Hello, how can I replace a variable capacitor with a varicap
Click For Summary
Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around replacing a variable capacitor with a varicap diode in an AM receiver circuit. Participants explore the feasibility, necessary modifications, and implications of such a substitution, touching on both theoretical and practical aspects of circuit design.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Experimental/applied
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about replacing a variable capacitor with a BB112 varicap diode, seeking guidance on the necessary circuit modifications.
- Another participant notes the difficulty in finding a suitable varicap diode with a capacitance close to 500 pF, suggesting that the BB112 has a range of 440 pF to 520 pF.
- It is mentioned that the varicap is voltage-driven and should be isolated with capacitors at each end, or one end should be grounded.
- Concerns are raised about the impact of using a varicap on the circuit's biasing and the potential need for a regulated control voltage to avoid detuning.
- Participants discuss the importance of using low leakage capacitors in the modified bias circuit and the implications of resistor values on circuit performance.
- There is a suggestion to use a ferrite rod for the tuning inductor and antenna, with alternatives for winding techniques discussed.
- One participant questions whether a high-resistance wire-wound resistor can serve as an inductor, prompting clarification on the differences between inductors and resistors.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express various viewpoints regarding the replacement of the variable capacitor with a varicap, with no clear consensus on the best approach or the implications of the modifications. Some participants agree on certain technical aspects, while others raise questions and concerns about specific components and configurations.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include uncertainties about the performance of the BB112 varicap in the circuit, potential issues with biasing and voltage regulation, and the need for careful consideration of component values to maintain circuit quality.
- 4,894
- 1,556
- 434
- 19
this varicap is 520pFAveragesupernova said:You will have a hard time finding a 500 pF varicap diode. I did a quick search on digikey and found: https://www.digikey.com/products/en?keywords=varactor
- 2,316
- 813
- 434
- 19
Svein said:The varicap is voltage driven, so you must isolate it with a 1nF capacitor at each end. Or - bring one end of the varicap to ground like this:
View attachment 221826
I search a lot in internet and i so your circuits, and i did not find help so i come here to help me, because i have no variable capacitorSvein said:The varicap is voltage driven, so you must isolate it with a 1nF capacitor at each end. Or - bring one end of the varicap to ground like this:
View attachment 221826
So to remove variable cabacitor, and to add R1 C1 VARICAP, but what about the antenna, how to make antenna, how to where to conected in the circuit?
- 4,894
- 1,556
Which varicap? The link I posted offers a number of them and nothing comes close to 500 pF.michael1978 said:this varicap is 520pF
- 1,733
- 824
min = 440 pF, typ = 470 pF, max = 520 pF
I can't vouch for the datasheet as I've never had a BB112, but Siemens should know.
Edit: PS and BTW, I'm testing some diodes - varicaps, LEDs and simple power diodes - at the moment, and the record is over 1 nF for a Lucas DD710 low voltage power diode
- 1,733
- 824
- 16,899
- 10,506
A minor difficulty with that circuit is the floating voltage of the tuned circuit secondary.michael1978 said:i found this am receiver, but is using variable capacitor, how can i replace of do with varicap this circuits(i hava varicap bb112)
If it is to use a varicap, controlled by a DC voltage, it will need to be referenced to ground.
But there is an envelope detector embedded in that circuit, which must not be broken by the change in front end bias.
That might explain why the input RF transformer has a floating tuned secondary.
The supply voltage is 9V, the varicap will need most of that. The control voltage pot needs a regulated voltage.
Without regulation, any change in battery voltage due to audio output load will de-tune the RF circuit.
The pot and regulator will use more current. So power consumption will rise with the change to a varicap.
- 434
- 19
yes me too, but i connect without antenna i hear noiseMerlin3189 said:Datasheet
min = 440 pF, typ = 470 pF, max = 520 pF
I can't vouch for the datasheet as I've never had a BB112, but Siemens should know.
Edit: PS and BTW, I'm testing some diodes - varicaps, LEDs and simple power diodes - at the moment, and the record is over 1 nF for a Lucas DD710 low voltage power diode
- 16,899
- 10,506
@michael1978. That looks like LTspice. Have you been successful running that simulation ?michael1978 said:No this was orginal circuits so i replace varicap bb112, but i hear only noise
There are some obvious problems, it is easier to edit your file than create another.
Can you please attach your file.asc to a post with the txt extension as file.asc.txt
Attach the plot file in the same way if the simulation worked. file.plt.txt
- 434
- 19
yes i send you, if you can help me... I RENAME am.asc into am.txtBaluncore said:@michael1978. That looks like LTspice. Have you been successful running that simulation ?
There are some obvious problems, it is easier to edit your file than create another.
Can you please attach your file.asc to a post with the txt extension as file.asc.txt
Attach the plot file in the same way if the simulation worked. file.plt.txt
Attachments
- 16,899
- 10,506
- 434
- 19
Baluncore said:Here is a modified bias circuit, no model for BB112 or Pot, but circuit should work.
View attachment 221877
C1 and C2 must be low leakage caps. Avoid power supply bypass caps.
thank you very much, but i have just 2 more question, why you pick 47K to potentiometer, normally they say a few megaohms, and last where to connect antenna and i need simple inductor 200u ? and that was only for test trnsformer thanksBaluncore said:Here is a modified bias circuit, no model for BB112 or Pot, but circuit should work.
View attachment 221877
C1 and C2 must be low leakage caps. Avoid power supply bypass caps.
