Entries by ZapperZ

Addressing the “Classical Physics Is Wrong” Fallacy

Introduction One of the common questions or comments we get on PF is the claim that classical physics or classical mechanics (i.e. Newton’s laws, etc.) is wrong because it has been superseded by Special Relativity (SR) and General Relativity (GR), and/or Quantum Mechanics (QM). Such claims are typically made by either a student who barely…

How to Ask Questions Effectively and Avoid Cold Questions

Common Questions We Receive We frequently get questions such as these: “What is energy?” “What are Cooper Pairs?” “What is conservation of momentum?” etc…etc. Why Context Matters And the persons who asked such questions didn’t bother to explain the context of the question, what exactly did he/she wanted to know, and didn’t reveal the level…

Spotting Fake Science News: Wendelstein 7‑X & Media

Fake News, Data, and the Need to Check Sources During and even after the recent US election campaign, numerous reports of fake or misleading news were circulated: outright fabrications, inaccurate summaries, and incomplete reporting designed to push one point of view or another. Outright fabricated stories are often exposed eventually, but subtler misreports — especially…

Why Quantum Mechanics Feels Difficult — Mathematical Bridge

[CONTENT] QM’s formalism Overview of the formalism Strangely enough, quantum mechanics (QM)’s formalism isn’t any more difficult than other areas of physics. The mathematics of the “standard” QM isn’t any worse than, for example, electromagnetism. Yet to many people—especially non-physicists—QM presents a daunting effort to understand. Why QM often feels difficult I strongly believe this…

So I Am Your Intro Physics Instructor

I posted this elsewhere (on my blog), and someone mentioned that maybe it might also be useful here on PF. So I’m reproducing the entire entry here in case it might make a difference. This is essentially a “sequel” to my earlier essay on “So I am Your Academic Advisor“. My aim in writing this…

Have Scientists Seen an Electron? How We Detect Them

Have Scientists Seen an Electron? Why Seeing Isn’t Enough This article is not about literally seeing a single electron with your eye; it addresses the broader—and common—belief that direct visual perception is the only valid form of evidence. I will show that the human eye, as a light detector, is NOT a reliable detector in…

Do Photons Move Slower in a Solid Medium?

Scope and context This question appears often because it has been shown that in a normal, dispersive solid such as glass, the speed of light is slower than it is in a vacuum. This FAQ will strictly deal with that scenario only and will not address light transport in anomalous medium, atomic vapor, metals, etc.,…

Why Is Acceleration Due to Gravity a Constant?

This question has popped up many times. So here is an attempt to address it. To answer this question at the elementary level, several assumptions will be made, which will become obvious later on. Still, at this point, we will simply deal with objects with spherical symmetry and no complicated mass distribution. In other words,…

“Violating” Einstein’s Photoelectric Effect Model

Einstein’s Photoelectric Insight One of the most spectacular theoretical descriptions that Einstein had ever produced is the corpuscular nature of light that he used in his 1905 photoelectric effect paper. In fact, there have been arguments put forth that of all of his 1905 papers, the one proposing this model for light is what is…

Do Photons have Mass?

Do photons have mass? The quick answer: NO Common source of confusion However, this is where it gets a bit confusing for most people. This is because, in physics, there are several ways to define and measure a quantity that we call “mass”. Now, it doesn’t create any confusion among physicists because we tend to…

Why You Can’t Quantum Tunnel Through a Wall

Can You Quantum Tunnel Through a Wall? Short answer The short and sweet answer if a tennis ball, a bowling ball, or any other kind of ordinary macroscopic object can tunnel through a wall is NO. You can’t quantum tunnel through a wall. Why people ask We periodically get questions on PF about people wanting…

Postdoctoral Positions: How to Succeed as a Physicist

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Physics PhD Job Search: Start Well Before Graduation

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Writing Your Doctoral Thesis: Guide for Physics Grad

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

How to Publish in a Physics Journal (Addendum)

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

How to Publish Your PhD Research in Physics Journals

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Careers with a Physics Degree: Alternatives & Advice

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Understanding the US Physics Graduate School System

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Physics Graduate Assistantships: TA vs RA Explained

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Physics Grad School: Senior-Year Application Guide

Full Chapter List – So You Want To Be A Physicist… Series Part I: Early Physics Education in High schools Part II: Surviving the First Year of College Part III: Mathematical Preparations Part IV: The Life of a Physics Major Part V: Applying for Graduate School Part VI: What to Expect from Graduate School Before…

Essential Guide: Surviving Your First Year in Physics

Part II: Surviving the First Year of College This part covers survival tips for the first two undergraduate years. You’re now in college and intend to be a physics major — though much of the advice here applies to anyone taking physics classes, not just physics majors. Advising and the calculus sequence In most U.S….