Classical Mechanics Problem with balls

29 replies · 4K views · last reply
Manolisjam
Messages
49
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Consider 2 balls A,B on the same line . and they are connected to a third one G with a rope L. AG, AB. now the system monves in the effect of the mass of G and its projection to the line AB is in the middle. No friction. mass of A=mass of B=m and mass of G=2m
.FInd the time of impact and the velocity of G at that time

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I know the only forces are From the rope. 2 on the G ball and 1 in each of the balls.I understant i have to apply conservation law of energy but how? What is the potential energy? And also How to calculate the forces. Is it like the 3ball acts like gravity would do?
Hand-drawn diagram of a symmetric system: a horizontal line with points A and B at its ends, and a point O on the line above a point G below, with dashed line from O to G. Strings of length l join A to G and B to G. Angle theta marked at B. Labeled Σχήμα 1 below.
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn diagram of a symmetric system: a horizontal line with points A and B at its ends, and a point O on the line above a point G below, with dashed line from O to G. Strings of length l join A to G and B to G. Angle theta marked at B. Labeled Σχήμα 1 below.
    aaa.jpg
    7.8 KB · Views: 632
Manolisjam said:
i have to apply conservation law of energy
You can use that, and the kinematics (i.e. dynamic geometry), to find the collision speed, but it will not yield the time.
To find the time you need to write out the force and acceleration equations and solve.
Use kinematics to find the relationships between the different accelerations.
 
Make a second sketch with balls A and B at the point of impact. Now compare the two sketches. What is the change in potential energy? Where did that energy go / what was done with the energy?
 
haruspex said:
You can use that, and the kinematics (i.e. dynamic geometry), to find the collision speed, but it will not yield the time.
To find the time you need to write out the force and acceleration equations and solve.
Use kinematics to find the relationships between the different accelerations.
Sorry but could you explain in more detail. I don't even get how to aply the conservation law.And how would i proceed doing the kinematics?
 
jrmichler said:
Make a second sketch with balls A and B at the point of impact. Now compare the two sketches. What is the change in potential energy? Where did that energy go / what was done with the energy?
i Understant that at the initial time kinetic energy is zero and an the final time all the potential energy is kinetic. So V_intitial =_Kfinal i know K=1/2 mu^2 but what about the potential?
 
Manolisjam said:
how would i proceed doing the kinematics?
These can be tricky to work out.
What you know is that the distances AG and BG are constant. Consider the arrangement when, say, angle ABG is θ. Suppose at this point A has an acceleration aA. What is the component of that acceleration in the AG direction?
If the distance AG is constant, what does that tell you about the acceleration of G in the AG direction?
 
haruspex said:
These can be tricky to work out.
What you know is that the distances AG and BG are constant. Consider the arrangement when, say, angle ABG is θ. Suppose at this point A has an acceleration aA. What is the component of that acceleration in the AG direction?
If the distance AG is constant, what does that tell you about the acceleration of G in the AG direction?
isnt the acceleration a_A towards AG but it has 2 components one towards B and one point down ?
 
Manolisjam said:
isnt the acceleration a_A towards AG but it has 2 components one towards B and one point down ?
My understanding of the question is that A and B are constrained to move horizontally, while G descends under gravity.
Please confirm or correct.
 
haruspex said:
My understanding of the question is that A and B are constrained to move horizontally, while G descends under gravity.
Please confirm or correct.
yes they are costrained to move horizontally only!
 
Manolisjam said:
yes they are costrained to move horizontally only!
So A's acceleration, aA, is horizontal, but that has a component in the AG direction. What is the magnitude of that component?
 
haruspex said:
So A's acceleration, aA, is horizontal, but that has a component in the AG direction. What is the magnitude of that component?
F/m ?? by Newtons law?
 
Manolisjam said:
F/m ?? by Newtons law?
No, we're just discussing kinematics at this stage: displacements, velocities, accelerations. No forces or masses.
If the horizontal acceleration is aA, what component does that have in the AG direction? Use the angle θ.
 
haruspex said:
No, we're just discussing kinematics at this stage: displacements, velocities, accelerations. No forces or masses.
If the horizontal acceleration is aA, what component does that have in the AG direction? Use the angle θ.
a_A=cosθ*a_G
 
Manolisjam said:
a_A=cosθ*a_G
I assume you are defining aG as the acceleration of G. That is not correct. (I said it was tricky.)
We need to take it in smaller steps. Please try to answer the question I asked, don't worry about aG yet.
What component does A's acceleration have in the AG direction?
 
haruspex said:
I assume you are defining aG as the acceleration of G. That is not correct. (I said it was tricky.)
We need to take it in smaller steps. Please try to answer the question I asked, don't worry about aG yet.
What component does A's acceleration have in the AG direction?
a_G i meant th component of a of A to the direction of G.
 
