Physics Forums Insights
  • Physics
    • Mechanics
    • Thermodynamics
    • Electromagnetism
    • Fluids
    • Optics
    • Particles
    • Quantum
    • Relativity
    • Biophysics
  • Astronomy
    • Astrophysics
    • Cosmology
    • Observing
  • Mathematics
    • Algebra
    • Analysis
    • Geometry
    • Number Theory
    • Probability
  • Computing
    • Programming
    • Electronics
    • Imaging
  • Science Culture
    • Education
    • Careers
    • Philosophy
    • Profiles
    • Trivia
  • Forums
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
cliffordjohnson

Clifford V. Johnson: The Dialogues & Science Outreach

February 26, 2018/7 Comments/in Interviews, Profiles/by Greg Bernhardt
📖Read Time: 9 minutes
📊Readability: Moderate (Standard complexity)
🔖Core Topics: Johnsonphysicsblackholetheory

Clifford V. Johnson, a professor in the Physics and Astronomy Department at the University of Southern California (USC), works on superstring theory, gravity, gauge theory, and M-theory, and in this interview he discusses his career path, his approach to science communication, his graphic-novel physics book The Dialogues, and his ideas about black hole heat engines and planetary-mass black hole experiments.

Table of Contents

  • Key Takeaways
  • Background: how did Clifford Johnson get interested in physics?
  • What drew Clifford Johnson to theoretical physics specifically?
  • What are Clifford Johnson’s views on science communication?
  • How does Clifford Johnson see the roles of blogs versus social media?
  • How does Clifford Johnson balance technicality and public accessibility?
  • Why did Clifford Johnson choose a graphic format for The Dialogues?
  • How did Clifford Johnson create The Dialogues?
  • If a planetary-mass black hole existed in our solar system, what experiments would come first?
  • Can string theory be experimentally tested this century?
  • What is the current state of string theory, according to Clifford Johnson?
  • What are black hole heat engines, and why do they matter?
  • What recent projects or discoveries excite Clifford Johnson?
  • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Who is Clifford V. Johnson?
    • What is The Dialogues about?
    • What is a black hole heat engine?
    • Can string theory be tested experimentally?
    • What experiments would test a planetary-mass black hole in our solar system?
  • Glossary

Key Takeaways

  • Clifford V. Johnson is a physicist at USC who works on (super)string theory, gravity, gauge theory, and M-theory, and he runs the blog Asymptotia.
  • Johnson wrote and illustrated The Dialogues, a graphic-novel format exploration of physics, after first conceiving the idea in 1999.
  • Johnson cites a 2009 result by Kastor, Ray, and Traschen, in which allowing the cosmological constant to be dynamical introduces notions of pressure and volume into black hole thermodynamics.
  • Johnson argues that black hole heat engines, systems that do mechanical work while exchanging heat, could yield insights into quantum field theory because black hole physics can be dual to classes of quantum field theory.
  • Johnson says he taught himself to draw at a professional level for The Dialogues, describing drawing as a learnable skill rather than an innate talent.

Physicist Clifford V. JohnsonBackground: how did Clifford Johnson get interested in physics?

Clifford V. Johnson says he started the way he thinks everyone starts: by asking lots of questions about the world and finding ways to answer them, through experimenting, taking things apart and putting them back together, or reading. He got hooked on that process, and he says people mostly left him alone to pursue it, which he suspects was helped by being the youngest child in his family.

Johnson later learned there was a career built around asking questions and figuring out how things worked, and he set that as his goal as early as age 8 or 9. He recalls being surprised when a family friend asked what kind of scientist he wanted to be, since he did not know you had to choose a specialty. He remembers sitting with a dictionary and looking up every word ending in “-ist” and “-ologist” until he reached “physicist,” whose definition described it as the field underlying all the other scientific fields. Johnson says that definition felt like permission to keep his options open, since he loved, and still loves, all of science.

What drew Clifford Johnson to theoretical physics specifically?

Johnson says his interest in theoretical physics was again about keeping his options open. He loved, and still loves, experimental physics, but as he learned more about physics careers, he understood that one had to choose between experiment and theory. He chose theory because it allowed him to go as deep or as wide as he wanted.

