500 anyway?
 
oh hold on I made a mistake here, t supposed to be 228 million Km/3x10^8(m/s)
 
Mars and Earth orbit on concentric roughly circular orbits around the sun. They can be either on the same side of the sun, in which case you would subtract the radiii, right? Or they could be on the opposite sides, in which case you would add them, yes? Draw a picture. But dividing distance by velocity is a good idea!
 
so I'm on the right track
and i thought that i needed to get delta radii, but then I've changed my mind.
 
Now finish. Or are you done?
 
  • #10
after getting the differences between the radii, I proceed and divide that number by the speed of light, right ? but when it says "million Km, does it mean #X10^9" ?
 
  • #11
1 million km=10^9 meters. 1km=10^3m. 1 million=10^6. If that's what you mean, yes.
 
  • #12
ok, so this is how i get the minimum time : 78X10^9/3x10^8(m/s)= 260s
and the maximum : 378x10^9/3x10^8(m/s)= 1260s
so what do you think? am I correct?
 
  • #13
yeah
 
  • #14
yes, thank you all.
 
  • #15
Actually, when you reply 'hello', your message has to get there, and the reply has to come back before you can hear your friend's reply.
 
Back
Top