Sean Carroll Interview: Career, Physics, and The Big Picture
Theoretical physicist Sean Carroll, a research professor at Caltech working on the foundations of quantum mechanics and the evolution of entropy, discusses his career path from astronomy to cosmology, his book The Big Picture on naturalism, his estimate of roughly a 30% chance of discovering supersymmetry (SUSY) within five years, and his view that gravitational wave detection opens new tests of general relativity.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Sean Carroll studied astronomy as an undergraduate at Villanova University before shifting to physics, completing graduate work in astronomy at Harvard University.
- He collaborated with Bill Press and Ed Turner on a major review of the cosmological constant, positioning him to work on cosmic acceleration after its 1998 discovery by classmates Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess.
- After being denied tenure at the University of Chicago, Carroll moved to Caltech, where he is now a research professor focused on quantum mechanics foundations and entropy.
- Carroll estimated roughly 60% odds before the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) turned on that it would find supersymmetry (SUSY), a figure he has since revised down to about 30% for the following five years.
- He puts a roughly 50% chance on direct dark matter detection within ten years and about 10% on detecting primordial gravitational waves in the cosmic microwave background within the same timeframe.
Who is Sean Carroll?
Sean Carroll is a theoretical physicist at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech) specializing in cosmology and quantum mechanics. He grew up in the suburbs outside Philadelphia, attended public schools, and studied at Villanova University as an astronomy major.
Carroll realized that his real interests, including black holes, particle physics, and cosmology, were more aligned with physics than astronomy, so he applied only to physics graduate programs. He was not admitted to Princeton or Harvard University’s physics program, but he transferred his application to astronomy at Harvard at the last minute, which is why he holds no formal physics degrees despite being a professional physicist.
Graduate work, early research, and postdocs
At Harvard, Carroll worked with George Field, Alan Guth, and others on a broad mix of topics. During a postdoc at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), he explored violations of Lorentz invariance, dynamical triangulations, supergravity, topological defects, and closed timelike curves, among other subjects.
During a second postdoc at the Institute for Theoretical Physics (ITP) in Santa Barbara in the early 1990s, Carroll concluded that this kind of broad, unfocused exploration would not sustain a long-term career in physics, prompting him to search for topics combining personal interest with wider scientific relevance.
In 1998, astronomers discovered that the expansion of the universe was accelerating. Two of the discoverers, Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess, had been Carroll’s classmates at Harvard, and Carroll had already collaborated with Bill Press and Ed Turner on a major review of the cosmological constant, which positioned him well to study cosmic acceleration.
Faculty positions and current research
Carroll wrote papers on quintessence, modified gravity, and interactions in the dark sector while obtaining a faculty position at the University of Chicago, where he published several highly cited papers on dark energy and modified gravity in collaboration with Mark Trodden and others.
That body of work was not enough to secure tenure at Chicago, for reasons Carroll says remain mysterious to him. He then moved to Caltech, where he is now a research professor, and has narrowed his focus to two areas: the foundations of quantum mechanics, particularly how space and time might emerge from the wave function of the universe, and the evolution of entropy and complex structures over time.
What is Sean Carroll’s book The Big Picture about?
In The Big Picture, Carroll argues that there is one natural world accessible to science, and that this conclusion should not cause existential despair. He calls this viewpoint “naturalism,” the idea that questions currently considered mysterious, such as the origin of the universe, the origin of life, and the nature of consciousness, are in principle answerable through scientific investigation. The book surveys several areas of science to show how they fit together and why none of these problems need remain unsolvable.
Balancing technicality and accessibility
Writing for a general audience requires choosing an audience, in Carroll’s case readers willing to engage with difficult ideas but without technical or mathematical background. He selects what is genuinely worth explaining and aims for honesty about those points. With particle physics, for example, it is tempting to list every particle and force, but details that do not support the book’s broader argument are cut to avoid distraction.
Why is the Higgs book called The Particle at the End of the Universe?
The title of Carroll’s Higgs book, The Particle at the End of the Universe, emphasizes that the Higgs boson was the final piece of the Standard Model of particle physics. No physical particle sits at a literal end of the universe; conceptually, the Higgs represented the completion of the Standard Model and the start of a new era of questions in particle physics.
How does Sean Carroll approach science communication?
Responsibility to the public
Carroll holds that the scientific field as a whole bears responsibility for communicating with the public, though he does not believe every individual scientist must engage in outreach. He finds the work personally enjoyable and rewarding: explaining scientific discoveries helps him understand topics more deeply while sharing that excitement with a wide audience.
How blogging shaped his approach
Blogging is one part of a diverse ecosystem of science communication that also includes television, magazines, websites, Twitter, podcasts, and books. Carroll describes blogging as personal, capable of some depth, and offering immediate feedback: readers quickly call out claims made without genuine understanding, which forces clarity and accuracy in his writing.
What does Sean Carroll predict for future physics discoveries?
Supersymmetry (SUSY)
Before the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) turned on, Carroll gave roughly 60% odds that it would find supersymmetry (SUSY), a prediction made on his blog, Preposterous Universe. The LHC has run at somewhat lower energies than originally expected and, as of Carroll’s comments, had shown no credible sign of SUSY.
