
Inside the Scientific Box: History and Challenges Today
/
1 Comment
In Memoriam
In Memory of Dr. Thomas J. LeCompte (1964-2025), Detector Designer and Champion of Education and Science.
Prologue
Defining "the box"
Someone…

Why Entangled Photon-Polarization Qubits Violate Bell’s Inequality per Quantum Information Theory
In her YouTube video Bell's Theorem Experiments on Entangled Photons, Dr. Fugate shows how polarization-entangled photons violate Bell's inequality. In…

Relativator (Circular Slide-Rule) – Simulated with Desmos
The Relativator (revisited)
This is an update of my 2006 post (reconstructed in 2014) Relativator: The circular slide-rule for physicists.
This is a…

What Exactly is Dirac’s Delta Function?
Introduction: "Convenient Notation"In Dirac's Principles of Quantum Mechanics published in 1930 he introduced a "convenient notation" he referred …

Quantum Entanglement is a Kinematic Fact, not a Dynamical Effect
Towards the end of the first lecture for the Qiskit Global Summer School 2025, Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Olivia Lanes (Global Lead, Content and…

Fixing Things Which Can Go Wrong With Complex Numbers
Abstract
This article will build on the hints about treating the complex numbers as a branched surface, briefly described and pictured in section 4.2…

Fermat’s Last Theorem
Abstract
Fermat's Last Theorem has long been one of the most famous mathematical problems, and is now one of the most famous theorems. It simply states…

Vector Spaces: Concepts, History, and Applications Guide
The Concept
A vector space is an additively written abelian group together with a field that operates on it.Intuitive picture vs abstract definition
Vector…

Why the Tidal Bulge Doesn’t Exist – Tidal Theory Explained
[CONTENT]
Introduction
Overview
That there is no tidal bulge is the key premise of this article. Upper-level oceanography undergraduates and above know…

The Many Faces of Topology
Abstract
Topology as a branch of mathematics is a bracket that encompasses many different parts of mathematics. It is sometimes even difficult to see…

Brownian Motions and Quantifying Randomness in Physical Systems
Stochastic calculus has come a long way since Robert Brown described the motion of pollen through a microscope in 1827. It's now a key player in data science,…

Quantum Reconstruction & Bell Correlations Explained
Comment on PBS Space Time video
PBS Space Time produces some very good videos on the foundations of quantum mechanics (QM), so let me comment on their…

Aspects Behind the Concept of Dimension in Various Fields
Abstract
It took until the last century for physicists and mathematicians in the Netherlands to question the Euclidean concept of dimension as length,…

Views On Complex Numbers
Abstract
Why do we need yet another article about complex numbers? This is a valid question and I have asked it myself. I could mention that I wanted…

Addition of Velocities (Velocity Composition) in Special Relativity
The "Addition of Velocities" formula (more correctly, the "Composition of Velocities" formula) in Special Relativity[tex]\frac{v_{AC}}{c}=\frac{ \frac{v_{AB}}{c}+\frac{v_{BC}}{c}…

Schrödinger’s Cat and the Qbit
The concept of quantum superposition (or superposition for short) is very counterintuitive, as Schr##\ddot{\text{o}}##dinger noted in 1935 writing [1],…

The Slinky Drop Experiment Analysed
The slinky drop is a rather simple experiment. In its most basic form, it requires only a popular toy for children, a stable hand, and a keen eye.…

Spatial Curvature in Cosmological Models
Standard cosmological models are classified by spatial curvature into three broad types: open, flat, and closed universes. These correspond to negative,…

The Lambert W Function in Finance
Preamble
The classical mathematician practically by instinct views the continuous process as the "real" process, and the discrete process as an approximation…

Why Division by Zero is a Bad Idea
A division by zero is primarily an algebraic question. The reasoning therefore follows the indirect pattern of most algebraic proofs:
What if it was allowed?
Then…

Series in Mathematics: From Zeno to Quantum Theory
Introduction
Series play a decisive role in many branches of mathematics. They accompanied mathematical developments from Zeno of Elea (##5##-th century…

Epsilontic – Limits and Continuity
Abstract
I remember that I had some difficulties moving from school mathematics to university mathematics. From what I read on PF through the years, I…

The Poor Man’s Milli-Ohm Meter
Introduction
In a previous article on measuring battery internal resistance, a simple technique for low-resistance measurement was outlined. In this article,…

Differential Equation Systems and Nature
Abstract
"Mathematics is the native language of nature." is a phrase that is often used when it comes to explaining why mathematics is all around in natural…

Beginners Guide to Precalculus, Calculus and Infinitesimals
Introduction
I am convinced students learn Calculus far too late. In my view, there has never been a good reason for this.In the US, they go through…