What are Clifford Johnson’s views on science communication?

Johnson objects to science being treated as separate from the rest of culture, often presented as something done by unusual, socially awkward super-geniuses. He says that framing puts people off, and he notes that many scientists secretly enjoy the myth of being super geniuses and do nothing to dispel it.

Johnson’s main effort is to present science as something all kinds of people can contribute to, since he believes science belongs to everyone. He says he hopes his book The Dialogues shows this, and that the same philosophy shows up in his behind-the-scenes work as a science advisor in the entertainment industry, where he tries to encourage filmmakers to portray a wider variety of people doing science and to humanize scientists more generally.

Asymptotia blogHow does Clifford Johnson see the roles of blogs versus social media?

Johnson does not consider blogs a form of social media. He describes blogs as a place for actual content, such as long-form discussion, extended explanations, and reflections, while what is commonly called social media today mainly points to content elsewhere. In his view, social media is excellent for sharing the location of content, while blogs are where an idea can be expanded.

Johnson says these platforms can work together: direct access to people producing scientific results, complemented by social channels that amplify and guide readers to that content.

How does Clifford Johnson balance technicality and public accessibility?

Johnson politely rejects the notion that physics is more technical or specialized than other subjects the public can learn about if interested, such as music, architecture, law, medicine, politics, or art. He identifies the mistaken belief that you need a special kind of brain for physics as a major barrier to public engagement.

Johnson says the key is to be empathetic and help people find a door into the subject that suits them, since not everyone can use the same door, nor should they. He notes that editors often insist every physics book restart from scratch, which leads to many physics books repeating the same introductory chapters rather than building on each other.

Johnson expects readers to immerse themselves, sit with the book, and be active participants in their reading. He says that is why one of the most important features of The Dialogues is a set of notes for further reading at the end of each conversation. He explains that if he tried to unpack every concept within each conversation, every character would end up delivering a mini-lecture whenever they spoke, which would stop it from reading as a real conversation.

The Dialogues bookWhy did Clifford Johnson choose a graphic format for The Dialogues?

Clifford V. Johnson first had the idea for The Dialogues in 1999, prompted by what he felt was missing from standard prose physics books: the feeling of being part of a conversation rather than being lectured at. He wanted readers to see the people involved, the places where science happens, and what they were writing, to show that science can take place in cafes, on streets, buses, and trains. That drive toward inclusiveness led him to the graphic novel format, and he says he was surprised no one had really done it before.

Johnson had dabbled in doodling and sketching before, but to produce a full book he taught himself to draw at the level the project required. He drew extensively during this process. He describes drawing as not primarily about innate talent, but as a set of learnable skills that can be perfected through practice.

How did Clifford Johnson create The Dialogues?

Johnson used several different modes while creating The Dialogues. Sometimes he wrote dialogue on its own with little attention to the art, and other times he worked visually first, creating tiny thumbnail pages and then developing dialogue to fit the visuals. Most often, he says, it was a mix of both, with words, layout, settings, and design evolving in parallel so that they would support each other.

Throughout the project, Johnson was simultaneously learning drawing techniques and the overall process of making a graphic book, with writing, layout, and art informing each other continuously.

If a planetary-mass black hole existed in our solar system, what experiments would come first?

Clifford Johnson says the first step would be running precision versions of the classic tests of Einstein’s general relativity (GR), such as observing how the black hole bends light from distant objects and how objects orbit around it, in order to look for deviations that might point beyond relativity. He would then scatter specially prepared beams of known particles near the black hole and throw test masses into it to study their behavior. He says this close examination of strong gravity could reveal deviations from general relativity or show how strong gravity affects quantum mechanics.

Can string theory be experimentally tested this century?

Johnson says he does not know. He suggests that physicists might start seeing phenomena whose most elegant explanation comes from a string-theory-like context, but he stresses that this would be an early sign of a new framework rather than a definitive test. If forced to bet, he says it might occur in an astrophysical or cosmological scenario.

What is the current state of string theory, according to Clifford Johnson?

Johnson describes string theory as a framework of ideas with immense and expanding value, touching particle physics, nuclear physics, astrophysics, condensed matter physics, and more.

