Physics Forums Insights
  • Physics
    • Mechanics
    • Thermodynamics
    • Electromagnetism
    • Fluids
    • Optics
    • Particles
    • Quantum
    • Relativity
    • Biophysics
  • Astronomy
    • Astrophysics
    • Cosmology
    • Observing
  • Mathematics
    • Algebra
    • Analysis
    • Geometry
    • Number Theory
    • Probability
  • Computing
    • Programming
    • Electronics
    • Imaging
  • Science Culture
    • Education
    • Careers
    • Philosophy
    • Profiles
    • Trivia
  • Forums
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
carlo

Carlo Rovelli Interview: Supersymmetry, Multiverse, Time

March 21, 2016/6 Comments/in Interviews, Profiles/by Greg Bernhardt
📖Read Time: 6 minutes
📊Readability: Advanced 📐(contains math) (Technical knowledge needed)
🔖Core Topics: Rovelliphysicstheorytimequantum

Physicist Carlo Rovelli, known for his work on loop quantum gravity and his book Seven Brief Lessons on Physics, discusses his views on supersymmetry, the multiverse, string theory, and the role of falsifiability in physics in this interview. He argues that decades of promised but undiscovered supersymmetry warrant skepticism, and that untestable multiverse speculation falls outside science.

Table of Contents

  • Key Takeaways
  • Background and inspiration for Seven Brief Lessons on Physics
  • What would an eighth lesson in the book cover?
  • What does Rovelli think about supersymmetry?
  • Is it time to give up on a single universe?
  • Are there indications that nature follows simple, unique laws?
  • Three physics insights that could change how we understand the world
  • What future conceptual developments could matter most?
  • Should falsifiability be adjusted given recent theoretical developments?
  • Can string theory be criticized on methodological grounds?
  • How does Rovelli feel about his 60th birthday celebration (“carlofest”)?
  • What are Rovelli’s interests outside physics?
  • Who were Rovelli’s heroes growing up?
  • Frequently Asked Questions
    • What does Carlo Rovelli think about supersymmetry being discovered soon?
    • Does Rovelli support multiverse theories?
    • What is Seven Brief Lessons on Physics about?
    • What objectives did string theory originally set for itself?
    • What three insights does Rovelli consider most important for understanding the world?
    • What does Rovelli say about adjusting the criterion of falsifiability?
  • Glossary
    • Further reading

Key Takeaways

  • Carlo Rovelli states that after being told for 30 years that supersymmetry would “certainly” be seen “very soon,” he thinks it is time to mostly give up on that expectation.
  • Rovelli argues that multiverse speculation lacks any reasonable proposal for empirical testing, so physics should remain focused on the “uni” in “universe.”
  • Rovelli identifies three physics insights he considers most transformative: that there is no “time” in the fundamental description of the world, that “space” is not a container of things, and that there is nothing outside the natural world.
  • Rovelli says string theory set clear objectives in the 1980s, including computing the parameters of the standard model from first principles and explaining the existence of three generations of particles, and that it is time to acknowledge if those objectives have not been met.
  • Rovelli describes his book Seven Brief Lessons on Physics as a personal take on general relativity and quantum theory rather than a condensed summary of contemporary physics.

Background and inspiration for Seven Brief Lessons on Physics

Carlo Rovelli

Carlo Rovelli was born and educated in Italy, then spent 10 years in the United States and 15 years in France. He says he came to physics late, having first been drawn to political activism before discovering, in his third university year, a fascination with the problem of quantum gravity, a theoretical effort to reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity (GR).

Rovelli recalls drawing a large colourful picture with ##10^{-33}## centimetres at the center, representing the Planck length, and posting it on his wall as a personal commitment to understanding what happens at that scale, where conventional notions of space and time break down.

His book Seven Brief Lessons on Physics originated from three articles he wrote for the cultural supplement of an Italian newspaper. A prestigious Italian publisher asked him to expand them into a short book, an idea he initially considered unpromising before coming around to it.

Rovelli emphasizes that the book is not a condensed summary of contemporary physics but a personal take on how he views general relativity, quantum theory, and related topics, presented differently from how they are usually taught.

What would an eighth lesson in the book cover?

Rovelli says a hypothetical eighth lesson would address the brain, but he adds that he would need to study the subject for another century before being able to write it.

What does Rovelli think about supersymmetry?

Rovelli was told at age 30 that supersymmetry would certainly be observed very soon. Now 60, he says he has heard that same prediction for three decades without confirmation.

He concludes that it is time to mostly give up on the expectation that supersymmetry will soon be found.

Is it time to give up on a single universe?

Rovelli says no. He respects multiverse speculations but has not seen a single reasonable idea for how to actually test them empirically, and without empirical testing, he maintains, a proposal is not doing science.

He allows that testable proposals might eventually emerge, but says that for now physics remains confined to a single universe.