- 16,899
- 10,506
1. The resistor needs to be big to keep the Q of the LC circuit high. Any coupling capacitor or varicap reverse leakage current will flow through the resistor, so I use 47k as a starting value. Any resistor over 100k is likely to leak due to environmental contamination.michael1978 said:but i have just 2 more question, why you pick 47K to potentiometer, normally they say a few megaohms, and last where to connect antenna and i need simple inductor 200u ?
2. For MW reception I would wind 75 turns on a ferrite rod and use that for the tuning inductor and the antenna. No external antenna is needed.
You could experiment with 50 turns of wire on a 2" or 50mm plastic pipe or cardboard roll. Wind a temporary primary of 12 turns over the coil to couple an external antenna.
- 434
- 19
helloBaluncore said:1. The resistor needs to be big to keep the Q of the LC circuit high. Any coupling capacitor or varicap reverse leakage current will flow through the resistor, so I use 47k as a starting value. Any resistor over 100k is likely to leak due to environmental contamination.
2. For MW reception I would wind 75 turns on a ferrite rod and use that for the tuning inductor and the antenna. No external antenna is needed.
You could experiment with 50 turns of wire on a 2" or 50mm plastic pipe or cardboard roll. Wind a temporary primary of 12 turns over the coil to couple an external antenna.
but can i use inductor in form of resistor? in place of ferrit rod they are the same of not?
- 434
- 19
sorry i make you tired, can you answer me please... thnxmichael1978 said:hello
but can i use inductor in form of resistor? in place of ferrit rod they are the same of not?
- 9,725
- 11,820
an inductor ISNT a resistormichael1978 said:hello
but can i use inductor in form of resistor? in place of ferrit rod they are the same of not?
follow @Baluncore 's instructions, he is wise in such things
- 69,500
- 25,047
He might be asking if he can use a high-resistance wire-wound resistor as an inductor, but I'm not able to decode his questions very well.davenn said:an inductor ISNT a resistor
- 1,733
- 824
Attachments
- 16,899
- 10,506
The primary of the air cored RF transformer is maybe 6 turns of wire wound over the secondary and used to lightly couple the antenna current into the tuned secondary.
The alternative is a ferrite rod that acts as an antenna wound with wire to make the tuning inductor. That may eliminate the need for the antenna and primary winding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferrite_core#Ferrite_rod_aerial
You might find a 200uH RF “choke” inductor with low loss characteristics, but I doubt it. If you use a small inductor, wound on a small ferrite slug, you will find it very difficult to couple the antenna signal into the small tuning inductor.
The reactance of 190uH at 530kHz is about 630 ohms. The BB112 varicap has a series resistance of 1.5 ohms so the Q will be about 300 which is OK on the AM broadcast band. Keep your tuning inductor wire resistance below 1.5 ohms to have good Q = selectivity.
There are many calculators, such as here; http://zpostbox.ru/how_to_calculate_inductors.html
Try 85 turns, spread over 40mm along a 40mm diameter former.
Work out the length of wire. Then from wire tables, the resistance. Will 85 turns fit along 40mm? 40 / 85 = 0.47mm diam wire.
- 434
- 19
berkeman said:He might be asking if he can use a high-resistance wire-wound resistor as an inductor, but I'm not able to decode his questions very well.
sorry you misundestand me, i have a inductor(i don't know how they call? they look like resistor, but they are inductor)davenn said:
- 434
- 19
yes like that...Merlin3189 said:
- 434
- 19
sorry you misundestand me, i have a inductor(i don't know how they call? they look like resistor, but they are inductor)davenn said:
- 434
- 19
I have those inductor, thay work of not with this inductor?Baluncore said:1. The resistor needs to be big to keep the Q of the LC circuit high. Any coupling capacitor or varicap reverse leakage current will flow through the resistor, so I use 47k as a starting value. Any resistor over 100k is likely to leak due to environmental contamination.
2. For MW reception I would wind 75 turns on a ferrite rod and use that for the tuning inductor and the antenna. No external antenna is needed.
You could experiment with 50 turns of wire on a 2" or 50mm plastic pipe or cardboard roll. Wind a temporary primary of 12 turns over the coil to couple an external antenna.
Attachments
- 9,725
- 11,820
OK, got that cleared upmichael1978 said:I have those inductor, thay work of not with this inductor?
View attachment 221909
I will say no, you need to go with what Baluncore was telling you in post #22
- 16,899
- 10,506
If you use a two terminal axial inductor, how will you connect the antenna?michael1978 said:I have those inductor, thay work of not with this inductor?
The antenna connects to the primary of the RF transformer, the secondary is tuned to resonance with a capacitor.
- 1,733
- 824
- 434
- 19
thanks merlinMerlin3189 said:I don't know whether these inductors would work in this tuned circuit, but since he has them he could try it out. I would expect to be able to couple to it with an overwinding of a few turns, just as in the original circuit.
Similar threads
- · Replies 6 ·
- Replies
- 6
- Views
- 3K
- · Replies 6 ·
- Replies
- 6
- Views
- 4K
- Replies
- 2
- Views
- 3K
- · Replies 46 ·
- Replies
- 46
- Views
- 8K
- · Replies 2 ·
- Replies
- 2
- Views
- 2K
- · Replies 32 ·
- Replies
- 32
- Views
- 4K
- · Replies 30 ·
- Replies
- 30
- Views
- 3K
- · Replies 39 ·
- Replies
- 39
- Views
- 6K
- · Replies 6 ·
- Replies
- 6
- Views
- 1K
- · Replies 3 ·
- Replies
- 3
- Views
- 2K