Is the Pressure Vessel Design for a Railway Cistern Appropriate?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the design of a railway cistern intended to hold 120,000 kg of liquid, with specific dimensions and material properties. Key considerations include evaluating the shell thickness of 32mm against various forces: internal pressure, weight of the liquid, and dynamic forces from braking and incline. The necessity of pressurization for a cistern, typically a non-pressurized container, is questioned, highlighting that liquids exert hydrostatic pressure differently than solids. The calculation of forces, including friction and net force on an incline, is also discussed, emphasizing the need to determine the coefficient of friction experimentally or through reference. Overall, the design approach appears sound, but clarification on the need for pressurization remains a point of inquiry.
lak91
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Design a railway cistern for 120,000 kg of Liquid. It has to be a cylindrical shell on two supports.

The cistern is
18 m long
3 m in diameter (inner).
It is made of steel with the yield strength of SY= 240MPa.
Safety factor of FY= 1.9;
Total corrosion allowance, c= 3.0 mm;
Welded joint efficiency = 0.85
Shell thickness, t - 32mm

Check whether this thickness is sufficient to withstand combined action of the internal pressure, t
he weight of liquid, and the action of longitudinal external forces (tensile or compressive) .
Assume the mass of the train as m= 12 x 10^6kg, deceleration during braking of a = 3m/sec
, and during climbing uphill assume the inclination angle of 10 degrees


I assume there will be 3 design cases for this problem:
Case 1 Internal Pressure+ Weight of Liquid
Case 2Internal Pressure+ Weight of Liquid + Inertia during breaking of the railway cistern
Case 3 Forces acting on the pressure vessel: Internal Pressure + Weight of liquid+ inertia of breaking + inclination angle (locomotive applied to the first cistern in the train)

Wondering if I am going about this correctly?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I don't see any problem with your method of reasoning, but my question is why a railway cistern needs to be pressurized. AFAIK, a cistern just a big container to hold water or some other liquid, isn't it?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
So for each case I work out the total longitudinal stress?

For case three I am unsure if I am going about it correctly:

Determine mgsinx and Ff(friction).
mgsinx pushes block down the incline and Ff(friction) opposes this.

Write the equation
Fnet = mgsinx - FfSince Ff=uFn and we know Fn=mgcosx and we also know Fnet=ma, we write

ma = mgsinx- u(mgcosx)

Divide by m throughout, so we don't need mass a=gsinx - ugcosx

How would I work out u ?
 
I think in your equations, "u" is really mu, the coefficient of friction. You should just look it up or experimentally determine it.
 
timthereaper said:
I don't see any problem with your method of reasoning, but my question is why a railway cistern needs to be pressurized. AFAIK, a cistern just a big container to hold water or some other liquid, isn't it?

The liquid exerts a hydrostatic pressure on ALL the surface of the container. That is different from a truck containing a solid. For example a liquid would exert a force on the ends of the cylinder when the train was horizontal, but a solid would not.
 
Here's a video by “driving 4 answers” who seems to me to be well versed on the details of Internal Combustion engines. The video does cover something that's a bit shrouded in 'conspiracy theory', and he touches on that, but of course for phys.org, I'm only interested in the actual science involved. He analyzes the claim of achieving 100 mpg with a 427 cubic inch V8 1970 Ford Galaxy in 1977. Only the fuel supply system was modified. I was surprised that he feels the claim could have been...
TL;DR Summary: Heard in the news about using sonar to locate the sub Hello : After the sinking of the ship near the Greek shores , carrying of alot of people , there was another accident that include 5 tourists and a submarine visiting the titanic , which went missing Some technical notes captured my attention, that there us few sonar devices are hearing sounds repeated every 30 seconds , but they are not able to locate the source Is it possible that the sound waves are reflecting from...
Back
Top