Visualizing an engineering drawing

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around difficulties in visualizing and modeling an engineering drawing, particularly the middle section. Participants clarify that the triangular shapes in the drawing are cut into the part rather than being solid. They emphasize the importance of interpreting the drawing dimensions accurately to facilitate modeling. One contributor shares a quick sketching and modeling process, highlighting techniques like extrusion and filleting, which can aid in creating the part. Overall, understanding the drawing's details is crucial for effective engineering design and modeling.
theone
Messages
81
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I am trying to make a model of the attached drawing but am having trouble visualising the middle part of the drawings. I was wondering if someone could describe it to me

Homework Equations


-

The Attempt at a Solution


I think it involves two of something like this http://www.jbprince.com/images/K555_zoom.jpg with a hole through them?
 

Attachments

  • drawing.png
    drawing.png
    21.9 KB · Views: 428
Physics news on Phys.org
That's what it looks like to me, too.
 
insightful said:
That's what it looks like to me, too.

i also don't understand what this part is:
http://postimg.org/image/ph22yhslp/
 
That's simply the hole. The "bulges" shown are where the hole goes through the beginning of the curved parts of the indentations.
 
insightful said:
That's simply the hole. The "bulges" shown are where the hole goes through the beginning of the curved parts of the indentations.

alight, thanks.
also, do you have any idea what it is a picture of?
 
theone said:
...do you have any idea what it is a picture of?
It's roughly the shape of an "A" arm for an automobile independent suspension, but it could be a mechanical link for many machines.
 
  • Like
Likes billy_joule
insightful said:
It's roughly the shape of an "A" arm for an automobile independent suspension, but it could be a mechanical link for many machines.

im still unsure : are the triangular things solid or just a shape cut into the part?
 
theone said:
im still unsure : are the triangular things solid or just a shape cut into the part?
The triangular shapes are cut into the part, top and bottom.

You must look at the section view (with the cross-hatching) and compare that to the top view which is on the left.
 
This may, or may not, help (sorry, I'm no sculptor).
PF1 001.jpg
 
  • Like
Likes CWatters and theone
  • #10
theone said:

Homework Statement


I am trying to make a model of the attached drawing but am having trouble visualising the middle part of the drawings.

If the drawing is dimensioned correctly you shouldn't have to visualise it at all, just model it as the dimensions state and the correct form will appear.
Of course, being able to interpret the drawing first will make the modelling easier and is obviously an important skill for an engineer.
Your drawing does not have enough information to recreate it exactly, this is a two minute sketch showing the rough form (I've ignored the taper and some fillets):
 

Attachments

  • A arm.jpg
    A arm.jpg
    23.7 KB · Views: 395
  • Like
Likes Nidum, insightful and theone
  • #11
billy_joule said:
If the drawing is dimensioned correctly you shouldn't have to visualise it at all, just model it as the dimensions state and the correct form will appear.
Of course, being able to interpret the drawing first will make the modelling easier and is obviously an important skill for an engineer.
Your drawing does not have enough information to recreate it exactly, this is a two minute sketch showing the rough form (I've ignored the taper and some fillets):

how did you make that in two minutes; what did you sketch first?
 
  • #12
theone said:
how did you make that in two minutes; what did you sketch first?

The whole process:
sketched the top view outline with random dimensions, I then extruded it half the total thickness.
sketched a triangle on the top face and extruded cut ~90% depth of the previous extrusion.
filleted the inner edges of the triangle cut and the tips of the arms (radius of length set equal to the first extrusion)
>this is where I would've added the taper had I done so.
sketched two circles on the side view then extruded cut, this formed semicircular holes with centerlines on the bottom face.
Sketched & extruded cut the large centre hole on the top view
I then mirrored the part abouts its bottom face.

There's many other, probably better ways to do it but it's what came to my mind. I've had no formal CAD training, just practice, learning the hotkeys is important if you want to be fast.
 
  • Like
Likes theone
  • #13
billy_joule said:
The whole process:
sketched the top view outline with random dimensions, I then extruded it half the total thickness.
sketched a triangle on the top face and extruded cut ~90% depth of the previous extrusion.
filleted the inner edges of the triangle cut and the tips of the arms (radius of length set equal to the first extrusion)
>this is where I would've added the taper had I done so.
sketched two circles on the side view then extruded cut, this formed semicircular holes with centerlines on the bottom face.
Sketched & extruded cut the large centre hole on the top view
I then mirrored the part abouts its bottom face.

There's many other, probably better ways to do it but it's what came to my mind. I've had no formal CAD training, just practice, learning the hotkeys is important if you want to be fast.

thanks, that's very helpful
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top