Manolisjam said:
a_G i meant th component of a of A to the direction of G.
Ok, but your answer was wrong. It would make the component greater than the whole.
 
haruspex said:
Ok, but your answer was wrong. It would make the component greater than the whole.
Handwritten diagram on a whiteboard of a pendulum-like setup: pivot point G at the bottom with two strings of length l meeting at it, a point A on the left and B on the right, with angle theta marked. Below is written a_AB / a_AG = cos theta = adjacent/hypotenuse, followed by No?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten diagram on a whiteboard of a pendulum-like setup: pivot point G at the bottom with two strings of length l meeting at it, a point A on the left and B on the right, with angle theta marked. Below is written a_AB / a_AG = cos theta = adjacent/hypotenuse, followed by No?
    28450388_10213703965147783_1458233801_n.jpg
    11 KB · Views: 460
You are making an assumption about which is adjacent and which is hypotenuse.
If you have any vector - force, acceleration, velocity, whatever - and you want a component of that in some other direction then the vector you started with is the hypotenuse.
 
haruspex said:
You are making an assumption about which is adjacent and which is hypotenuse.
If you have any vector - force, acceleration, velocity, whatever - and you want a component of that in some other direction then the vector you started with is the hypotenuse.
im tired ill pm you tommorow thanks so far !
 
haruspex said:
You are making an assumption about which is adjacent and which is hypotenuse.
If you have any vector - force, acceleration, velocity, whatever - and you want a component of that in some other direction then the vector you started with is the hypotenuse.
Handwritten physics working: a pendulum-style diagram with points A, B and O, a ball labelled G with mass 2mg, and equations including 2T sinθ - 2mg = mq/a, -T cosθ = ma/l, and energy conservation K_P + V_P = K_final + V_final, with V_P = 0 and V_initial = V_C = 2mg(L - √(L² - h²)).
Handwritten physics working: a pendulum-style diagram with points A, B and O, a ball labelled G with mass 2mg, and equations including 2T sinθ - 2mg = mq/a, -T cosθ = ma/l, and energy conservation K_P + V_P = K_final + V_final, with V_P = 0 and V_initial = V_C = 2mg(L - √(L² - h²)).
my progress so far...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten physics working: a pendulum-style diagram with points A, B and O, a ball labelled G with mass 2mg, and equations including 2T sinθ - 2mg = mq/a, -T cosθ = ma/l, and energy conservation K_P + V_P = K_final + V_final, with V_P = 0 and V_initial = V_C = 2mg(L - √(L² - h²)).
    1.jpg
    11.1 KB · Views: 450
  • Handwritten derivation on lined paper: 'Now since v_A = v_B at this time, K_final = m_B v_B^2 ... + m_A v_A^2', then 'K_initial = K_final => v_A^2 + v_A^2 = 2g(l - sqrt(l^2 - x^2))', with 'sqrt(l^2 - x^2) = D(x)' the distance of G in ..., and 'l - sqrt(l^2 - x^2)' the height of G since its max is l.
    2.jpg
    8.1 KB · Views: 448
Your force equations might be ok... depends which directions you are defining as positive.
As I mentioned, there really is no point in working with energy conservation since you are asked to find time.

Please do not post algebra as images. It makes it hard to comment on specific lines.
 
haruspex said:
Your force equations might be ok... depends which directions you are defining as positive.
As I mentioned, there really is no point in working with energy conservation since you are asked to find time.

Please do not post algebra as images. It makes it hard to comment on specific lines.
SO what do i do?
 
Manolisjam said:
SO what do i do?
i think ima loose it.
 
Manolisjam said:
i think ima loose it.
Apply what I explained about resolving components in post #18 and hence find the correct relationship between aA and its component in the AG direction.
You will find it valuable to be able to do this correctly. It is fundamental to many kinematics problems.
 
haruspex said:
Apply what I explained about resolving components in post #18 and hence find the correct relationship between aA and its component in the AG direction.
You will find it valuable to be able to do this correctly. It is fundamental to many kinematics problems.
ok if a_A is the acceleration on x axes then cosθ=a_AG/a_A right? where a_AG is the component in a_AG direction
 
Manolisjam said:
ok if a_A is the acceleration on x axes then cosθ=a_AG/a_A right? where a_AG is the component in a_AG direction
Yes.
Now consider this: the distance from A to G is constant. What does that tell you about how the component of G's acceleration in the AG direction relates to aAG?
 
Manolisjam said:
isnt Gs acceleration down?
dont get it
 
ive been trying 2 days now straght . all . I've asked other people no1 will give me a full answer so i can study it and understant it. because that the policy .. i give up
haruspex said:
Yes.
Now consider this: the distance from A to G is constant. What does that tell you about how the component of G's acceleration in the AG direction relates to aAG?
nvm i give up.. its 3 day straight I am just doing this thing... and no1 can give me a full answer since i can't derive it..gn
 
Manolisjam said:
isnt Gs acceleration down?
Yes, but it also has a component in the AG direction.
It might help to think about velocity components first. What would happen to the string if the component of G's velocity in the AG direction were greater than the component of A's velocity in the AG direction?