Shear Force and Bending Diagram. Need help understanding.

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on understanding shear force and bending moment diagrams in a structural analysis problem. Participants express confusion about how to properly construct these diagrams, particularly in the intervals 2<x<5 and 5<x<7, questioning the inclusion of certain forces and moments. Clarification is provided on how to measure distances from the section cut and the importance of including the entire structure to the left of the cut for consistency. The conversation highlights the need for clear representation in diagrams to avoid confusion and ensure accurate calculations. Overall, the thread aims to help users grasp the concepts necessary for solving related problems effectively.
bob29
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


[PLAIN]http://img80.imageshack.us/img80/4476/bendingshearquestion.jpg

Homework Equations


\sumM = 0:
\sumFy = 0:

The Attempt at a Solution


Revising for my finals and going over questions, and would like to understand more clearly how to get the following.

Solution is in the image.
[PLAIN]http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/7237/bendingshearsolution.jpg

When 2<x<5:
I do not understand how to obtain the graph.
Shouldn't the graph be from 0<x<5, since it includes the 2m and reaction force at A?
I also do not know how to obtain the (x-2).

Same when 5<x<7:
I do not understand how to obtain the (7-x) or (9-x) in the moment equilibrium equation.

Hope someone can help.
Cheers,
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
bob29: I drew on your diagram to show you how the (x - 2) and 0.5(x - 2) are obtained. The origin is at point A. The blue line is the section cut. The section cut is located at x, measured from the origin. The (x - 2) and 0.5(x - 2) are measured from the section cut, as I showed in the diagram.

Each diagram, such as 2 < x < 5 m, must show everything to the left-hand side of the section cut. If you omit part of the left-hand end of the beam, then you must add the force and moment at the left-hand-end section cut. Omitting part of the left-hand end of the structure perhaps makes it more confusing. And the diagram is inconsistent. Notice the first two domains in the diagram (0 < x < 2, and 2 < x < 5) show the entire structure to the left of the section cut (the blue line). But then the diagram changes its method, and omits a left-hand portion of the structure in the diagram domains 5 < x < 7, and 7 < x < 9.

You can draw the entire structure to the left-hand side of the section cut (the blue line) for each domain, if you wish. And it would make the solution more clear.
 

Attachments

  • bendingshearsolution01.png
    bendingshearsolution01.png
    12.4 KB · Views: 604
Thx much easier 2 understand. Should be able to ace this question if it pops up.
 
Sorry to dig up an old thread but i had a look at the workings posted by nvn and can see how most forces etc are achieved except the force of 2100N, can someone point out what I've missed. Thanks in Advance :-)
 

Similar threads

Back
Top