Carroll now estimates roughly a 30% chance of discovering SUSY within the following five years from when he made the comment. He notes it is possible SUSY exists but is broken at an energy scale too high for the LHC to reach, and he says he would not be surprised by either outcome.
Gravitational waves
Carroll regards the direct detection of gravitational waves as a major development, noting that while their existence was already known indirectly, dedicated detectors now give researchers a new tool to investigate the universe in detail. He expects this to be a substantial boon for astronomy and says it could even allow tests of general relativity in the strong-field regime near black hole horizons, potentially revealing deviations from standard general relativity (GR).
Next big discoveries
With the Higgs boson and gravitational waves now confirmed, Carroll identifies two remaining major goals: directly detecting dark matter, and detecting primordial gravitational waves in the cosmic microwave background. He places roughly a 50% chance on direct dark matter detection within ten years and about 10% on detecting primordial gravitational waves in the same timeframe, noting that many inflationary models predict amplitudes too small to observe easily.
Personal life and favorites
| Category | Favorites |
|---|---|
| Hobbies | Food, reading, playing poker |
| Movies | Casablanca, Brazil, Memento |
| Books | Pride and Prejudice; Gravity’s Rainbow; The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress |
| Places | Paris, Vietnam, Florence, Las Vegas |
On heroes and goals
Carroll says he was not a hero-worshipping child. He admired many people for their accomplishments, especially in science, from Galileo to Stephen Hawking, but he believed one could accomplish great things regardless of a person’s private character, so he found it unwise to elevate individuals to hero status.
His stated main goal is simple: keep having a good time, keep learning interesting things about the universe, and spread the excitement of science. He frames it as being about the journey rather than any particular destination, though he adds that he would love to write a paper that significantly improves understanding of the universe, for example by reconciling quantum mechanics and gravity, or explaining the origin of life.
Thanks for participating, Sean Carroll! To learn more, visit his website Preposterous Universe and look for his books on Amazon: The Big Picture and Particle at the End of the Universe.
Read the next interview with physicist Clifford V. Johnson.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Sean Carroll research?
Sean Carroll focuses on two main areas at Caltech: the foundations of quantum mechanics, especially how space and time might emerge from the wave function of the universe, and the evolution of entropy and complex structures over time. He previously published highly cited work on dark energy and modified gravity.
What is naturalism according to Sean Carroll?
Naturalism, as Carroll presents it in The Big Picture, is the view that there is one natural world accessible to science, and that questions like the origin of the universe, the origin of life, and the nature of consciousness are in principle answerable through scientific investigation rather than being permanently mysterious.
Does Sean Carroll think the LHC will find supersymmetry?
Carroll estimates roughly a 30% chance of discovering supersymmetry (SUSY) in the five years following his comment, down from his earlier 60% estimate before the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) turned on. He notes SUSY could exist but be broken at an energy scale beyond the LHC’s reach.
Why does Sean Carroll think gravitational wave detection matters?
Carroll views direct gravitational wave detection as a major development because it gives astronomers a new observational tool, with potential to test general relativity in the strong-field regime near black hole horizons, where deviations from standard GR might appear.
I have a BS in Information Sciences from UW-Milwaukee. I’ve helped manage Physics Forums for over 22 years. I enjoy learning and discussing new scientific developments. STEM communication and policy are big interests as well. Currently a Sr. SEO Specialist at Shopify and writer at importsem.com








The UNBELIEVABLE similarities between Sean Carroll’s idea (2016) (California Institute of Technology, USA) (within the wrong framework, the “universe”) and my ideas (2002-2010) (within the EDWs framework) on quantum mechanics, the relationship between Einstein relativity and quantum mechanics, life, the mind-brain problem, etc. athttps://plus.google.com/u/0/+GabrielVacariuhttp://philpapers.org/rec/VACTUS-5https://www.academia.edu/29578814/The_UNBELIEVABLE_similarities_between_Sean_Carrolls_idea_2016_California_Institute_of_Technology_USA_or_Frank_Wilczecks_ideas_2016_Nobel_Prize_on_Physics_and_my_ideas_2002-2010
Great interview!
Just started reading The Big Picture last night. As a naturalist, I’ve been looking forward to it for some time. Worth the wait!
THE Sean Carroll? Awesome!
This is a great interview! I’ve learned a lot by Sean Carroll’s books and papers and I’m keeping on doing so…
Thanks Sean!
I enjoyed this fairly recent lecture from Sean too
[MEDIA=youtube]1sA5esQmB04[/MEDIA]
Are you really able to make an argument that the laws of physics can explain consciousness?
I do believe it as a matter of faith, but would be hard pressed for a convincing argument.
Great interview!
I never knew he was a physicist without papers so he wrote his own. :-)
Great interview!Just started reading The Big Picture last night. As a naturalist, I've been looking forward to it for some time. Worth the wait!
THE Sean Carroll? Awesome!
Thanks Sean!I enjoyed this fairly recent lecture from Sean toohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sA5esQmB04