What are black hole heat engines, and why do they matter?

It is a remarkable and still mysterious fact that black holes, combined with quantum physics, appear to obey the laws of thermodynamics, which Johnson treats as an important clue. He points to a 2009 result from Kastor, Ray, and Traschen, in which allowing the cosmological constant to be dynamical introduces notions of pressure and volume into black hole thermodynamics, and with them the idea of mechanical work. Once pressure and volume enter the picture, the idea of a black hole heat engine, a system that does mechanical work while exchanging heat, becomes natural. Johnson notes that much of what was historically learned about thermodynamics came from thinking about engines, and that limits on efficiency provide lessons across physics and information theory. Because black hole physics can be dual to classes of quantum field theory (QFT), Johnson argues that formulating questions in terms of black hole heat engines may yield far-reaching insights.

What recent projects or discoveries excite Clifford Johnson?

Johnson names colliding black holes and neutron stars, along with the discoveries coming from LIGO and Virgo and the associated multi-messenger astronomy revolution, as the developments exciting him most. He expects this area of research to change a lot of things.

Thanks to Clifford V. Johnson for his time. His book The Dialogues is available for purchase.

Read the next interview with physicist Arnold Neumaier.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Clifford V. Johnson?

Clifford V. Johnson is a professor in the Physics and Astronomy Department at USC who works on superstring theory, gravity, gauge theory, and M-theory. He runs the blog Asymptotia and wrote and illustrated the graphic-novel physics book The Dialogues.

What is The Dialogues about?

The Dialogues is a graphic-novel format book in which Clifford Johnson presents physics through conversations between characters, set in places like cafes, streets, buses, and trains, rather than through standard textbook prose.

What is a black hole heat engine?

A black hole heat engine is a system built from a black hole that does mechanical work while exchanging heat. This concept became natural once a 2009 result from Kastor, Ray, and Traschen introduced notions of pressure and volume into black hole thermodynamics by allowing the cosmological constant to be dynamical.

Can string theory be tested experimentally?

Clifford Johnson says he does not know whether string theory can be tested this century. He suggests physicists might observe phenomena best explained in a string-theory-like context, which would be an early sign of a new framework rather than a definitive test, possibly arising in an astrophysical or cosmological scenario.

What experiments would test a planetary-mass black hole in our solar system?

Johnson proposes starting with precision versions of classic general relativity tests, such as light bending and orbital behavior, followed by scattering known particle beams near the black hole and throwing test masses into it to study strong gravity and possible deviations from general relativity.

Glossary

  • General relativity (GR): Einstein’s theory of gravity, tested through phenomena such as light bending and orbital motion around massive objects.
  • Quantum field theory (QFT): A framework combining quantum mechanics and field theory, which Johnson notes can be dual to black hole physics.
  • Black hole heat engine: A system built from a black hole that does mechanical work while exchanging heat, made possible by treating the cosmological constant as dynamical.
  • M-theory: A theoretical framework unifying versions of string theory, one of Johnson’s areas of research.
Greg Bernhardt
Greg Bernhardt

I have a BS in Information Sciences from UW-Milwaukee. I’ve helped manage Physics Forums for over 22 years. I enjoy learning and discussing new scientific developments. STEM communication and policy are big interests as well. Currently a Sr. SEO Specialist at Shopify and writer at importsem.com

More Related Articles

  • Interview with Physicist George Jones
  • Interview with Mathematician Fresh_42
  • Roger Babson’s Anti-Gravity Contest and Modern Physics
  • Interview with a Physics Mentor: PeterDonis
  • Interview with a Physics Mentor: Nugatory
  • Interview with a Physicist: Doc Al
Tags: General, interview, Physicist, science outreach, string theory
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/cliffordjohnson.png 135 240 Greg Bernhardt https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Physics_Forums_Insights_logo.png Greg Bernhardt2018-02-26 16:42:172026-11-08 09:07:34Clifford V. Johnson: The Dialogues & Science Outreach
You might also like
selfstudy Why Math Self-Study Projects Fail (And How to Avoid It)
learnfrompf The Most Important Thing You Can Learn from Physics Forums
Milli-Ohm The Poor Man’s Milli-Ohm Meter
solar_eclipse Solar Eclipse Viewing & Safety Guide: What to Expect
Camera Lens Physics Evaluate Camera Lens Performance Using an LCD Display
10mathtips Exam Tips & Test Strategies: Practical Study Techniques
7 replies
  1. Greg Bernhardt
    Greg Bernhardt says:
    March 9, 2018 at 4:39 pm