Are there indications that nature follows simple, unique laws?

Rovelli points to the discovery that the enormous complexity of physical phenomena largely follows simple laws that can be written down mathematically, as a strong indication favoring this view. He says physicists would change course if evidence emerged against expressing nature through simple laws, but states that no such evidence currently exists.

Three physics insights that could change how we understand the world

Rovelli names three insights he believes would make the greatest difference if widely assimilated: that there is no “time” in the fundamental description of the world, that “space” is not a container of things, and that there is nothing outside the natural world.

What future conceptual developments could matter most?

Rovelli says physics needs greater clarity about the physical notion of “information.” He attributes current confusion to the fact that the word carries many different meanings that get mixed together, and suggests that resolving this could move the field forward substantially.

Should falsifiability be adjusted given recent theoretical developments?

Rovelli argues against adjusting the criterion of falsifiability to accommodate theories that have not delivered results. He states that unfalsifiable theories should be discarded, and warns that a scientific theory should not become, in his words, a structure that delivers nothing but university positions.

Can string theory be criticized on methodological grounds?

Rovelli says string theory set clear objectives in the 1980s: computing the parameters of the standard model from first principles, explaining why there are three generations of particles, and describing what happens at the center of a black hole. He argues that if those objectives have not been met, it is time to say so rather than avoid the issue.

How does Rovelli feel about his 60th birthday celebration (“carlofest”)?

Rovelli says the celebration, a “carlofest” marking his 60th birthday, was meant to be a surprise, though he learned of it anyway. He admits that although he once thought he would never want such an event, he now finds himself happy to see people attend and express affection, and jokes that younger physicists may privately hold the same reservations about him that he once held about honorees.

What are Rovelli’s interests outside physics?

Rovelli says he enjoys reading widely, particularly philosophy, neurobiology, anthropology, and classic novels, naming Joseph Conrad as a favorite author.

Who were Rovelli’s heroes growing up?

Rovelli names Allen Ginsberg, Alexander the Great, Spinoza, and Che Guevara as his childhood heroes, explaining that he admired them because each thought the opposite of what the people around them were thinking.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Carlo Rovelli think about supersymmetry being discovered soon?

Rovelli says that for 30 years, since he was told at age 30 that supersymmetry would certainly be seen very soon, that same prediction has gone unfulfilled. At 60, he believes it is time to mostly give up on the expectation of an imminent discovery.

Does Rovelli support multiverse theories?

Rovelli respects multiverse speculations but says he has not seen a single reasonable idea for testing them empirically. He states that without empirical testing, such proposals are not science, though testable approaches might emerge in the future.

What is Seven Brief Lessons on Physics about?

According to Rovelli, the book is a personal take on general relativity, quantum theory, and related topics, grown from three newspaper articles, rather than a condensed summary of contemporary physics as it is often advertised to be.

What objectives did string theory originally set for itself?

Rovelli says string theory set clear aims in the 1980s: computing the standard model’s parameters from first principles, explaining why there are three generations of particles, and describing what happens at the center of a black hole.

What three insights does Rovelli consider most important for understanding the world?

Rovelli names the absence of “time” in the fundamental description of the world, the idea that “space” is not a container of things, and the view that there is nothing outside the natural world.

What does Rovelli say about adjusting the criterion of falsifiability?

Rovelli argues that falsifiability should not be adjusted to accommodate theories that fail to deliver results, and that unfalsifiable theories should be discarded rather than defended.

Glossary

  • Quantum gravity: the theoretical effort to reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity.
  • Planck length: the scale of ##10^{-33}## centimetres that Rovelli identifies as central to the problem of quantum gravity.
  • Supersymmetry: a proposed symmetry between particles of different spin, discussed here as a long-predicted but unconfirmed discovery.
  • Multiverse: the speculative idea of multiple universes, described by Rovelli as currently untestable.
  • Falsifiability: the criterion that a scientific theory must be capable of being proven false through empirical test.

Further reading

To learn more about Carlo Rovelli, visit his personal webpage or his Wikipedia entry. His book is available on Amazon.

Read another interview with theoretical physicist Sabine Hossenfelder.

