Carnot Heat Engine to Carnot Heat Pump

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 3K views
keith river
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
We have a carnot engine with Th = 800 degrees Celsius, and Tc = 50 degrees Celsius.
This produces a work which is drives a carnot heat pump which has heat reservoirs at Th' = 50 degrees celsius and Tc' = 0 degress Celsius.
What is the ratio of heat absorbed by the Heat Engine to the heat absorbed by the heat pump.

I know the ratio from Qh/Qc for the heat engine would be Th/Tc but when I was planning on doing the same for a heat pump (Qh'/Qc') but It doesn't work out as the ratio would be infinite (divides by 0)
I was going to rearrange for Qh/Qc' as these are the heats absorbed by the heat engine and pump respectfully but this also would be infinite.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
keith river said:
We have a carnot engine with Th = 800 degrees Celsius, and Tc = 50 degrees Celsius.
This produces a work which is drives a carnot heat pump which has heat reservoirs at Th' = 50 degrees celsius and Tc' = 0 degress Celsius.
What is the ratio of heat absorbed by the Heat Engine to the heat absorbed by the heat pump.

I know the ratio from Qh/Qc for the heat engine would be Th/Tc but when I was planning on doing the same for a heat pump (Qh'/Qc') but It doesn't work out as the ratio would be infinite (divides by 0)
I was going to rearrange for Qh/Qc' as these are the heats absorbed by the heat engine and pump respectfully but this also would be infinite.
You are using the wrong scale for temperature.

AM
 
Thanks AM
I can't believe I never noticed that before. Such a simple problem.