Question with 3 Phase Transformers Wye-Delta problem

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Aristotle
Messages
169
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Text problem: a 5-MVA, 66:13.2 kV three-phase transformer supplies a 4500 kW resistive load at 13.2 kV; asks load resistance in ohms seen line-to-neutral on the high-voltage side for a) Y-Y and b) Y-Delta connections, with book answers 966.25 ohms and 2898.75 ohms.


Homework Equations


Wye:
V_Line = sqrt(3) x V_Phase

Delta:
V_Line = V_Phase

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten-style worked solution typeset as text, Part (a): current I2 = S/(sqrt(3)V2) = 5x10^6/(sqrt(3) x 13.2x10^3) = 218.6932 A; impedance Z02 = P/I2^2 = 94.0896 ohms; ratio K = 13.2/66 = 0.2; Z01 = Z02/K^2 = 2352.24 ohms.


Handwritten-style worked solution typeset as text: Part (b) Y-Delta connected, transformation ratio K = Vph1/Vph2 = (66/sqrt(3))/13.2 = 2.8867, and Z01 = Z02/K^2 = 94.0896/2.8867^2 = 11.2911 ohms.


My answer doesn't quite match up with the solutions in the book, and was wondering what I went wrong here? Any help is greatly appreciated!
 
For part a) I get approx. the book answer if the secondary load is 3 phase 4 wire, same configuration as the primary.
You might find it more straightforward to work directly with resistances, rather than with current then calculating resistances.

As the textbooks like to say: "Part b) is left as an exercise for the reader."
 
Tom.G said:
For part a) I get approx. the book answer if the secondary load is 3 phase 4 wire, same configuration as the primary.
You might find it more straightforward to work directly with resistances, rather than with current then calculating resistances.

As the textbooks like to say: "Part b) is left as an exercise for the reader."
Yes I've solved it, turned out part b's solution of the book is incorrect according to my professor. Thanks!