    Clifford V. Johnson Named as Recipient of the 2018 Klopsteg Memorial Lecture Award
    http://www.aapt.org/aboutaapt/Clifford-Johnson-2018-Klopsteg.cfm

    Log in to Reply
  2. Greg Bernhardt
    Greg Bernhardt says:
    March 6, 2018 at 7:02 pm

    If you're near LA you can meet him and get your book signed!
    http://lastbookstorela.com/events/dialogues-clifford-johnson-aimee-bender-discussion/

    Log in to Reply
  3. berkeman
    berkeman says:
    March 3, 2018 at 5:16 pm
    Greg Bernhardt

    The read is definitely accessible but I wouldn't say quick.Some parts quick. Others, not so much… :biggrin:

    Log in to Reply
  4. Greg Bernhardt
    Greg Bernhardt says:
    March 3, 2018 at 5:12 pm

    The read is definitely accessible but I wouldn't say quick. There is a lot to digest and packed with value!

    Log in to Reply
  5. berkeman
    berkeman says:
    March 3, 2018 at 5:03 pm
    Greg Bernhardt

    he production is really really impressive.I agree. I bought the book and it came in the mail yesterday. It's a very unique book, and I'm having fun reading it so far.

    One part I really like is at the end of each chapter, he's included comments and references about some of the things that have been covered in the dialogs in that chapter. That includes references at various levels, from popular literature to peer-reviewed journal articles. Good stuff. :smile:

    View attachment 221381
    View attachment 221382

    Log in to Reply
  6. Greg Bernhardt
    Greg Bernhardt says:
    March 3, 2018 at 3:34 pm

    Just got 3 more books yesterday! The production is really really impressive. I'll have more contests for them later next week. You're going to want it!

    Log in to Reply
  7. Greg Bernhardt
    Greg Bernhardt says:
    February 28, 2018 at 2:01 pm

    Two of his books are being used as prizes for this new contest!
    https://www.physicsforums.com/threa…-book-giveaway-who-wants-it-n95-straw.940872/

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Popular Articles

  • The Block Universe – Refuting a Common Argument
  • The Birth of a Physics Textbook: An Author’s Journey
  • Emergence From the Superpoint
  • Lenses and Pinholes: What Does “In Focus” Mean?
  • I Know the Math Says so, but Is It Really True?
  • Interview with Mentor Evo
  • Introduction to Evolution: Key Concepts & FAQs Guide
  • Beginner Telescope Buying Guide: Dobsonians, Binoculars & More
  • Why Uranus Spins on Its Side: Tilt, Theories, Models
  • Learn All About Earth’s Gravity

Physics Forums

  • Classical Physics
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
  • Quantum Physics
  • Special and General Relativity
  • Beyond the Standard Model
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Cosmology
  • Other Physics Topics

Receive Insights Articles to Your Inbox

Enter your email address:

Blog Information

  • Become a Member!
  • Write for Us!
  • Table of Contents
  • Blog Author List

Popular Topics

black holes (23) classical physics (35) education (23) FAQ (58) General (230) general relativity (23) Graduate (186) gravity (25) Guide (86) interview (49) mathematics (39) mathematics self-study (21) Physicist (27) Quantum Field Theory (34) quantum mechanics (38) quantum physics (24) relativity (40) Special Relativity (22) Tutorial (147) Undergraduate (288)
2026 © Physics Forums, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - Contact Us - Privacy Policy - About PF Insights
  • Link to X
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to LinkedIn
Link to: Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Definitions Link to: Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Definitions Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Definitionshilbertspaces Link to: Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Operators Link to: Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Operators hilbertspaces2Learn the Basics of Hilbert Spaces and Their Relatives: Operators
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top