Arithmetic mean Fermi Dirac & Bose Einstein

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the relationship between the arithmetic mean of Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions and the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution for indistinguishable particles. The original poster successfully proved that the arithmetic mean of FD and BE distributions equals the MB distribution but seeks an explanation for this phenomenon. There is skepticism about whether this equivalence holds at all temperatures, particularly at low temperatures where Fermi-Dirac effects become significant. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding partition functions and the behavior of quantum distributions in relation to classical mechanics. Overall, the interaction emphasizes the complexity of quantum statistical mechanics and its classical limits.
Frank Einstein
Messages
166
Reaction score
1
Hi everybody, I was doing one asignment form class, I was tasked to prove that in one system, the arimetic mean of FD and BE distributions is equal to MB's distribution for undishtingable particles.
After doing the numbers I found out that it actually was, but I don't know why this happens, can someone explain this to me or point me to a place where I can learn that?
Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think this is a demonstration that the quantum mechanical averaged values behave classically.
Mind that the classical analogue of the Bose Einstein/Fermi Dirac distributions is the Maxwell Boltzmann distribution (give the number density as a function of the energy of the system).
 
  • Like
Likes Frank Einstein
For all temperatures? That would surprise me. Fermi-Dirac includes particles at an energy way above the energies Maxwell-Boltzmann at low temperatures would give, and I don't see how MB would reproduce the step coming from Fermi-Dirac at the Fermi energy.
 
Well, to be honest I have not advanced that much in theory lessons. All I know is that I have a system with two particles and three possible enrgies for them and I had to study the partiton function for each of the three distributions, I checked that the math were right and saw that it acturally worked so I asked the quastion.

By the way thank you very much for your anwsers.
 
Ah, for only two particles it might look different.
I'm not convinced that it works out for all temperatures, however. In the limit of large temperature: sure.
 
  • Like
Likes Frank Einstein
Thread 'Is there a white hole inside every black hole?'
This is what I am thinking. How much feasible is it? There is a white hole inside every black hole The white hole spits mass/energy out continuously The mass/energy that is spit out of a white hole drops back into it eventually. This is because of extreme space time curvature around the white hole Ironically this extreme space time curvature of the space around a white hole is caused by the huge mass/energy packed in the white hole Because of continuously spitting mass/energy which keeps...
Back
Top