What Are Numbers?
Introduction
When doing mathematics, we usually take for granted what natural numbers, integers, and rationals are. They are pretty intuitive. Going…

Introduction to the World of Algebras
Abstract
Richard Pierce describes the intention of his book [2] about associative algebras as his attempt to prove that there is algebra after Galois…

Why ChatGPT Is Unreliable: Design Limits and Misconceptions
ChatGPT's reliability
I'll start with the simple fact: ChatGPT is not a reliable answerer to questions.
Wolfram's explanation
To try to explain why from…

How Quantum Information Theory Solves “the only mystery” of Quantum Mechanics
In Chapter 37 of "The Feynman Lectures on Physics Volume 1," Richard Feynman famously wrote that the mystery of wave-particle duality in the double-slit…

What Are Infinitesimals – Advanced Version
Introduction
When I learned calculus, the intuitive idea of infinitesimal was used. These are real numbers so small that, for all practical purposes (say…

Popular Science Communication: Bridging Science & Public
Abstract
Famous Science Communicators
There is so much to say about the many endeavors by professional scientists to explain to us the world. The list…

An Overview of Complex Differentiation and Integration
Abstract
I want to shed some light on complex analysis without getting all the technical details in the way which are necessary for the precise treatments…

When Lie Groups Became Physics
Abstract
We explain by simple examples (one-parameter Lie groups), partly in the original language, and along the historical papers of Sophus Lie, Abraham…

Why There Are Maximum Mass Limits for Compact Objects
In this article, we will look at why there are maximum mass limits for objects that are supported against gravity by degeneracy pressure instead of kinetic…

Oppenheimer-Snyder Model of Gravitational Collapse: Implications
Part 1: OverviewPart 2: Mathematical DetailsPart 3: ImplicationsIn the last article in this series, we finished up with a metric for the Oppenheimer-Snyder…

What Are Tensors and Why Are They Used in Relativity?
If you try learning general relativity, and sometimes special relativity, on your own, you will undoubtedly run into tensors. This article will outline…

Oppenheimer-Snyder Model of Gravitational Collapse: Mathematical Details
Part 1: OverviewPart 2: Mathematical DetailsPart 3: ImplicationsIn a previous article, I described in general terms the model of gravitational…

Twin Paradox Guide: Spacetime Geometry Explained Clearly
Introduction
This article is intended for anyone who wants to start a thread here at Physics Forums on the twin paradox. There are already many, many threads…

The Oppenheimer-Snyder Model of Gravitational Collapse: An Overview
Part 1: OverviewPart 2: Mathematical DetailsPart 3: ImplicationsMost people who have spent any time at all studying GR are familiar with the…

Mathematics Fields & Applications: A Structured Guide
Introduction
I often read questions about our classification scheme that we use on physicsforums.com to sort posts by science fields and subjects, what…

Counting to p-adic Calculus: All Number Systems That We Have
An entire book could easily be written about the history of numbers from ancient Babylon and India, over Abu Dscha'far Muhammad ibn Musa al-Chwarizmi (##\sim…

Évariste Galois and His Theory
* Oct. 25th, 1811 † May 31st, 1832
... or why squaring the circle is doomed.
Galois died in a duel at the age of twenty. Yet, he gave…

Yardsticks to Metric Tensor Fields
I asked myself why different scientists understand the same thing seemingly differently, especially the concept of a metric tensor. If we ask a topologist,…

P vs. NP and what is a Turing Machine (TM)?
P or NP
This article deals with the complexity of calculations and in particular the meaning of
##P\stackrel{?}{\neq}NP##
Before we explain what P and…

Quantum Computing Explained: Qubits, Algorithms & Applications
Overview
This article provides an accessible introduction to quantum computing, a cutting-edge technology that processes certain types of information…

A Physics Misconception with Gauss’ Law
Introduction
It is relatively common to see the following type of argument:
The surface area is ##A## and the enclosed charge is ##Q##. The electric…

How Can We Jump When the Ground Does No Work?
Common mistaken argument
It is relatively common on Physics Forums to see arguments that are effectively similar to the following:
When we jump off the…

The History and Importance of the Riemann Hypothesis
Riemann Hypothesis History
The Riemann Hypothesis is one of the most famous and long-standing unsolved problems in mathematics, specifically in the field…

Symmetry Arguments and the Infinite Wire with a Current
Many people reading this will be familiar with symmetry arguments related to the use of Gauss law. Finding the electric field around a spherically symmetric…

The Amazing Relationship Between Integration And Euler’s Number
We use integration to measure lengths, areas, or volumes. This is a geometrical interpretation, but we want to examine an analytical interpretation that…

Superdeterminism and the Mermin Device
Superdeterminism as a way to resolve the mystery of quantum entanglement is generally not taken seriously in the foundations community, as explained in…

