Expansive Mathematical Logic Text

AI Thread Summary
For those looking to learn mathematical logic, the discussion highlights several book recommendations and critiques. Ebinghaus and Monk are mentioned, with Monk receiving criticism for his philosophical approach and perceived lack of familiarity with key concepts from Carnap, particularly regarding internal and external languages. This raises concerns about the depth and accuracy of Monk's work. In contrast, Hinman's book is recommended as a solid alternative. Additionally, the two-volume series by Cori and Lascar is suggested as an easier yet effective introduction to the subject. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the importance of choosing comprehensive and accurate texts for studying mathematical logic.
SrVishi
Messages
75
Reaction score
15
Hello, I want to start learning mathematical logic. I was wondering what would be a good "expansive" mathematical logic book that covers as much material as possible. My school has books by both Ebinghaus (et. al) and Monk. Are these good? I've heard good things about Schoenfield, but I was wondering how they compare to the aforementioned books. Thanks in advance for any response. [Note: I am already planning on going through Jech's Set theory, along with Kunen's books and Model Theory by Chang]
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Monk doesn't look good and Ebbinghaus doesn't look expansive.

Why does Monk not look good? He talks about philosophy in the preface and mentions that he wrote a book about platonism and formalism, topics in the philosophy of math, but he seems unfamiliar with Carnap because he makes a mistake that Carnap wrote about in 1950. Monk's book is from 1967 and I think he should have known about Carnap's concept of internal and external language. If anything, I read his preface as a defense against exactly this criticism, that he goes against Carnap. It's not a convincing defense, it was wrong when he wrote it and it is still wrong today.
 
Last edited:
For the following four books, has anyone used them in a course or for self study? Compiler Construction Principles and Practice 1st Edition by Kenneth C Louden Programming Languages Principles and Practices 3rd Edition by Kenneth C Louden, and Kenneth A Lambert Programming Languages 2nd Edition by Allen B Tucker, Robert E Noonan Concepts of Programming Languages 9th Edition by Robert W Sebesta If yes to either, can you share your opinions about your personal experience using them. I...
Hi, I have notice that Ashcroft, Mermin and Wei worked at a revised edition of the original solid state physics book (here). The book, however, seems to be never available. I have also read that the reason is related to some disputes related to copyright. Do you have any further information about it? Did you have the opportunity to get your hands on this revised edition? I am really curious about it, also considering that I am planning to buy the book in the near future... Thanks!
Back
Top