Simple piston Pressure Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter engstud
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Piston Pressure
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the force required on a vertical piston in a gas cylinder under specific conditions. The user has calculated the gas pressure exerted on the piston and applied Newton's second law to derive the force needed. However, there is confusion regarding the use of the shaft's cross-sectional area and the correct application of forces in the free body diagram. Some participants suggest that the area of the shaft is unnecessary for this calculation and point out potential errors in the gas force calculation. The overall consensus is to focus on converting pressures to forces and accurately applying the free body diagram principles to solve for the required force.
engstud
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Figure P1.30 (attached) shows a gas contained in a vertical piston-cylinder assembly. A vertical shaft whose cross-sectional area is 0.8 cm2 is attached to the top of the piston. Determine the magnitude, F, of the force acting on the shaft, in N, required if the gas pressure is 3 bar. The masses of the piston and attached shaft are 24.5kg and 0.5kg respectively. The piston diameter is 10cm. The local atmospheric pressure is 1 bar. The piston moves smoothly in the cylinder and g=9.81 m/s2

Homework Equations



F=pA
F=ma

The Attempt at a Solution



I calculated the pressure exerted on the piston by the gas (I called it Fg) using Fg=pA which gave me Fg=(3 bar * 105 Pa)*pi*(.05m)^2=23561.9 N

I then drew a free body diagram of the piston, applied Newton's second law and ended up with 0=Fg-F-Ws-Wp where Ws is the weight of the shaft and Wp is the weight of the piston. When I plug in all my numbers and solve for F I end up with 23316.7N. I do not know whether or not this is the correct answer but I am being thrown off by the fact that they gave me the cross-sectional area of the shaft and I did not use it. Can someone please check my logic?
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.png
    Untitled.png
    19.4 KB · Views: 2,749
Physics news on Phys.org
I have the calculations for the atm and gas force. I am not seeing how some get the formula, Fatm=F+Fgas+W. How do you come to this formula from the diagram? And then solve for F. Anyone.
 
The area of the shaft is not needed. Convert the pressures to forces and do a free body diagram on the piston. I think the Force exerted by the gas is incorrect, decimal problem.
 
Back
Top