Relativity on Rotated Graph Paper (a graphical motivation)
(based on https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/teaching-sr-without-simultaneity.1011051/post-6588952 and https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/689291/148184…

Probabilistic Factors Involved in Disease and Virus Testing
Introduction
This Insight looks at the various probabilistic factors and related terminology involved in disease and virus testing.As we all know,…

Quantum Physics via Quantum Tomography: A New Approach to Quantum Mechanics
This Insight article presents the main features of a conceptual foundation of quantum physics with the same characteristic features as classical physics…

How Quantum Information Theorists Revealed the Relativity Principle at the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics
This Insight is a condensed version of No Preferred Reference Frame at the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics. Reference numbers here correspond to that paper.…

Quantum Mechanics and the Famous Double-slit Experiment
Double-slit Key PointsQuantum mechanics is known for its strangeness, including phenomena like wave–particle duality, which allows particles to…

Safety Factors: Why Forums Avoid Design Advice Online
Forum Guidelines
There are often questions on Physics Forums related to building machines or structures that are left unanswered because of this guideline…

10 Math Things We All Learnt Wrong At School
Some of these could even lead to heavy debates within the scientific community, so maybe I should say: from my point of view. So before you get excited…

Tolman Law in a Nutshell
The Tolman law describes how the temperature in a fixed gravitational field depends on the position (see https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.04106 for a pedagogic…

Posterior Predictive Distributions in Bayesian Statistics
Confessions of a moderate Bayesian, part 4
Bayesian statistics by and for non-statisticiansRead part 1: How to Get Started with Bayesian StatisticsRead…

How Bayesian Inference Works in the Context of Science
Confessions of a moderate Bayesian part 3
Read part 1: How to Get Started with Bayesian Statistics
Read part 2: Frequentist Probability vs Bayesian ProbabilityBayesian…

Exploring Frequentist Probability vs Bayesian Probability
Confessions of a moderate Bayesian, part 2
Read Part 1: Confessions of a moderate Bayesian, part 1Bayesian statistics by and for non-statisticianshttps://www.cafepress.com/physicsforums.13280237
Background
One…

How to Get Started with Bayesian Statistics
Confessions of a moderate Bayesian, part 1
Bayesian statistics by and for non-statisticianshttps://www.cafepress.com/physicsforums.13265286
Background
I…

Electric Vector Potential: Detect Non-Conservative Fields
Main Point
The electric vector potential offers a means of determining the non-conservative component of a mixed stationary or quasi-stationary electric…

I Know the Math Says so, but Is It Really True?
I'm sure anyone who has hung out long enough here on Physics Forums has encountered threads that go something like this (I'll use an example based on threads…

Does the Block Universe of Physics Mean Time is an Illusion?
I have written many Insights (and coauthored an entire book) explaining how the puzzles, problems, and paradoxes of modern physics can be attributed to…

Introduction to Pitot-Static Systems in Gliders
Introduction
Like many others, I have been seeking new and fun things to do during a pandemic. I decided on the new Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020,…

Why Bother Teaching Mechanical Energy Conservation?
Note: It is assumed that the reader has read part I and part II of the series.
Earlier partsIs Mechanical Energy Conservation Free of Ambiguity?
…

Intro to Centrifugal Force Reversal in Kerr Spacetime
In this article, we will analyze "centrifugal force reversal" in Kerr spacetime, similar to what was done for Schwarzschild spacetime in a previous Insights…

A Principle Explanation of the “Mysteries” of Modern Physics
All undergraduate physics majors are shown how the counterintuitive aspects ("mysteries") of time dilation and length contraction in special relativity…

Exploring the Anatomy of Compton Scattering
Introduction
In this article, we take as our starting point the original equations which Compton drew up and solved in his ground-breaking 1925 article: From…

Learning the Twin Paradox for Freely-falling Observers
The "twin paradox" is often discussed in the introductory treatment of special relativity. Under "twin paradox" we understand the fact that if two twins…

Are Electromagnetic Waves Always Transverse? Full Explanation
In this insight, we will explore classical electrodynamics and examine whether electromagnetic (EM) waves are always transverse. We use Jefimenko's equations…

Is Pressure A Source Of Gravity?
In a previous series of articles, I posed the question "Does Gravity Gravitate?" and explained how, depending on how you interpreted the terms "gravity"…

Massive Meets Massless: Compton Scattering Revisited
Introduction
In a previous article entitled "Alternate Approach to 2D Collisions" we analyzed collisions between a moving and stationary object by defining…

How Non-Scientists Should Evaluate Scientific Claims
How should non-scientists evaluate scientists' public claims?
In a previous article, I discussed why scientists (among others) are rarely interested…