Greg Bernhardt
Greg Bernhardt

I have a BS in Information Sciences from UW-Milwaukee. I’ve helped manage Physics Forums for over 22 years. I enjoy learning and discussing new scientific developments. STEM communication and policy are big interests as well. Currently a Sr. SEO Specialist at Shopify and writer at importsem.com

More Related Articles

  • Interview with Physics Mentor: Stevendaryl
  • Interview with a Chemist: Borek
  • Interview with Physics Mentor bhobba
  • Interview with Physicist Dale
  • Interview with a Physics Mentor: Nugatory
  • Interview with a Physicist: ZapperZ
Tags: General, interview, Physicist
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/carlo.png 135 240 Greg Bernhardt https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Physics_Forums_Insights_logo.png Greg Bernhardt2016-03-21 14:13:402026-11-08 09:21:42Carlo Rovelli Interview: Supersymmetry, Multiverse, Time
You might also like
CrispR DNA Why CRISPR Technologies Won’t Lead to Designer Babies
matterphoton Will All Matter Be Converted to Photons?
supernova Star Death Explained: White Dwarfs to Black Holes
coldquestioning How to Ask Questions Effectively and Avoid Cold Questions
medical physics How to Become a Medical Physicist in 3653 Easy Steps
android rooting Android Rooting & Magisk Guide: Systemless Root Tips
6 replies
  1. fuzzyfelt
    fuzzyfelt says:
    May 20, 2016 at 7:44 am

    Great interview and beautiful book!

    Log in to Reply
  2. marcus
    marcus says:
    March 25, 2016 at 6:03 pm

    I guess I should give the link:http://www.amazon.com/Seven-Brief-Lessons-Physics-Rovelli/dp/0399184414/ref=zg_bs_13449_1I wonder if any of Hawking's books, or Kaku's ever placed that high.

    Log in to Reply
  3. marcus
    marcus says:
    March 25, 2016 at 5:52 pm

    Just now I checked to the Amazon page for Rovelli's book. it www #9 among all the books Amazon sells:==quote==Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #9 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)#1 in Books > Science & Math > Physics#1 in Books > Science & Math > Astronomy & Space Science > Cosmology#1 in Books > Textbooks > Science & Mathematics > Physics==endquote==I've never seen a physics book rank that high. It's phenomenal! Surely some congratulations are in order.  Great going Carlo!

    Log in to Reply
  4. DiracPool
    DiracPool says:
    March 25, 2016 at 1:19 pm

    Happy Birthday!

    Log in to Reply
  5. marcus
    marcus says:
    March 24, 2016 at 11:07 pm

    Great interview!Thanks, Greg. It goes right to the heart of things I think Rovelli cares about and gives a sense of what he's like. You get a good idea of his views on some of the foremost issues facing science (in particular, physics) today.

    Log in to Reply
  6. isocliff
    isocliff says:
    March 22, 2016 at 10:21 am

    What a complete waste. Don't you have any desire to ask him about, I don't know, his own ideas? Or any kind of substantive question at all, instead of just his competitors?I don't understand the desire to keep waging this battle against string theory, supersymmetry and every other idea other than what Rovelli works on. Surely nobody is illuminated by the entirely negative message, let alone convinced. Surely nobody is laboring under the misimpression that Rovelli's approaches have been any more successful at making unique predictions or being experimentally observed than his competitors – quite the opposite if anything.One is left with the impression that Rovelli's thoughts on physics are defined by what he is against rather than for, though I'm sure that has much to do with the terrible job by the interviewer. One also gets the impression the interviewer hasn't heard of anything interesting happening in theoretical physics over the past decade besides arguments about string wars and multiverses. I'm sorry if that's the case.

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Popular Articles

  • The Block Universe – Refuting a Common Argument
  • The Birth of a Physics Textbook: An Author’s Journey
  • Emergence From the Superpoint
  • Lenses and Pinholes: What Does “In Focus” Mean?
  • I Know the Math Says so, but Is It Really True?
  • Interview with Mentor Evo
  • Introduction to Evolution: Key Concepts & FAQs Guide
  • Beginner Telescope Buying Guide: Dobsonians, Binoculars & More
  • Why Uranus Spins on Its Side: Tilt, Theories, Models
  • Learn All About Earth’s Gravity

Physics Forums

  • Classical Physics
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
  • Quantum Physics
  • Special and General Relativity
  • Beyond the Standard Model
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Cosmology
  • Other Physics Topics

Receive Insights Articles to Your Inbox

Enter your email address:

Blog Information

  • Become a Member!
  • Write for Us!
  • Table of Contents
  • Blog Author List

Popular Topics

black holes (23) classical physics (35) education (23) FAQ (58) General (230) general relativity (23) Graduate (186) gravity (25) Guide (86) interview (49) mathematics (39) mathematics self-study (21) Physicist (27) Quantum Field Theory (34) quantum mechanics (38) quantum physics (24) relativity (40) Special Relativity (22) Tutorial (147) Undergraduate (288)
2026 © Physics Forums, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - Contact Us - Privacy Policy - About PF Insights
  • Link to X
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to LinkedIn
Link to: PF Insights Scavenger Hunt Link to: PF Insights Scavenger Hunt PF Insights Scavenger Huntscavengerhunt Link to: Intro to AC Power Analysis: Learn System Basics Link to: Intro to AC Power Analysis: Learn System Basics acpoweranalysisp1Intro to AC Power Analysis: Learn System Basics
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top