Dark Energy Part 3: Fitting the SCP Union 2.1 Supernova Data
In Part 1 of this 3-part series, I explained kinematics in Einstien-deSitter (EdS) cosmology and in Part 2, I explained kinematics in ##\Lambda##CDM cosmology…

Dark Energy Part 2: LCDM Cosmology
This is Part 2 of a 3-part series explaining evidence for so-called “dark energy” leading to a current positive cosmological acceleration. The evidence…

A Beginner Physics Guide to Baryon Particles
Baryon Introduction
At the beginning of the 20th century, it was thought that all matter consisted of only three particles: the electron, the neutron,…

Slowly Lowering an Object in a Static, Spherically Symmetric Spacetime
In the first two articles in this series, we looked at the Einstein Field Equation and Maxwell's Equations in a static, spherically symmetric spacetime.…

Supernova Refsdal: Multiply-Imaged Supernova Guide
Supernova (SN) Refsdal — Key PointsAstronomers have been trying to understand space for thousands of years.
Supernova Refsdal was the first known…

Dark Energy Part 1: Einstein-deSitter Cosmology
In this 3-part series, I want to motivate the (re)introduction of the cosmological constant ##\Lambda## into Einstein's equations of general relativity…

Cosmic Web Connectivity: How It Shapes Galaxy Evolution
Introduction
The universe was not perfectly uniform at the beginning; some regions had higher density than others.
Over time these higher-density regions…

Gaia Astrometry: Detecting Gravitational Waves Guide
Overview
Gravitational waves (GWs) are disturbances in spacetime produced by massive objects moving asymmetrically. Only the most massive and most relativistic…

Why Uranus Spins on Its Side: Tilt, Theories, Models
Uranus' Peculiar Tilt
Uranus spins on its side. It has an obliquity (tilt) of 98° — its rotation axis lies closer to the ecliptic plane than any other…

VHE Gamma Rays from Sgr A*: Black Holes and CTA Observations
Black Hole Key PointsBlack holes (BHs) have a gravitational pull so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape.
BHs can be divided into two…

Can We Do Better Than Mechanical Energy Conservation?
Note: It is assumed that the reader has read part I of the series.
Introduction
The ambiguity and flaws discussed in part I can be resolved using the…

Is Mechanical Energy Conservation Free of Ambiguity?
Introduction
"Close to any question that is in the textbook, there is another question that has never been answered that is interesting."
[Stephen Wolfram,…

Introduction to Evolution: Key Concepts & FAQs Guide
Introduction to Evolution
Overview
The study of evolution has dominated biology for over a century. Explaining why life is the way it is fascinates both…

Mary Somerville: Scottish Polymath & RAS Honorary Member
Mary Somerville & Caroline Herschel: Google DoodleGoogle Doodle: Mary Somerville and Caroline Herschel
The Google Doodle for 2 February 2020 celebrated…

Video Analysis of Spheres Falling Through Two Liquids
Introduction
Providing accurate fluid-dynamics experiments for undergraduate laboratories is challenging in several ways, including reproducibility, simplicity,…

Tell One Wood from Another: Basic Wood Anatomy
Introduction
About the author
As a long-time woodworker, I enjoy being able to tell one wood from another. In the process of learning how to do that,…

Learn the Fundamentals of the Diffraction Grating Spectrometer
Introduction
In this article, we will discuss the fundamentals of the diffraction grating spectrometer. The operation of the instrument is based upon…

Intro to the Ionization Energy of Atomic Hydrogen
Introduction
In previous articles relating to various transition energies in Hydrogen, Helium, and Deuterium we have employed the following formula for…

Answering Mermin’s Challenge with the Relativity Principle
Note: This Insight was previously titled, "Answering Mermin's Challenge with Wilczek's Challenge." While that version of this Insight did not involve any…

Exploring Bell States and Conservation of Spin Angular Momentum
In a recent thread, I outlined how to compute the correlation function for the Bell basis states\begin{equation}\begin{split}|\psi_-\rangle &=…

Modern Physics Understood as an Unrecognized Kuhnian Revolution
People often claim on Physics Forums and in the foundations community proper that quantum mechanics is "incomplete." Indeed, Lee Smolin recently wrote…

Relativistic Treatment of the DC Conducting Straight Wire
Introduction
The direct-current-conducting infinitely long wire is often discussed in the context of relativistic electrodynamics. It is of course a completely…

Revisiting The Deuterium Lyman Alpha Line Experiment
Introduction
In this article, we will be revisiting a somewhat understudied (and seemingly unrepeated) experiment to measure the Deuterium Lyman Alpha…

Signature of the Sun: Analyzing the Solar Balmer Series Lines
Introduction
We are in many ways a fortunate generation having so many wonderful tools at our disposal on account of the "silicon revolution". The advent…
